 |
|
|
Latest Michigan News & Editorials |
Note: Interviews on the miwatchdog are recorded over the telephone, edited, and then posted. None of the content has been taken out of context by editing or remixing. Please click here or on 'Feedback' to give us your comments and criticisms, or to make a suggestion for a possible guest interview on miwatchdog.com. Thank you! |
|
GRANHOLM MAKES FALSE STATEMENT, “GM HAS PAID BACK THE LOAN.”
posted 8.09.10
Governor Jennifer Granholm needs to get her facts straight. In an interview with Think Progress she stated, “You know, GM has paid back the loan.” She was talking about the $52 billon emergency loan from the federal government to GM. Her statement was only partial truth and is a text book definition of obfuscation (lying by omission). While it is true that GM has paid back $6.7 billion in cash to the federal government, the auto maker still owes the feds $43.5 billion. That money will not be paid back unless and until GM is able to make an IPO (initial public offering) to sell stock to the public as the new GM, the company that emerged from bankruptcy.
In April, GM made the mistake of running a nationwide advertising campaign featuring CEO Ed Whitacre Jr. claiming the company had paid back the loan in full. Whitacre’s exact statement was, “We have paid back our government loans in full – with interest – five years ahead of schedule.” That was only a half truth, and GM was justifiably criticized for its false claim. Common sense prevailed, and, to its credit, the company quickly shelved the ill-advised advertising campaign.
While the MIwatchdog is a strong advocate for GM, the fact is the company still owes 80 percent of the money it borrowed from the federal government. Statements aimed at shading the truth are a disservice, particularly when they emanate from the governor of Michigan or the CEO of General Motors.
AUTO COMPANIES GAIN BY RISING CHINESE CURRENCY
posted 6.23.10
The Chinese yuan, which for years has been artificially held back in value by the Chinese government, is on the rise. On Monday the yuan rose to its highest level in five years; and that’s great news for both GM and Ford, each with impressive shares of the Chinese automotive market. It means more revenue and more sales for the American car companies. In fact, for the first time in history China has outsold the United States in vehicle sales, and it’s highly unlikely that will ever change. China is literally and figuratively in the driver’s seat.
Here are some imposing economic developments:
-In 2009 China vehicle sales (12.7 million) surpassed the United States (10.4 million).
-In 2009 China auto sales increased by 44 percent.
-China’s economy is growing at a robust 9 to 10 percent a year.
-China’s population is 1.3 billion, largest in the world.
China has a huge emerging middle class that is purchasing new vehicles at a rapid rate. Both GM and Ford enjoy solid reputations in China, and the most popular nameplate is Buick. There will continue to pressure to raise the value of the yuan against the dollar as most experts believe it is still undervalued. The Obama administration said it was pleased with the Chinese government’s decision, but that it also wanted to wait and make sure China really follows through with the move.
BEST DOMESTIC AUTO QUALITY IN 24 YEARS
posted 6.18.10
Magnificent news! Domestic auto makers are doing more than closing the quality gap; they are winning in quality and reliability worldwide. According to J.D. Power and Associates, for the first time in history of their survey (24 years), Detroit’s Big Three, collectively, have outperformed their foreign rivals for initial quality. The study is based on problems experienced by car owners in the fist 90 days after they’ve purchased a vehicle.
Porsche lead the rankings, followed by Acura, Mercedes-Benz, Lexis, and Ford. Dearborn-based Ford scored high with the Focus, taking the number one ranking for compact car. Mustang is also ranked number one for midsize sporty vehicle, and Ford Taurus is the top-rated large car. Meantime GM had the top ranked vehicles for the following categories: Chevrolet Tahoe for large crossover/suv; Cadillac Escalade for large premium crossover/suv; and the Chevrolet Avalanche and GMC Sierra tied for top-ranked large pickup.
The story was much different for Toyota, which plummeted in quality rankings. In 2009 the Japanese automaker was ranked 6th for quality and reliability, but for 2010 Toyota is ranked 21st -- an amazing fall. Click here to see the highlights of the J.D. Power 2010 initial quality survey.
(sources: Mlive, J.D. Power)
OBAMA WANTS TOUGHER CAFE STANDARDS – AGAIN!
posted 05.21.10
The government first started to regulate fuel efficiency on U.S. car companies in 1975. The internal combustion engine has been a favorite target of environmentalists for years, and increasing CAFE standards has been an effective tool for pushing their agenda. Their environmental moral imperative ‘global warming’ makes carbon emissions from cars and trucks public enemy number one. Every time the federal government imposes higher CAFE standards the cost of producing vehicles to meet that standard increases substantially. A year ago President Obama and government bureaucrats negotiated/coerced U.S. automakers to a 35.5 m.p.g. standard by 2016. According to U.S. auto companies, the 35.5 standard will increase the cost of producing a new vehicle by $1500. Now President Obama is on a new push for tougher CAFÉ standards in 2017, which again will raise the cost of building cars and trucks for GM, Ford, and Chrysler. In addition, an Obama administration official says the President wants new tougher standards for medium and heavy duty vehicles produced from 2014 to 2018.
The U.S. government is actually protecting American car companies from even tougher standards. If California had its way, they would impose CAFE levels way beyond the U.S. standard, which would lead to the demise of the domestic auto industry. Having the President push an agenda which increases the cost of building and purchasing American cars and trucks is counterproductive on many levels. Ironic when one considers how much time and effort the administration has put into saving GM and Chrysler through the difficult bankruptcy process, and of course loaning the companies $80 billion. GM and Chrysler, though out of bankruptcy, still owe the federal government billions of dollars and are in no position to fight tougher CAFE standards. The price of gas is the biggest factor in fuel economy, and if Americans want to drive SUVs and pay the price to fill the tank, so be it. If environmentalists want to make a meaningful contribution to their cause, they should focus their time and attention on India and China, each with a population over 1 billion and an appalling record on pollution in all forms.
FIRST QUARTERLY PROFIT FOR GM SINCE 2007
posted 05.18.10
DETROIT -- GM has turned a major corner by posting its first quarterly profit in three years. For the first quarter of 2010 the automaker had a net profit of $865 million on $31.5 billion in revenue. That compares with a $6 billion loss on $22.4 billion in revenue for the 1st quarter of 2009. It is a dramatic turnaround by any measure, though the company has a long way to go. GM emerged from bankruptcy on July 10 of last year. To keep the company solvent the U.S. government gave General Motors $50 billion. Despite advertising claims GM still owes the U.S. Treasury $43.5 billion. On a historical basis, just being in the black after GM’s turmoil the last three years is a big deal. In 2008 General Motors lost a staggering $30.9 billion and a company record $38.7 billion in 2007, the worst two years in company history. Officially for 2009 the company lost $4.3 billion. Ultimately, in order to survive General Motors must have a successful initial public offering (IPO) of company stock, hoping Americans see enough value in GM to invest in the auto giant.
GM has been aided by increasing U.S. market sales, up 15.5 percent so far in 2010. But the company deserves credit for withstanding a firestorm of adversarial obstacles, albeit some which were self-inflicted. Most incriminating was failing to produce cars that effectively competed with foreign rivals Toyota, Honda, and Hyundai. Recently GM has been fighting back with winning vehicles like the Chevy Malibu and Buick Lacrosse. The new compact Chevy Cruz is hitting dealer showrooms now; it has been a huge hit in Australia and parts of Europe. It delivers an impressive 40 highway MPG. The soon-to-be-released Chevy Volt, the revolutionary extended range electric vehicle, could also help change the fortunes of the auto giant. The U.S. government, which on the one hand saved the company, also threatens GM with rising CAFE (Corporate Average Fuel Economy) requirements, which dramatically increases the cost of building new vehicles. But GM does have a second chance thanks to the federal government and American taxpayers. The first quarterly profit in three years is welcome news for all Michiganders.
(sources: Detroit Free Press, Detroit News, MIWatchDog)
APRIL AUTO SALES SKYROCKET
posted 05.04.10
Ford, General Motors, and even Chrysler posted substantial sales gains for the month of April. Bear in mind it was April last year that GM and Chrysler officially entered bankruptcy proceedings. But nonetheless, a gain is a gain. Chrysler’s sales spike of 25 percent was lead by the hot selling muscle car, Dodge Challenger. Ford and General Motors also fared very well, with sales up 24.7 and 20 percent, respectively. With the lone exception of the Mustang, which is being redesigned for 2011, Ford sales were up across the board very impressively. For GM in April, Buick was up 36.4 percent and Cadillac’s sales rose by 35.7 percent. That’s not to discount Chevy, which was up a healthy 17 percent and GMC, which was up 18 percent. The positive news on April American car sales and a hefty one-day increase in the stock market is no coincidence. On Monday, May 3rd, the market saw a nice run up of 143 points. The U.S. economy will not fully recover without a revival of the domestic auto industry. Michigan and the Big 3 will lead the nation in this economic recovery – unless the politicians get in the way.
GM PAYS PR PRICE FOR OBFUSCATION
posted 04.29.10
Detroit -- GM has drawn criticism for its claim of paying off its federal loan in full—five years ahead of schedule—to the federal government. The claim is a complete and total obfuscation (not admitting the truth by not disclosing the whole truth). In total GM borrowed $52 billion from the federal government. While it is a fact that the company has paid back its cash portion of the loan ($6.7 billion), GM however still owes the federal government a hefty $43.5 billion. That portion of the loan was converted to equity as part of the company’s bankruptcy restructuring. The $43.5 billion won’t be realized unless and until GM has an initial public offering for its stock. And that can’t happen unless GM’s turnaround plan is successful, and value in the company increases due to earnings -- which in turn inspires investors to purchase the stock. On a side note, having the stock gain value is crucial for the viability of the VEBA (or retiree health care trust), a central portion of the GM’s bankruptcy restructuring.
In a recent General Motors television ad, Whitacre claims, “We have paid back our government loans in full – with interest – five years ahead of the original schedule.” That has drawn the ire of many, including U.S. Senator Charles Grassley (R-Iowa), who is highly critical of the claim, “The hype does not match the reality. Taxpayers have not been repaid in full — far from it. ... Much of it will never be repaid.” The MIwatchDog, while a staunch supporter of GM, believes the ad is misleading and should be pulled immediately. As Senator Grassley asserts -- informed Americans understand GM is far from paying off its federal loan. Obfuscation of this sort will harm GM’s comeback, not embolden it, which apparently was the original intent. Since Whitacre is the CEO, presumably he OK’d or even perhaps brainstormed the ‘paid off in full’ advertising campaign. Whitacre should know better. Who is his boss anyway?
(sources: Detroit Free Press, Associated Press, MIwatchDog)
FORD OVERTAKES GM IN U.S. MARKET
posted 03.03.10
Ford auto sales were on fire in February -- up 43 percent, enough for the car maker to overtake GM as the sales leader in the U.S. market. Albeit by a very thin margin--only 334 vehicles, statistically .002 percent—the leap over GM is a major boost for the Dearborn automaker just the same. It’s the first time Ford has beaten its cross-town rival in 10 years, and that was due to a strike at GM. According to Ward’s Data, by the raw numbers, in February Ford recorded 142,285 deliveries compared to GM with 141,951. General Motors was up 12 percent -- but when you recalculate and omit the closed brands of Pontiac, Hummer, Saturn, and Saab, sales are up 32 percent. That’s very impressive, but overshadowed by the gargantuan gains at Ford. For example, for the first two months of 2010 Ford has captured 17.5 percent of the U.S. market, up three full percentage points from last year. Under incredible pressure, GM has done a fabulous job, and their gains should not be discounted or overlooked, but the psychological factor of falling behind Ford, even by .002 percent, can’t feel good at General Motors. Both companies have dramatically benefited by Toyota’s accelerator, brake, and steering recall meltdown. Nonetheless the MIwatchdog sends kudos to both Ford and GM for a magnificent turnaround.
Here’s a run down of the February monthly sales figures:
February monthly U.S. auto sales:
Ford Motor Company, +43 percent; Nissan North America, +29 percent;
Honda, +13 percent; General Motors, +12 percent; Chrysler, +01 percent; Toyota, -20 percent
(sources: Los Angeles Times, Ward’s Data, Edmunds)
GM ADDS 1200 WORKERS
posted 02.23.10
The new compact Chevy Cruze is on fire, even before it hits the U.S. market. GM will add a third shift and 1000 employees at its Lordstown, Ohio assembly plant, which builds the Chevy Cruze. With an average of 40 MPG on the highway and a total range of 600 miles per tank, GM is hoping the Cruze—a five passenger compact which replaces the Cobalt—wows the market. It has certainly done so in Australia, where the Cruze is the eighth best-selling car on the market. GM is banking on the vehicle’s spacious interior, safety features
(like its ten standard air bags), two-tone cockpit, and quiet driving experience to be a big hit. As of late, the small car market has been dominated by foreign manufacturers who hold a commanding 78 percent of the U.S. market share. The Cruze is a savior to the Lordstown, Ohio assembly plant, which, during the automotive meltdown, lost two shifts and 2800 hourly workers. It’s been a wild ride for GM. In less than one year, the automotive giant endured bankruptcy and a government takeover…and is now gaining market share. In January, GM sales jumped up by 14.6 percent. To meet rising demand, GM has also added third shifts to assembly plants in Delta Township (near Lansing), Kansas City, Kansas, and Fort Wayne, Indiana. Those added shifts have restored another 2400 jobs at General Motors.
(sources: MIwatchdog, Detroit News, Detroit Free Press)
WOW -- TOYOTA RECALLS 300,000 PRIUSES WORLDWIDE
posted 02.09.10
It’s unbelievable! At the end of January Toyota predicted its worldwide 2010 sales would increase by six percent. Just two weeks later the auto giant is scrambling in the face of two major recall efforts. First is the recall of 5.3 million vehicles for the widely reported sudden accelerator problem. The second, and just announced effort is the worldwide recall of 300,000 Toyota Prius models for failing breaks. Toyota has pulled eight models off the market due to the sudden accelerator problem. It’s a shocking turn of events in the worldwide automotive market, and one that benefits Ford and General Motors. In January, Ford and GM sales were up 25 and 14.6, respectively; meantime Toyota saw its U.S. sales drop 16 percent.
TOYOTA TROUBLE
posted 02.05.10
The bad news just keeps coming for Toyota. According to a Japanese business newspaper, the company faces a probe by U.S. officials into the failing brakes on 37,000 2010 Prius hybrid cars. This development comes right in the middle of Toyota’s struggle with its sudden accelerator gas pedal crisis, or what at least appears to be. Toyota, with some nudging from U.S. Department of Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood, has voluntarily pulled eight vehicles off the market, including the top-selling Camry. That seems odd for a company with a world-class quality and reliability record for years and years. Toyota says the current 5.3 million vehicle recall and lost sales could cost the company $2 billion. Although Toyota’s sales were down 16 percent in January the news isn’t all bad. The auto giant just reported a 2009 third quarter profit of $1.7 billion, contrasted against a $1.8 billion loss a year ago.
FORD AND GM SALES SIZZLING HOT IN JANUARY!
posted 02.03.10
U.S. January auto sales increased by 6.3 percent. And it was Ford and GM that lead the way with sales up sharply from a year ago; 25 percent at Ford and 14.6 percent at General Motors. The companies are clearly gaining from the ‘sudden acceleration’ difficulty at Toyota. The Japanese automaker has recalled 5.6 million vehicles due to the problem. In addition--and most severe--effective January 26th Toyota temporarily removed eight of its vehicles from the market including the top-selling Camry. U. S. Department of Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood called the company “a little safety deaf”. What a change of fortunes in the U.S. auto market. General Motors, just six months after emerging from bankruptcy, announced it will repay the cash portion of its government loan back early, and has dramatically improved its U.S. market share. Contrast that with Toyota -- suddenly having to deal with crisis and voluntarily pulling cars off the market, albeit temporarily, to address a safety concern. For January, Toyota’s U.S. auto sales fell 16 percent. Toyota also lost its status of the #2 selling automaker in the U.S. Ford Motor Company has reclaimed that honor and designation. The news wasn’t all good for the U.S. automakers in January as Chrysler’s sales dipped 8.1 percent.
(source: Detroit Free Press)
FORD FINISHES 2009 WITH $2.7 BILLION PROFIT
posted 01.29.10
For the first time in four years, Ford Motor Company has posted a profit. Officially for 2009 Ford made a profit of $2.7 billion, much improved over 2008 when the company lost $14.6 billion. Ford’s total 2009 revenue was $118.3 billion, which is down by nearly 20 percent in 2008. But the Dearborn automaker managed to increase its U.S. market share by 1.1 percent, capturing 15.3 of the market. The company also gained market share in South America and Europe. Chief Financial Officer Lewis Booth attributed small signs of economic growth, lower costs, and the ability to charge higher prices as reasons for Ford making a profit in 2009. Booth expressed concern over the tenuous U.S. economy, but Ford estimates modest growth in 2010 U.S. vehicle sales -- somewhere between 11.5 to 12.5 million vehicles. 2005 was a recent high-water mark when there were 17 million vehicles sold in the U.S. market, a huge disparity to today’s numbers. It’s worth noting Ford finished 2009 with $34.3 billion in debt, $7 billion which was just paid to the health care trust for UAW retirees. Ford’s 2009 profit represents 2.2 percent of its revenue, a thin margin, but one that could easily increase in 2010. The news pushed Ford stock to $11.95 yesterday before settling at $11.41 at the close.
(sources: Associated Press, Google, MIwatchDog)
FORD ADDS 1200 JOBS IN CHICAGO – SOME UAW COMPLAINTS posted 01.27.10
Ford Motor Company has confirmed its plans to add a second shift at its Chicago plant, which makes the next generation Explorer SUV. The move will create 1200 new jobs. That’s more excellent news for Ford, which continues its string of successful achievements and benchmarks, including a 2009 3rd quarter profit of $997 million. As of January 1st Ford had 600 hourly workers on temporary layoff, according to company spokesperson John Stoll. Those workers will get a chance at the new jobs; how many will agree is undetermined, but there will be some new hires at a lower wage of $14.20 an hour. The new lower starting wage was a UAW concession given to Ford, commensurate with the two-tired wage scale that was awarded to both GM and Chrysler through bankruptcy proceedings. The UAW wisely gave Ford the same, so as to not create a competitive disadvantage for the Dearborn automaker. Regrettably the UAW did not concede to more flexible work rules with Ford that both General Motors and Chrysler also negotiated and attained in bankruptcy. Though UAW President Ron Gettlefinger and union leadership recommended ratification of the new work rules, Ford rank and file rejected them. That does put Ford at a competitive disadvantage with Chrysler and GM, and the greediness of Ford UAW members is to blame. Ron Gettlefinger was wise enough to know that it was in the best interest of his membership and Ford Motor Company to have the new work rules in place. Ford rank and file’s rejection of the work rules only hurts the UAW’s public perception, and possibly themselves, depending on things go. Now some Ford UAW members are complaining about the prospect of new hires starting at the lower wage of $14.20, citing it could create some dissension on the plant floor. Active UAW workers hourly wage is double that amount, not including benefits. Most Americans don’t have much pity for anyone making just under $30 an hour, plus lucrative health coverage and pension. Here’s a suggestion: Active UAW Ford workers should be grateful for their jobs, and not question new hires starting at $14.20 an hour. One thing is for sure. The hundreds of people that will be hired by Ford at an hourly rate at $14.20 an hour plus benefits will be very grateful for their new jobs, even when they work next to someone that makes double their hourly wage.
(sources: Detroit Free Press, MIWatchdog)
BIG SURPRISE -- WHITACRE NAMED PERMANENT GM CEO
posted 01.26.10
After a seven-week search for a new CEO the GM board of directors has changed direction. The board has named interim CEO Ed Whitacre Jr. as the permanent CEO of General Motors. The best news is Whitacre’s statement that he will rely heavily on Vice-President Robert Lutz to run the company. Let’s hope Lutz, a former Chrysler executive, will have the most to say about running the company. Whitacre also said he would count on Wall Street analyst and former auto task force chairman Stephen Girsky -- that move is substantially less comforting. No CEO candidates the board considered are being made public. So far Whitacre has fired the Chevy brand manager, the Buick-GMC brand manager, and former CEO Fritz Henderson. He has combined sales and marketing, consolidated control of GM’s core North American market under one executive, and brought in lobbyists from AT&T (his former company). He also hired former Microsoft Chief Financial Officer Chris Liddell to serve in the same position at General Motors. Of course Whitacre is there because he was appointed by President Obama’s auto task force, and the decision to maintain him--albeit from the board of directors--will be questioned by many. He served as Chairman of AT&T from 1990 to 2007. Thank goodness there is still a car guy involved (no pressure on Bob Lutz, but right now…we need you). GM has announced that it will repay its entire $8.1 billion cash loan portion of its debt. It already paid back $1.3 billion in December. The remainder of its loan from the federal government, which is $45.3 billion, will be paid back when GM stock is sold to the public. That could happen later this year; we can hope.
1st QTR AUTO PRODUCTION UP 69 % posted 01.19.10
Good news for the auto industry: AutoInfoBank says automakers collectively plan on building 2.93 million cars and trucks between January 1st and March 31st; that’s an increase of 69 percent over 2009. Ford and GM plan on doubling their production for the North American market, while Chrysler will boost their output by 92 percent. Toyota meanwhile plans on increasing its 1Q output by 113 percent. This production thrust means longer hours for some auto workers and the possibility that some idle workers could be called back. It’s welcome news for an industry that bottomed out last year. According to JD Power & Associates, 2009 U.S. auto sales will come in at 10.4 million (the worst since 1983). For 2010, Ann Arbor-based Center for Automotive Research is calling for 12.4 million new car and truck sales. Other groups have not been so optimistic, but no one predicts a repeat of 2009. Another positive factor motivating the market is the average age of an American vehicle, now 8.1 years according to R.L. Polk. At some point drivers will elect to purchase a new vehicle rather than reinvestment more money in their older vehicle. The Watchdog thinks the worst is over for American car makers.
(Sources: AutoInfoBank, JD Power & Associates, Center for Automotive Research, R.L. Polk)
500 SKILLED JOBS COMING TO DETROIT posted 01.15.10
A123 Systems says it will hire more than 500 skilled workers at plants in Livonia and Romulus this year. The Watertown, Massachusetts-based company develops and manufacturers advanced lithium-ion batteries and battery systems. The job expansion is related to a new supply agreement with Fisker Automotive. Fisker is a new American automaker that builds premium green vehicles including the Karma plug-in hybrid electric vehicle. The Karma is expected to be on the market in late 2010 and is being presented as the cleanest, most fuel-efficient vehicle in the world while still offering industry-leading style and performance. It will have a range of 50 miles under electric power and a total range of 300 miles with an onboard generator turned by a traditional four cylinder gasoline engine. The Karma features 403 horsepower and is designed to go from 0 to 60 mph in about six seconds, and can reach a top speed of 125 mph. For more information, click here.
(sources: Fisker Automotive, Nanoenergy, Mlive.com)
UPBEAT MOOD FOR DETROIT AUTO SHOW posted 01.11.10
DETROIT -- A year ago GM and Chrysler were scrambling to survive. The companies had just received an $18 billion emergency loan from the government and bankruptcy was eminent. The outlook for the American auto industry was in question as the Detroit International Auto Show was preparing to open its doors. What a difference a year makes. GM Chairman Ed Whitacre is predicting the company will actually make money in 2010, and Chrysler’s merger with Fiat has given the auto maker a new lease on life. Meantime Ford,--which was able to avert bankruptcy--posted a modest profit for 2009, has quadrupled its stock price, and gained one percentage point in the crucial U.S. market. Ford has also received numerous accolades including having its Fusion model being named the 2010 Motor Trend Magazine ‘Car of the Year.’ Yes, the domestic industry has a long battle ahead, but by comparison to last year there is room for optimism. The 2010 Detroit International Auto Show will unveil 41 new vehicles this week at Cobo Hall. The major emphasis of the show is the small car, hybrid, and electric segments. One large display, “Electric Avenue”, will feature 20 new vehicles powered by kilowatts instead of gasoline. Nissan will present its rechargeable Leaf vehicle -- a pure electric car at a cost of about $30,000. GM will offer the Chevy Volt, three years in development and set to hit showrooms this fall for a price of $40,000, but with an available $7500 in tax credits. Even Cobo Hall is in better shape. The facility--which was taken over by a five-member regional authority--has repaired all the roof leaks and is addressing long-delayed maintenance projects.
(Sources: Associated Press, Detroit News, MIwatchdog)
GM PRODUCES FIRST LITHIUM-ION BATTERY posted 01.08.10
BROWNSTOWN TOWNSHIP -- They came out of the woodwork to see General Motors roll out its first lithium-ion battery pack for the new Chevy Volt extended-range electric vehicle. The January 7th event at GM’s Brownstown Township plant was attended by Senator Carl Levin, Governor Jennifer Granholm, U.S. Secretary of Energy Steven Chu, and a brigade of federal, state, and local politicians. They were all snuggling up to the green energy appeal of the Chevy Volt, a key part of GM’s turnaround plan. The Volt, which goes on sale later this year, allows drivers to travel 40 miles using electric power, after which the gasoline engine kicks in. In actuality the gas engine starts when the battery is drained by 70 percent which sustains the battery’s remaining charge and keeps the vehicle running for several hundred additional miles. GM plans on building 8000 Volts for the 2011 model year and hopes to eventually produce 60,000 per year. Full production of the Chevy Volt is expected to begin sometime in the fourth quarter.
(Source: Detroit News)
FORD SALES SOAR BY 33% IN DECEMBER posted 01.06.10
Ford Motor Company ended 2009 with a bang as its sales jumped by 33 percent in December. The news catapulted Ford stock to $11.24 a share before closing the day at $10.96. The Dearborn automaker has been on a roll. Ford has increased its share of the U.S. market by 1.1 percent and Motor Trend Magazine recently named the Ford Fusion as its Car of the Year. What’s most impressive is what a strong year Ford had during the automotive meltdown of 2009. Total U.S. market sales dropped to just 10.4 million, down 21.2 percent and the lowest level since 1982. Total sales are a far cry from 16 million sold in 2007, making Ford’s performance even more impressive. For the month of December total U.S. auto sales were up 15.1 percent over last year. Ford was the only American car company to increase its sales. GM December sales fell by 5.7 percent and Chrysler was off 3.7 percent.
(Sources: Motor Trend, Edmunds.com, Detroit Free Press, MIwatchdog)
FORD HEALTH TRUST NOW PAYS FOR RETIREE HEALTH CARE posted 01.05.10
DEARBORN -- Effective December 31st, 2009, a gigantic trust--set up and paid for by Ford Motor Company (on behalf of the UAW)--will begin to pay for retiree health care. It is a huge change for the Dearborn automaker, as it rids itself of expensive legacy costs that have pinched the domestic auto industry for years. Ford has 285,000 retirees and dependents. The cost is now shifted to the health care trust, also known as a VEBA (or Voluntary Employee Benefits Association), which is owned and managed by the UAW. Ford has placed an astounding $2.51 billion into the trust and has agreed to an additional $7 billion in debt to cover future obligations. As a gesture of goodwill, Ford included a $500 million payment on the debt ahead of schedule. The UAW has also agreed to VEBA agreements with GM and Chrysler, which was a critical portion of their bankruptcy process, and is also the reason why the UAW ended up with a 55 percent equity stake in Chrysler and 17 percent of General Motors.
(Sources: Detroit Free Press, MIwatchdog)
GMAC GETS ANOTHER $3.8 BILLION FROM GOVERNMENT
posted 12.31.09
The U. S. Treasury Department has agreed to invest an additional $3.8 billion in GMAC. In total, Uncle Sam has invested $17.2 billion in the automotive lending company. GMAC officials say most of the new funding will go to restructure its money-losing ResCap unit and mortgage business. The new funding gives the Treasury the right to appoint two additional directors to the GMAC board of directors. Of the nine-member board, four seats will be nominated by the government. GMAC is the primary lender to most GM and Chrysler dealerships, and are considered critical to the recovery of both automotive companies. The $3.8 billion capital infusion is actually less than what was predicted in May, when GMAC forecasted it would need $5.6 billion. The government swapped its investment for an increased equity position in the company, now giving the U.S. Treasury 56.3 percent of the company.
(Sources: Detroit News)
DECEMBER AUTO SALES EXPECTED TO JUMP 7% posted 12.30.09
Senior vice-president of global operations for J.D. Power and Associates Gary Dilts expects December auto sales to improve by seven percent over 2008. If that happens, it’s more proof the hemorrhaging is over for the auto industry, which experienced it worst sales performance since 1983. For all of 2009, J.D. Power says U.S. car and truck sales are expected to reach only 10.4 million, which would be a 21 percent fall from 2008 levels. At this time last year the auto crisis was reaching a boiling point: GM and Chrysler sought emergency funding from the U.S. government and a national recession was starting to suffocate the credit markets and spread fear among consumers. December’s sales growth continues to be lead by Ford. Edmunds is calling for Ford sales to improve by 25 percent in December. Both JD Power and TrueCar are predicting 2010 U.S. auto sales will grow by 10 percent, improving to around 11.5 million. The growth is certainly great news but pales in comparison to the 16 million units sold in 2007. Most importantly though is the industry seems to be stabilizing after enduring one of the most difficult periods in its history -- self imposed or not.
(Sources: Detroit Free Press, J.D. Power and Associates, Edmunds.com, TrueCar)
FORD STOCK TOPS $10 PER SHARE posted 12.24.09
Ford Motor which is a string of financial gain, increased market share, and notable industry accolades just past another benchmark. The stock, which had fallen to less than $2 a share, closed at $10.08 on December 23rd. It is a dramatic comeback and big-time payback for the millions who bought Ford stock in the single digits. In another positive development, Ford has announced it will sign an agreement to sell its Swedish brand Volvo to China’s Zhejiang Geely Holding Group Co. Volvo has been hemorrhaging money, like $135 million in the third quarter. Analysts predict Ford will sell the Swedish automaker for $2 billion, far below the $6.45 billion it paid for Volvo in 1999. Ford has already sold its three British luxury brands: Aston Martin, Jaguar, and Land Rover. It is part of Ford CEO Allan Mullaly’s turnaround plan to focus on the core brands of Ford, Lincoln, and Mercury. The plan appears to be working.
FORD REINSTATES SALARIED EMPLOYEE BENEFITS
posted 12.16.09
DEARBORN -- Great news for the 20,000 or so Ford Motor U.S. salaried employees…their merit pay, 401(k) and tuition reimbursement will be reinstated in next year. The benefits were shelved in 2006, paid later than normal in 2008, and suspended again in 2009. The reinstatement of benefits comes following a series of noteworthy accomplishments at Ford Motor Company:
• The Insurance Institute of Highway Safety named six Ford vehicles as top safety picks.
• Consumer Reports has recognized Ford as the only American car company with world-class quality.
• JD Power has ranked Lincoln and Mercury brands in the top 10 for long-term reliability.
• Motor Trend Magazine named Ford Fusion the 2010 Car of the Year.
• Ford has increased its U.S. market share one full percentage point.
Through September the Dearborn automaker is showing a profit of $1.8 billion, a dramatic turnaround after three years of losses (2006 to 2008) that topped $30 billion. Ford started out 2009 (January) with a staggering loss of $14.6 billion. Some pundits predicted bankruptcy, but Ford survived without it. Earlier this year Ford stock dipped below $2 a share; it has since quadrupled. Major credit should be given to Ford CEO Allan Mulally for navigating the company through the most difficult automotive period since the Great Depression. The reinstatement of salaried employee benefits is another sign of stability and emerging strength at Ford Motor Company.
2010 U.S. AUTO SALES PREDICTED @ 11.5 MILLION
posted 12.14.09
Automotive research firm Edmunds.com is predicting U.S. auto sales in 2010 will grow to 11.5 million, an 11.6 percent increase over 2009 sales, which are estimated to come in at 10.3 million. The recovery is good, but by contrast is low to the glory years of 16 and 17 million total vehicle sales. Another positive development, U.S. carmakers will also lose their pricy legacy costs in 2010; most notably retiree health care expenses. Those costs will now be paid for through health care trusts or VEBA (Voluntary Employee Benefit Association); set up and paid for by GM, Ford, and Chrysler. The three separate health care trusts will be owned and managed by the UAW. It is also the reason why the UAW holds substantial equity holdings in GM and Chrysler.
CHINA OVERTAKES U.S. FOR MOST VEHICLES SOLD
posted 12.11.09
It’s official. In 2009, for the first time ever, China will outsell the United States in vehicle sales. In fact it is the first time in history that any other country has sold more vehicles than the United States. China will sell more than 12.7 million vehicles in 2009, compared to the 10.3 million forecast to be sold in the United States, a 26-year low. After a downturn in 2008 auto sales the Chinese government became proactive by cutting taxes on small cars and spending $730 million on subsidies encouraging the sale of SUVs, pickups, and minivans. For the year China’s auto sales are up a sizzling 44 percent. Auto insiders have long predicted China would become the #1 auto market in the world, but not so quickly. Just two years ago the respected J.D. Power and Associates predicted China would overtake the U.S. in auto sales by 2025. China has a behemoth population of 1.3 billion and a huge emerging middle class that is driving robust vehicle sales. One of the largest Chinese automakers is BYD Company; interestingly enough backed by investment icon Warren Buffett. But both GM and Ford are well-positioned in China, and stand to strongly benefit from China’s exploding vehicle market.
FORD NEEDS EXEMPTION FOR HEALTH TRUST posted 12.10.09
Ford Motor Company needs an exemption from the U.S. Labor Department for the new health care trust it is setting up to pay for retiree health care. The health care trust will cover health care for 285,000 Ford retirees and their dependents. Specifically the exemption would allow Ford to transfer company stock into the health care trust. That of course raises the value of the trust, provided the stock has any…which Ford does: Ford’s stock has quadrupled since dropping below $2 a share. Current federal law prohibits benefit plans from owning significant quantities of employer stock and securities. GM and Chrysler received similar exemptions during bankruptcy. All three auto companies established health care trusts (a.k.a.VEBA) to pay for retiree health care, which is also known as legacy costs. The VEBA will be owned and managed by the UAW, and is the reason the union has a 55 ownership stake in GM and 17 percent ownership in Chrysler.
FIRST WAGONER, NOW HENDERSON posted 12.02.09
DETROIT -- The GM board of directors has forced the resignation of CEO Fritz Henderson. The reason cited, “it was time to accelerate the pace of rebuilding the largest U.S. automaker.” A new international search is planned for a new company CEO and President. General Motors Chairman Ed Whitacre Jr., who was hired in June by the Obama administration’s auto task force, will serve as interim CEO. Before being named GM Chairman by the government, Whitacre ran AT&T for 17 years. Henderson’s firing comes just eight months after the Obama administration removed Rick Wagoner as CEO. Many Americans, perhaps the majority, believe the Wagoner and Henderson dismissals are just. After all, under their leadership GM failed and had to be saved by the federal government. But the removal of both Henderson and Wagoner is precarious and troublesome, and not necessarily a positive move. The auto industry is unique in that it takes a period of years to develop and put a vehicle on the market. Wagoner and Henderson have accelerated that time frame. The new, hot-selling GM cars on the market today such as the Chevy Cruze (sold in Australia and soon in the U.S. market), Chevy Malibu (the 2008 Car of the Year), Chevy Equinox, and the highly-anticipated Chevy Volt (the extended range electric vehicle) are all products of Wagoner and Henderson. Though struggling in the U.S. market, the company is poised to win big in China and other emerging markets. The company has made significant quality improvements. Losing Fritz Henderson’s experience and expertise at this critical stage feels risky. One disagreement between the board of directors and Henderson was the proposed sale of the European Opel division to Canadian auto parts supplier Magna International and Russian state-owned Sberbank. Henderson was for the sale but the board opposed it. The theory is that selling Opel to Sberbank would provide the Russian company with valuable engineering, which they currently do not have, and as a result would create a new global competitor in Europe and Russia. The Obama administration has released a statement saying this decision (firing Henderson) was made by the board of directors alone, with no involvement from the administration. That seems disingenuous given the fact the President’s auto task force hired Chairman Ed Whitacre Jr., who will now serve as the interim CEO. When Rick Wagoner was fired many rose to his defense including Governor Granholm, who called his removal a sacrificial offering in the automotive crisis. You can now add Fritz Henderson to the same category.
THE OLD GM STRUGGLES posted 12.01.09
DETROIT -- With one exception (Hummer), General Motors’ plan of selling off its discarded car companies is not working. The first casualty was Saturn, when the deal with racing mogul and entrepreneur Roger Penske went south. The plan was to have GM continue to produce Saturn models for the first two years, and then Penske would have another manufacturer supply him with Saturn vehicles. That deal broke down when Renault-Nissan got cold feet about supplying Penske with cars under the Saturn name. Now it appears a deal to sell Saab is stalling. Media reports indicate the alliance of Swedish carmaker Koenigsegg Group AB and Beijing Automotive Industry Holdings will not purchase Saab. The one success story from the old GM is Hummer; the oddly-shaped SUV line derived from the U.S. military’s HumVees. Hummer has been sold to Sichuan Tengzhong Heavy Industrial Machinery Company of China. They plan on establishing the brand’s corporate headquarters in Metro Detroit with a $9.4 million investment and will initially employ 100 people.
NEW FORD MUSTANG GETS 30 MILES PER GALLON
posted 12.01.09
DETROIT -- Ford Motor is touting its all-new 2011 Mustang, which company officials say will get an impressive 30 highway miles per gallon and 19 in the city. The iconic sports car, which includes a V-6 engine, will debut this week at the Los Angeles Auto Show. The new Mustang will hit dealer showrooms in the spring of 2010. Through October of 2009 Ford sold 56,469 Mustangs - down 32.4 percent from the same period last year.
GM FIRED UP ABOUT CHEVY CRUZE posted 11.30.09
DETROIT – Slated as GM’s small car savior, the Chevy Cruze will finally make it to the U.S. market in the third quarter of 2011. The five-passenger compact has already debuted in Europe and Asia. The Cruze--which replaces the Chevy Cobalt--delivers an impressive 40 highway MPG with a range pushing 600 miles. In addition to world-class fuel efficiency GM officials tout the vehicle’s safety, buoyed by 10 standard airbags including frontal, side-impact, roof rail head curtain, rear seat side, and new knee air bags. Other noteworthy features include a spacious interior with two-toned cockpit design and unparalleled quietness. Currently the small car segment is dominated by foreign manufacturers with a commanding 78.1 percent of the market. GM officials are hopeful the Chevy Cruze, which will be built in Lordstown, Ohio, will compete effectively with Honda Civic and Toyota Corolla.
PONTIAC BUILDS ITS LAST CAR posted 11.27.09
LAKE ORION -- After an 82-year run it’s over for Pontiac in the United States. The last Pontiac rolled off the assembly line on November 26th at GM’s Lake Orion plant; it was a white G-6 sedan. There was no fanfare or media attention, but some workers did pose for photos as the last Pontiacs moved down the assembly line. In April of 2009 General Motors announced it would phase out Pontiac as part of its restructuring plan. Pontiac debuted in 1926 at the New York Auto Show. Over its lifetime the brand sold 41 million vehicles. Pontiac sales peaked in 1984 when nearly 850,000 vehicles were sold. In the U.S. market, Pontiac is the third-best selling automobile line of all time behind Ford and Chevrolet. The Lake Orion plant which employed 2400 workers will be idled and re-tooled to manufacture a new small car starting in 2011.
FORD MAKING BIG NORTH AMERICAN COMEBACK
posted 11.23.09
In the North American market Ford has been taking it on the chin since 2005, with a staggering $16.8 billion in losses. But things are looking much brighter for the Dearborn-based automaker. Though still in the red for 2009, the North American division reported a $357 million pre-tax profit for the 3rd quarter. Other recent positive developments include:
• Six Ford vehicles being named top safety picks by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.
• Consumer Reports recognizing Ford as the only American car company with world-class reliability.
• JD Power ranking the Lincoln and Mercury brands in the top 10 for long-term vehicle reliability.
• The Ford Fusion being named Car of the Year by Motor Trend Magazine.
Ford has gained market share in 12 out of the last 13 months in the U.S. market. All three brands—Ford, Lincoln and Mercury--are on track to achieve annual market share gains for 2009. In addition, the company’s average transaction price in the U.S. has increased $2156 in the last twelve months to $30,647. The company has spent less on incentives to lure buyers and instead loaded vehicles with more enticing options.
FORD FUSION: MOTOR TREND ‘CAR OF THE YEAR’
posted 11.18.09
DETROIT -- Fabulous news for Ford Motor Company: the Ford Fusion mid-size sedan has been named ‘Car of the year’ by Motor Trend Magazine. The Fusion beat a field of almost two dozen contenders – all of which went through intensive driving tests. The Fusion was first introduced in 2005, and was redesigned in March of 2009 with a new engine, transmission, and improved fuel mileage. Fusion is the top-selling car manufactured by an American auto company. The news helped Ford stock reach a two-year high of $9 before settling at $8.98 a share. Meantime the investment group representing billionaire financer George Soros announced they purchased $52.9 million in Ford stock.
GM TO PAY BACK FEDERAL LOANS AHEAD OF SCHEDULE posted 11.17.09
DETROIT -- Take it as a sign of stability -- GM has announced it will begin to pay back $6.7 billion in federal loans ahead of schedule. In December GM will make its first payment to the feds, a payment of $1.2 billion. The working plan is to have the loans paid off within two years; but GM CEO Fritz Henderson said if things are going well the federal loans could be paid in full by next summer. GM is required to have the loans paid in full no later than 2015. The good news comes at the same time GM announced its first financial report since emerging from bankruptcy on July 10th: a report showing a $1.2 billion loss in the third quarter. While it is a loss, the company said it had $3.3 billion in cash flow from July 10th to September 30th -- and did earn $1.5 billion before interest, taxes, depreciation, amortization, and special items. Looking at GM’s recent history, losing $1.2 billion in the third quarter is a marked improvement. For example, in 2008 GM lost $30.9 billion, and in 2007 the auto giant lost $38.7 billion. Obviously big-time challenges remain for GM, but the fact that the company will start to pay off its federal loans ahead of schedule is a very positive signal for Detroit and the state.
GM POSTS FIRST MONTHLY SALES GAIN IN ALMOST TWO YEARS posted 11.04.09
DETROIT -- General Motors’ October sales increased by 4.7 percent from October 2008, a sign the industry may be stabilizing after the worst sales environment since the Great Depression. Ford also saw a 3 percent improvement in October, while Chrysler’s sales slipped by 30 percent. Toyota’s sales were up slightly, less than a percent, while Honda experienced a slight decrease. Meantime South Korea-based Hyundai was a huge winner in October as sales jumped by 49 percent, anchored by the fuel-efficient Elantra sedan. Subaru, based in Japan, was also a big winner with sales improving by 41 percent, helped by strong sales in its Outback and Forester models.
FORD 3Q PROFIT = $1 BILLION posted 11.03.09
DETROIT -- Thanks to increased market share, cost cuts, and Cash for Clunkers the Ford Motor Company posted a $997 million profit in the third quarter. The company’s North American division posted a pre-tax profit of $357 million – and so far for 2009 the company is showing a $1.8 billion profit. Ford has gained a full percentage point in U.S. market share this year, representing 100,000 additional car and truck sales. It’s a remarkable performance for Ford, and a tribute to CEO Allan Mulally for turning around the giant automaker. It also comes just a week after Consumer Reports named 46 of 51 Ford cars and trucks as average or better in reliability. Despite the positive developments Mulally remains concerned about 2010 as the economy struggles from low consumer confidence and high unemployment -- which in turn will hold down demand for new vehicles. He is confident Ford Motor will be profitable by 2011. The news of Ford’s quarterly profit also comes at the same time UAW members have rejected a new contract which would have provided the same concessions GM and Chrysler earned in bankruptcy. Those concessions include reducing the number of skilled jobs classifications from 20 to 4. It means tradesmen such as electricians or pipe-fitters could perform multiple jobs, translating in less people per shift for the automaker. Other provisions in the contract were a wage freeze for entry-level workers and an agreement to enter binding arbitration on wage and benefit issues. Without those concessions Ford is at a competitive disadvantage, a position even UAW President Ron Gettlefinger agrees with. Gettlefinger pushed hard for ratification, and the rejection by the rank and file is considered a setback by many including Dr. David Cole, Chairman of the Ann Arbor-based Center for Automotive Research. Ford’s $1 billion 3Q profit is a fabulous turnaround.
FORD RANK & FILE REJECT FORD CONTRACT
posted 11.02.09
DETROIT – Regrettably Ford rank and file UAW members have soundly rejected a contract that would provide Ford the same concessions granted to GM and Chrysler during bankruptcy. Specifically the new contract terms called for a wage freeze for entry-level workers, a reduction of skilled trades’ classifications, and an agreement to enter binding arbitration (no strike clause) on wage and benefit issues. It is a major setback for UAW President Ron Gettlefinger and Vice-President Bob King, who both pushed hard for ratification. It also places Ford at a distinct disadvantage with cross town rivals GM and Chrysler. Though improved, Ford’s financial condition remains perilous. The company lost $14 billion last year, but did post a $2 billion profit in the 2nd quarter. However excluding debt reduction and other one-time items, analysts believe Ford would still have posted a loss in the 2nd quarter. David Cole, Chairman from the Center for Automotive Research, said the Ford contract rejection is not welcome news. "The labor harmony that we had achieved seems to be falling apart. This really reinforces that negative image of Michigan, and that impacts more than just the auto industry. It really reflects poorly on the whole industrial Midwest."
GM OCTOBER SALES ARE LOOKING GOOD
posted 10.29.09
DETROIT -- According to a company spokesperson, General Motors is about to post its first monthly sales increase in 21 months. While the official figures will not be released until next week, it appears October sales activity has been strong. Mike DiGiovanni, GM’s executive director of global market and industry analysis, was quoted as saying, “We’re really having a good October.” In October of 2008 GM sold 168,719 vehicles, which was a 45 percent plunge from October 2007. The monthly October sales increase-- though modest--couldn’t come at a better time. It is great news for GM and Michigan. Accolades to CEO Fritz Henderson and his team at General Motors!
FORD BUSTS THROUGH IN NEW CONSUMERS REPORTS
posted 10.28.09
According to a report released by Consumer Reports (October 27th) Ford Motor Company has scored very high in reliability ratings, putting the company on par with rivals Toyota and Honda in some categories. That’s fabulous news for Ford, the only American auto company that did not declare bankruptcy. Ford CEO Allan Mulally is making determined progress for the company, albeit during one of the most difficult periods the industry has ever faced. Of the 51 Ford, Lincoln and Mercury vehicles in the survey, 90 percent were rated average or better. Specifically the Ford Fusion and Mercury Milan mid-sized sedans ranked second best in ‘family sedans’ just behind the Toyota Prius hybrid. GM did not fare quite as well. 20 of 48 GM models had average reliability scores, although Chevy Malibu was a stand-out with well above average reliability rankings. Chevrolet Silverado and GMC Sierra 1500 pickups showed significant improvement and earned a Consumer Reports recommendation. The report did recommend one vehicle built by Chrysler: the four-wheel drive Dodge Ram pickup. Despite Ford’s progress overall, the Asian car companies dominate the top 10. Consumer Reports averages the overall reliability results for the last three model years. Here are the rankings by nameplate:
1. Scion
2. Honda
3. Toyota
4. Infiniti
5. Acura
6. Mitsubishi
7. Lexus
8. Hyundai
9. Porsche
10. Mercury
Click here to see the Consumer Reports 2009 Annual Car Reliability Survey:
SOME FORD UAW RANK & FILE REJECT CONTRACT
posted 10.27.09
DETROIT – Some UAW autoworkers in Missouri and Michigan have rejected a new contract with Ford Motor Company. If ratified, the contract would bring Ford’s labor costs in line with GM and Chrysler, which won the same critical labor concessions with the UAW during their recent bankruptcy filings. Specifically the contract language addresses a wage freeze for entry-level workers, a reduction of skilled trades’ classifications, and an agreement to enter binding arbitration on wage and benefit issues. UAW President Ron Gettlefinger has recommended that all locals ratify the language, which will even the playing field among the domestics and also reward each Ford UAW member with a $1000 one-time bonus. But workers at the Kansas City Assembly Plant voted no, in addition to Ford plants in Livonia and Plymouth. That’s a potential major headache for Ford; it needs the concessions to remain competitive with rivals General Motors and Chrysler. There are some UAW locals that have passed the new contract, two in Wayne, Michigan and two in Ohio. Voting is scheduled to end November 2nd.
AUTO EXEC PAY CUTS WILL BE COUNTERPRODUCTIVE
posted 10.22.09
President Obama’s pay czar is expected to slash top executive pay by 50 percent at seven companies that borrowed or were given money (bailed out) by the federal government. GM and Chrysler, who borrowed $80 billion from the government, are part of that group. General Motor’s CEO Fritz Henderson will make $1.26 million this year, down 27% from his 2008 compensation.
Rick Wagoner, meanwhile, has already been unfairly forced out of GM. The Watchdog’s take is that slashing the pay of the top 25 executives could cause noteworthy defections within the companies when they need leadership the most. There may be a case for reducing executive pay at AIG, which received a whopping $180 billion -- a one-time gift from the federal government that does not have to be paid back. AIG has since paid out millions in bonuses which incensed U.S. taxpayers, and justifiably so. However the law of unintended consequences is at play here. Chrysler’s situation is even more complicated. Fiat--which now owns 20 percent of Chrysler--is exempt from the pay czar’s authority. A wide disparity of income has the potential to create division amongst top Chrysler and Fiat executives. From a free market perspective, having government officials set the pay for executives in any company is unsettling, but particularly for GM and Chrysler, who are fighting to survive in a very difficult market. These executives didn’t get to their positions by accident; they are talented, driven, savvy, and capable. Chopping their pay will not benefit the company; contrarily it will probably hurt, particularly if it causes significant defections by top executives.
WILL FORD SHOW A PROFIT IN 3RD QUARTER?
posted 10.20.09
A JP Morgan analyst is going against the grain, saying he expects Ford Motor Company to report a profit of 16 cents per share for the 3rd quarter.
(This ended September 30th) Himanshu Patel cited Ford’s improvement in pricing and sales in the United States, plus a better performance in the European market. He also credited a surge in Ford F-150 pick- up sales and reduced incentive spending. Patel’s prediction is rejected by Wall Street analysts, who expect a loss of 24 cents a share. September was a very good month for Ford in China, which saw its sales swell 32 percent over the same month last year. Ford is the only American car maker not to declare bankruptcy. Its stock bottomed out below $2 a share earlier this year, but now trades in the $7 to $8 range.
CHINA SEPTEMBER AUTO SALES UP 78% posted 10.14.09
SHANGHAI -- China’s September 2009 auto sales increased by a stunning 78 percent, aided in part by Beijing’s tax cuts and subsidies. So far through September 2009 GM China sales are up 55 percent to 1.3 million, and Ford sales are up 32 percent to 316,639 units. Nothing is official yet, but for the first time in history China this year will likely outsell the United States in total vehicle sales. With a 1.3 billion population and an emerging middle class, the demand for new cars in China is robust and is reason for optimism for both GM and Ford, which are well-positioned in what soon could be the #1 auto market on the planet.
UAW SHOWS REAL LEADERSHIP! posted 10.14.09
Great news for Ford Motor Company! It has reached a tentative agreement with the UAW on three critical measures: a wage freeze for entry-level workers, a reduction of skilled trades classifications, and an agreement to enter binding arbitration on wage and benefit issues. The UAW made similar concessions with GM and Chrysler earlier this year during their bankruptcy process. Ford did not declare bankruptcy, but didn’t want to be left in a competitive disadvantage with rivals GM and Chrysler. To his credit UAW President Ron Gettlefinger and union leaders have agreed to the measures. They could have waited, which would have likely decreased the chance of an agreement, particularly in light of Ford’s improvement in the marketplace. In exchange for the concessions Ford will pay a one-time bonus of $1000 to every UAW-represented worker at the company -- and there are 41,000 UAW-represented workers worldwide employed by the Dearborn automaker. Ford will also agree to extensive job and product commitments at American plants. Ron Gettlefinger deserves much credit for moving ahead and approving this agreement, which will now be voted on by the rank and file. By historic standards, labor relations between Ford and the UAW are very good…maybe the best ever. This is a selfless move on the part of the UAW; they clearly have the best interests of the company in mind on this one. It is also worth noting that in March of this year, the UAW made concessions that will save Ford $500 million annually. If the auto companies and the UAW continue to work together, productivity can and will improve. Detroit is not dead yet.
DELPHI EMERGES FROM BANKRUPTCY posted 10.09.09
Delphi, which spent four years struggling through the bankruptcy process,
has finally emerged from court protection. The bankruptcy was long and difficult, highlighted by intense fights with the UAW, major investors pulling out at the 11th hour, and a global credit crisis. The new company is Delphi Holding LLP, a leaner and more focused company owned by General Motors and Delphi’s bankruptcy lenders. At its peak, Delphi owned and operated more than 40 plants with 211,000 worldwide employees. Four years ago, just prior to entering bankruptcy, Delphi’s U.S. workforce was 50,600. By June 2009 its workforce had shrunk to 14,000. At one time Delphi was the all-inclusive supplier for GM, but the new company has narrowed its attention to electronics, power-train, heating, and cooling systems. The bankruptcy process was very costly for Delphi -- almost $500 million. It was also costly for salaried employees who lost company-paid health care. Retiree pensions were also dumped on the federal Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation.
POST-CASH FOR CLUNKERS, SEPTEMBER AUTO SALES NOSE DIVE posted 10.02.09
The resounding sales success generated by the Cash for Clunkers program this past summer may have come at the expense of September auto sales. General Motors sales were off 45 percent, Chrysler down 42 percent, while Ford slipped only 5.1 percent, a moderate win given the huge Cash for Clunkers sales the month before. Despite a slump in numbers, there were some positive developments in September. For example, Ford’s sales of the new Taurus sedan increased by 60 percent, and sales of the F-150 pick-up sales jumped 3.5 percent, the second consecutive monthly gain for the popular truck. Total U.S. auto sales are tracking to come in at 9.4 million for the year, Depression-level sales according to Dr. David E. Cole, Chairman for the Center for Automotive Research. There was one company that bucked the trend in September: Hyundai reported a sales increase of 27 percent over last year.
ROGER PENSKE BAILS ON SATURN DEAL posted 10.02.09
Billionaire racing legend and Detroit Diesel owner Roger Penske has bailed on his plan to purchase Saturn from General Motors. The deal has been in the works since this summer and leaves 350 dealerships and 13,000 employees in a lurch. The plan called for GM to supply Penske with three current Saturn models: the Aura sedan, Vue, and Outlook SUV for at least two years. Penske’s plan was to then contract Renault-Nissan to produce vehicles that would be branded as Saturn. Negotiations recently broke down with Renault-Nissan, which prompted Penske to withdraw his purchase offer. The news stunned GM, and ignited speculation that another suitor could be pursued. Earlier this summer Telesto Ventures, which includes the Oklahoma City-based private equity firm Black Oak Partners, and several Saturn dealers had expressed interest in Saturn. For the year, Saturn sales are down 59 percent.
GM WILL INCREASE 2010 PRODUCTION BY 45%
posted 09.23.09
DETROIT – GM Group Vice-President Tim Lee says the auto giant will increase its 2010 auto production by 45 percent, or from 1.9 million vehicles to 2.8 million. The company has announced plans to recall 3000 workers at three factories including Kansas City, Lansing, and Fort Wayne. Lansing’s Delta Township plant will recall 800 workers to produce the Chevy Traverse, which is now being manufactured in Tennessee. GM will go to 24-hour operations at all three plants to meet increased demand and to make up for production lost from large-scale factory consolidations announced earlier this year. The announcement is fabulous news for the auto industry and Michigan!
CHINESE AUTO FIRM MAY INVEST IN DETROIT --100 NEW JOBS posted 09.23.09
DETROIT -- Sichuan Tengzhong Heavy Industrial Machinery Company, the firm on track to purchase Hummer from GM, says they hope to establish the brand’s corporate headquarters in Metro Detroit. Spokesperson Nick Richards says the company would initially employ 100 people and invest $9.4 million in the first five years of operations. Plans also include expanding employment to as many as 300 people. The headquarters would include several departments including design, engineering, product planning, purchasing, sales, marketing, and finance. On September 21st the Michigan Economic Development Corporation approved a $20.6 million state tax credit in hopes of enticing the company to choose Michigan for its headquarters. The MEDC also estimates the Hummer headquarters will create another 641 jobs with other companies.
CHEVY CRUZE -- BIG HIT IN AUSTRALIA posted 09.18.09
The Chevy Cruze, which came on the Australian auto market in July, is off to a fabulous start. According to General Motors, right out of the gate it zoomed to the 8th best-selling car in Australia. Chevy Cruze, which sports an impressive 45 highway MPG, will hit the U.S. market in mid 2010; it will replace the Chevy Cobalt compact car. GM is pinning its small car hopes on the new vehicle, which will be built at the Lordstown, Ohio assembly plant. So far for 2009 U. S. auto sales are down 27.9 percent. The Australian auto market is off 14.2 percent.
GM OFFERS 60-DAY MONEY BACK GUARANTEE posted 09.11.09
DETROIT -- In a bold move, General Motors will unveil a new advertising campaign offering a 60-day money back guarantee to new car buyers.
The campaign will start September 14th and will feature its new CEO Ed Whitmore as spokesperson. It will be called the “May the Best Car Win” campaign and will urge customers to choose from GM’s remaining four core brands: Chevrolet, Cadillac, Buick and GMC. If customers are unhappy, they can return the vehicle within 60 days. The 60-day money back guarantee is much more than a new advertising campaign; it’s a first in the 100-year-old industry. It’s an aggressive strategy and demonstrates that GM is ready shake up the market. Kudos to GM for trying something new and standing behind their product.
LABOR DAY 2009 MARKS HUGE GAINS FOR UAW
posted 09.08.09
DETROIT -- The United Auto Workers is the majority shareholder of the new Chrysler, controlling 67.7 percent of the company. The UAW also owns 17.5 percent in the new GM. Both developments are a direct result of the establishment of a retiree health care trust fund, also known as a VEBA (Voluntary Employee Benefits Association). Though paid for by the auto companies, the VEBA is owned and controlled by the UAW. Retiree health care costs, also known as legacy costs, have been draining the auto companies for years. Originally the VEBA was to be funded by all cash, but when the bottom fell out of the auto business and the cash went dry, that became a problem. The UAW was coaxed by both the Bush and Obama administrations to accept a mix of cash and stock to fund the health care trust fund. Ironically the UAW resisted the idea for months, sticking to their desire for all cash to fund the health care trust fund. But when the Obama administration helped circumvent bond holders in favor of the UAW in terms of redistributing equity in the new GM and Chrysler, the union became agreeable, and why not, because now they really do own the company. The VEBA is estimated to save the auto companies $88 billion in health care costs, an absolute requirement to give the industry a chance to survive. It will begin to pay for retiree health care costs starting in January 2010. There are 800,000 UAW retirees and their spouses in the United States -- almost twice as many active UAW members. Though UAW membership has fallen to 431,037, down from a peak of 1.5 million in 1979, in some ways the union has never been stronger. Their ownership stakes in GM and Chrysler gives the UAW even more power, more money, and more influence -- but only if the auto companies can survive and ultimately thrive once again. True, the UAW has agreed to a no-strike clause, new work rules, lower pay for new workers, and conceding cost of living adjustments. However on balance, and with their substantial ownership stakes in the new GM and Chrysler, a little humility from the UAW seems in order.
FORD AUGUST AUTO SALES UP 17.2% posted 09.02.09
DETROIT -- Buoyed by the Cash for Clunkers program, Ford improved its August sales 17.2 percent over last year. GM and Chrysler however did not fare quite as well, down 20 and 15 percent respectively. In total, the government-sponsored Cash for Clunkers program resulted in 690,114 new vehicle purchases at a taxpayer cost of $2.88 billion. As a result inventories plummeted and several dealers were left with little to no inventory on their lots. Even the Ford F-150 pick-up posted August sales gains of 13 percent, and the smaller Ford ranger was up a whopping 57.4 percent. Foreign manufacturers also saw positive gains for the month: Honda lead the way, up 9.9 percent in August; Toyota sales were up 6.4 percent over last year.
GM SALES IN CHINA ARE ON FIRE! posted 09.01.09
While GM’s United States sales may be down 37.7 percent for 2009, its sales in China are on fire -- up 42.8 percent so far this year. General Motor’s July sales in China were up a whopping 77% compared to the same month last year. China is on track to sell 10 million total vehicles this year. Earlier this year it looked like China would outsell the U.S. market for 2009, but the U.S. market has made a moderate comeback The leading GM brand in China is Buick. There is little doubt China will soon become the most important automotive market in the world, fueled by the country’s double digit GDP growth and its population of 1.6 billion, most of whom do not own vehicles.
UAW CAUTIOUS AGAINST NEW FORD CONCESSIONS
posted 08.28.09
DETROIT -- Ford Motor Company will soon be asking for additional concessions from the UAW, similar to ones negotiated with GM and Chrysler earlier this year. The concessions are regarding work rules, strike provisions, and wages for new hires. According to the Associated Press union officials have said some rank and file members have no interest in accepting any further concessions from the company. Ford wants to be on parity with its rivals, and does not want to be disadvantaged when it comes to labor costs. The UAW and Ford Motor Company started meeting this week. In March of this year Ford workers gave up cost-of-living increases and performance bonuses for 2009 and 2010. They also agreed to shelve the much maligned Job Banks program (where laid off UAW members were still paid for up to two years). The total savings for Ford is around $500 million per year. By comparison, concessions approved by the UAW for General Motors are expected to be close to $1.2 billion per year. Ford Motor Company has worked well with the union as of late, and hopes to maintain its good relationship with the powerful UAW. Ford saw a dramatic sales turnaround in July with a 2.4 percent jump in sales, the first monthly sales gain in almost two years…and signs of life for the American auto industry.
GM BALKS AT SELLING OPEL posted 08.27.09
General Motors has a tentative deal to sell Opel--its European car division--to Canadian auto parts maker Magna International and Russian state-owned Sberbank. Now the auto giant is having second thoughts. According to an article by the Associated Press, GM’s reservations are based on fears that American innovation and technology will end up in the hands of a Russian competitor. GM is the #2 car company in the growing Russian market and wants to flank their position. GM’s Russian rival is GAZ, a state-owned automaker stuck producing vehicles with 1970’s technology. GAZ is years behind world standards, and remains in business only through government subsidies and very low prices. Germany is also firmly behind the sale of Opel, and the German government has offered $4.5 billion in credit for the proposed deal. GM’s Opel operations are based in Germany and features an employment base of 25,000. General Motors is also considering selling to a Brussels based investor group. The auto company could also decide to keep Opel. Stay tuned.
U.S. SENATE AGREES ON CASH FOR CLUNKERS SUPPLEMENTAL FUNDING posted 08.06.09
WASHINGTON D.C. -- The U.S. Senate has reached an agreement and will vote today on another $2 billion in funding for the almost-broke Cash for Clunkers program. The U.S. government has said $775.2 million of the original $1 billion program has already been exhausted, representing 185,000 new vehicle purchases. President Barack Obama has said the program will dry up by Friday if not replenished with additional funding. Passage in Senate means the cost of the program will triple to $3 billion, and thus allow opportunity for another 500,000 Americans to purchase a new fuel-efficient vehicle. The program awards vouchers of $3500 to $4500 to consumers who trade in their clunker (which must average 18 miles per gallon or less) for a new fuel-efficient vehicle. Among manufacturers, GM has the largest share of Cash for Clunkers’ sales with 18.7 percent, followed by Toyota with 17.9 percent, and Ford Motor with 16 percent. Overall U.S. automakers have 45.3 percent of Clunker sales, while Japanese manufacturers have 36.5 percent. Dealer inventories are low and the replenished funding means an increase in production for the auto companies and calling laid-off auto workers back to work. Cash for Clunkers is credited for driving a wave of buyers into dealer show rooms. As a matter of fact, it has helped Ford Motor Company achieve its first monthly sales increase in two years. Ford Motor increased its July 2009 sales over the same month last year by 1.2 percent. And in this market, any increase is good news.
6 of 10 CASH for CLUNKERS SALES GO TO FOREIGN COMPANIES posted 08.05.09
Cash for Clunkers has been working well for GM, Ford, and Chrysler…but it’s been even better for the foreign car companies. Six of ten vehicle purchases made through Cash for Clunkers have gone towards a new Toyota, Honda, or Hyundai. According to reports by the Associated Press, the Obama administration has been reluctant to release complete government records on the program. The White House has been pressing the U.S. Senate for a quick vote authorizing an additional $2 billion for Cash for Clunkers. The U.S. Congress has already passed a similar measure. According to the Department of Transportation 157,000 rebate requests are in the system. Some Senate republicans are opposed to approving the additional $2 billion until they know more about the results of the first billion spent on Cash for Clunkers. It is clear the program helped Ford Motor Company post the first monthly sales gain in almost two years, with June 2009 sales up 1.2 percent from last year.
FORD JULY SALES UP 1.2 % FROM LAST YEAR posted 08.03.09
For the first time since November 2007 Ford Motor Company saw a monthly sales gain from the previous year, the companies July U.S. auto sales increased 1.2 percent over last year. Most analysts had figured early fall would be the earliest any of the domestics would see a monthly increase from the previous year. In an article posted on www.freep.com, Ford Vice President of Marketing Ken Czubay stated, “Our July business got off to a good start, and then with Clunkers, it went into high gear.” July sales figures puts industry on track to sell 11 million vehicles for all of 2009, which is appreciably better than the 9 million units the industry was tracking for previous to the July sales figures release.
CASH FOR CLUNKERS IN DOUBT? posted 07.31.09
According to an article from the Associated Press, the government plans to suspend the popular Cash for Clunkers program due to concerns that the program will quickly exhaust the $1 billion set aside in vouchers to purchase fuel-efficient vehicles. Through Wednesday, July 29th, there were 22,782 vehicles purchased with $96 million in total sales. But another 25,000 deals have been submitted but not yet approved by the National Highway Safety Administration which is overseeing the Cash for Clunkers program. In total, 250,000 vehicle sales were planned for under the one-billion dollar program. Some are concerned that the number may have already been reached, which is why the feds plan on suspending the program. The Watchdog thinks the government should step up and continue to fuel this program -- a program that is actually working! What about adding another billion or two to keep the cash flowing and remove gas guzzlers from the road? U.S. car sales are off 35 percent in 2009, and the market is on pace to sell 9 to 10 million for the year, a far cry from the robust levels of 16 million vehicles per year the industry had grown accustom to. The industry could use the additional stimulus to struggle through the most difficult sales environment it has ever faced.
CASH FOR CLUNKERS RESPONSE OVERWHELMING posted 07.28.09
DETROIT -- The U.S. government’s initiative Cash for Clunkers program officially began on July 27th, 2009 -- and the consumer response has been substantial; so much so, that the program could quickly burn through the $1 billion set aside to fund it. The program provides vouchers of $3500 to $4500 towards the purchase a new fuel-efficient vehicle when replacing their car or truck that averages less than 18 miles per gallon. Dealerships from around the state including Detroit and Cadillac report strong showroom traffic and several deposits placed on new vehicle purchases through the Cash for Clunkers program. According to an article posted on www.freep.com, the Demmer Auto Group in Metro Detroit had 70 pending deals. Several dealers have complained that the 136-page program is complicated and involves too much paperwork for both the auto dealer and the consumer. As for the traded-in clunkers, dealers are responsible for removing the engine and transmission, disabling those components, transporting them to a junkyard, and then providing proof to the government that the clunker has been properly disposed of. For more information, click on the following link (the official government website for Cash for Clunkers): http://www.cars.gov/.
THE NEW GM IS HERE posted 07.10.09
DETROIT -- According to www.freep.com, a July 10th mid-morning GM press conference with CEO Fritz Henderson and incoming Chairman Edward Whiteacre Jr. is scheduled, during which they will make the official announcement that General Motors has emerged from Chapter 11 bankruptcy. The new GM will be comprised of four vehicle lines: Chevrolet, Buick, Cadillac, and GMC. The old GM will focus on liquidating idle and underperforming assets. In a surprise move, Bob Lutz--who had earlier announced his retirement--will stay on with the new GM. Lutz had recently given up his position as the head of General Motors’ product development. Lutz has had a colorful and successful career in the automotive industry, working the last eight years for GM, and previously serving as Vice-Chairman of Chrysler.
MANY CHANGES POST-BANKRUPTCY FOR GM posted 07.09.09
GM will continue to downsize once it emerges from bankruptcy, which many believe will happen July 9th. According to CEO Fritz Henderson the company will cut its executive ranks from 1300 to 850. Total U.S. employment will be reduced from 29,650 to 23,500 by the end of this year. Another change is the background color of the GM logo, which will change from blue to green -- illustrative of a leaner and greener company focused on fuel efficiency. There is also speculation that GM will build a new subcompact car in Michigan, thought to be the four-seat mini-car Chevy Spark, which is currently sold in China. The U.S. government is expected to give General Motors $50 billion as it emerges from bankruptcy.
GM WILL SELL 8 FLINT FACILITIES – 100 TOTAL NATIONWIDE posted 07.08.09
As part of its bankruptcy plan of selling assets, General Motors hopes to sell about 100 properties nationwide including eight in Flint. The list includes the 235-acre Buick complex also known as Buick City. For years there has been a plan to transform Buick City’s massive concrete into a multimillion-dollar transportation hub, but that plan has stalled due to a lack of willing investors. According to an article posted on Bloomberg.com, GM spokesperson Tom Wilkinson said the old GM will be selling property it has accumulated over the last 100 years and that it will be like a big garage sale. Wilkinson asserts there will be some good real estate opportunities for investors and communities. One concern however is the possibility of environmental issues affecting any property transfer and as a result potentially scaring off viable investors. Both the federal government and the state would be wise to cooperate with any potential investors instead of wanting to stick them with environmental culpability. Some of the sites will fall under the federal government’s Brownfield classification, which does ease the burden to investors that purchase older manufacturing plants and sites. Selling these plants and parcels of land is important for Michigan’s economy…as well as the nation’s economy. At some point assets have value and when the price gets low enough entrepreneurs and investors are willing to step in, take the risk, and purchase the asset. Whilst feeling the heat of bankruptcy, GM will be forced to sell at prices low enough to get investors attention. To view a Google map of the Flint properties GM wants to unload click here.
THE NEW GM IS READY TO ROLL posted 07.07.09
After navigating through the most arduous time in its history, General Motors is about to emerge from bankruptcy. On July 5th U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Robert Gerber approved spinning off the good assets to create the new GM; comprised of Chevrolet, Buick, Cadillac, and GMC. The judge’s order will not go into effect until Thursday, July 10th, in order to allow time for GM creditors and objectors to appeal. Most experts believe there is no chance that the objectors will succeed and that the bankruptcy agreement will move forward. In terms of the future, the pipeline is loaded with new product at General Motors highlighted by the Chevy Cruz, which boasts an impressive 45 miles per gallon, and the revolutionary Chevy Volt, which can travel up to 40 miles on electric power. Both vehicles will be available in 2010. The new GM will be majority-owned by the U.S. government with a 60.8 percent stake, followed by the UAW retiree health care trust with 17.5 percent, the Canadian government with 11.7 percent, and the old GM stakeholders (comprised mostly of bondholders) will have 10 percent ownership. Should GM prevail and pay off the government loans, Uncle Sam stands to make a ton of dough, and General Motors will redeem itself. That would be outstanding.
JUNE AUTO SALES -- SIGNS OF RECOVERY? posted 07.02.09
There was a silver lining in the June auto numbers. The biggest positive news came from Ford Motor: in June they had the smallest sales decline of the year, down 10.7 percent compared to last year. This is actually very good news because in May Ford sales were down 24 percent -- and for the first five months of the year they were off a whopping 37 percent. General Motors--which is in the middle of bankruptcy--was off 33.4 percent for June, and Chrysler--which just emerged from bankruptcy on June 10th--saw its sales slip by 42 percent. Despite the down numbers, there are some positive signs. Analysts say it now appears the U.S. market may top the 10 million mark for total overall 2009 sales. Previous to June’s sales numbers the U.S. market was tracking to finish 2009 with just nine million total sales. Granted, those numbers are a far cry from what the U.S. market is capable of, more like 16 or 17 million units per year. The foreign automakers are not immune. All of them experienced major drops in their June auto sales: for example, Toyota slipped 32 percent and Nissan was off 23 percent. What is clear is that the U.S. market is experiencing the worst sales levels in 27 years. But perhaps Ford's June sales numbers shows some light at the end of the tunnel.
FORD MOTOR SEES TURNAROUND – WILL INCREASE PRODUCTION posted 06.30.09
Ford has announced it will increase vehicle production in the 3rd quarter
(July through September) by 15,000 cars and 10,000 trucks. By the raw numbers Ford will manufacture 485,000 vehicles in the third quarter, a 16 percent increase compared to the same period last year. Ford officials cited an up tick in consumer confidence, reduced jobless claims, and the federal “Cash for Clunkers” campaign. Cash for Clunkers is a national program which entices owners of gas guzzlers to trade them in for more fuel efficient vehicles. New car buyers will be rewarded with vouchers of $3500 to $4500.
TOTAL LOANS FOR GM & CHRYSLER = $80 BILLION!
posted 06.11.09
Skeptical lawmakers were reassured by President Obama’s auto task force that there will be no more auto loans for General Motors and Chrysler. During hearings on Capitol Hill Ron Bloom--senior advisor of the auto task force--was peppered with questions before the U.S. Senate. All together GM, Chrysler, and auto suppliers have received $80 billion in federal loans. That’s just over half of what insurance giant AIG received, but that money of course was ‘free’ and does not have to be paid back. We in Michigan will get over that double standard someday, especially when the loans ARE PAID BACK. The U.S. Treasury has set aside $30.1 billion for GM and $8.1 billion for Chrysler to get through the bankruptcy process. It appears the government will write off the $23 billion it lent to the automakers from January to March. Senator Richard Shelby was particularly critical saying the government’s 8 percent stake in Chrysler and 60 percent ownership of GM has embarked on a disturbing and difficult road. Other senators were critical of the 3000 dealerships that were closed. When questioned on when the U.S. taxpayer will be reimbursed, Bloom stated, “Over time a very substantial portion and potentially all of the taxpayer investment in General Motors would be returned.” He added, “By no means would I say I am highly confident that that would occur. I think there are reasonable scenarios where it could occur.”
SUPREMES CLEAR THE WAY FOR CHRYSLER BANKRUPTCY posted 06.10.09
A last-minute appeal by three Indiana pension funds and various consumers groups has been turned down by the U.S. Supreme Court, clearing the way for Chrysler to proceed with its bankruptcy plan. At least four of the nine Supreme Court justices would have had to have been convinced that the issue raised was serious enough to warrant a full appeal, and also a majority of the court would have to believe the lower court’s decision was incorrect. That was not the case and so the sale of Chrysler’s assets to Fiat will proceed. Chrysler has been working feverishly to meet a June 15th deadline, a key element in its restructuring plan negotiated with the Obama administration auto task force. On behalf of the auto task force, U.S. Solicitor General Elena Kagen stressed to the court that Chrysler is losing $100 million every day and that government financing would run out as soon as June 30th. It was also argued that Chrysler’s bankruptcy plan automatically terminates in less than a week, and that there is no guarantee a new bankruptcy agreement could be reached.
NEW GM CHAIRMAN HAS ZERO AUTO EXPERIENCE
posted 06.10.09
The Obama administration, which claims it wants nothing to do with the day-to-day operations of General Motors, has named Edward E. Whitacre GM’s new chairman. Though the announcement was made by GM itself, it’s hard to believe the hire was made without the approval of--or perhaps even the directive by--the Obama administration auto task force. Whitacre has spent his entire career in the telecommunications industry and from 1990 to 2007 served as Chairman and CEO of AT&T. He currently serves on the board of Exxon Mobil and Burlington Northern Santa Fe Corporation. Whitacre is 67 years old and holds an industrial engineering degree from Texas Technological University. He has zero experience in the automotive industry. The new GM board will have 13 directors, of which four are yet to be named. The UAW health care trust fund will also get one seat on the board, as will the Canadian government. General Motors has said that six current board members will likely resign their position when GM’s bankruptcy plan is approved by the courts. In fairness, Allan Mulally also had no automotive experience before starting as CEO with the Ford Motor Company. However Mulally did bring years of experience in heavy equipment manufacturing. He started with Boeing directly out of college in 1969.
CHRYSLER-FIAT SALE DELAYED BY SUPREME COURT
posted 06.09.09
Judge Ruth Bader Ginsburg has delayed the sale of Chrysler to the Italian auto maker Fiat. She ruled the sale is ‘stayed pending further order,’ which is an indication the delay could be very brief. She can decide herself to end the delay, or have the full Supreme Court decide. The stay is being pushed by secured debt holders who--per the bankruptcy agreement--are scheduled to receive 29 cents on the dollar on an investment of $6.9 billion. The fight in the Supreme Court has been lead by three Indiana state pension and construction funds, which has a $42.5 million investment in Chrysler. They assert the UAW has received preferential treatment, due to the detriment of itself. In addition, they challenge the constitutionality of the Treasury Department’s $3.4 billion loan from TARP (Troubled Asset Recovery Program) to Chrysler. They claim the government did so without congressional authority. In December of last year Congress passed emergency loan legislation for the auto industry, specifically targeted for GM and Chrysler. But a similar measure in the Senate was defeated in a bitter Senate battle, primarily lead by right-to-work Southern states. That’s when President Bush--who supported the defeated legislation, but was determined to help the industry--tapped the TARP fund for the $13.4 billion requested by GM and Chrysler to stay afloat.
RICK WAGONER REPORTEDLY UPSET OVER FIRING
posted 06.08.09
In an article on posted on www.freep.com people who know former CEO Rick Wagoner say he is still upset about being fired. They add that since his ousting from GM, Wagoner is spending his time at the family vacation home in Daufuskie Island, South Carolina. For most automotive insiders, not to mention free market capitalists, Wagoner’s ouster was a slap in the face. It’s also completely contrary to the Obama administration’s position of not wanting to run GM. Please…if you fire the CEO, you are running the company. It was at a March 27th meeting at the U.S. Treasury Department in Washington D.C. where Wagoner learned he was being fired by the President of the United States. Steven Rattner, leader of the automotive task force, was the person that actually told Wagoner he had to step down. Wagoner immediately told COO Fritz Henderson and CFO Ray Young that he was being fired. They were shocked, as were several board members. Wagoner served almost nine years as CEO of General Motors. He assumed the position in June of 2000. Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm strongly objected to his firing, and characterized it as a sacrificial offering in the automotive industry crisis.
HUMMER SOLD TO CHINESE COMPANY? posted 06.03.09
Declaring bankruptcy is triggering several moves for GM. According to an article posted on www.freep.com GM is close to selling Hummer to the Chinese firm Sichuan Tengzhong Heavy Industrial Machinery Company. The company is China’s leading manufacturer of road, construction, and energy industrial equipment. It will be the first Chinese-owned company to sell vehicles in the U.S. market. No selling price was released, but last year General Motors was hoping to sell Hummer for around $500 million. In a joint press release by the two companies, Hummer will continue to be headquartered in the United States, which will save 3000 U.S. manufacturing, engineering, and dealership jobs. The agreement also calls for GM to provide manufacturing and business services (which includes the building of the H3 SUV at Shreveport Louisiana) during a transitional period through next 2010. CEO Yang Yi said the company will invest heavily in Hummer including the development of more fuel-efficient vehicles that will be sold in both the U.S. and China. GM is also actively pursuing a buyer for Saturn, and according to CEO Fritz Henderson there are currently 16 interested parties. General Motors is also hoping to sell Saab, and currently has three possible suitors.
MAY GM SALES BETTER THAN EXPECTED posted 06.03.09
General Motors May sales slid 29.6 percent, but that number is substantially lower than the 36 percent decline expected by analysts. By the raw numbers
GM sold 191,875 new cars and trucks, compared to 272,363 vehicles sold last year -- making May the best performing month of the year. Also on a positive note, on a month-to-month basis, GM’s May sales increased 11 percent over
April sales. There was also good news from Ford Motor Company (which saw
May sales slip 24.2 percent): Ford Fusion sales increased 9.4 percent.
Most importantly Ford has announced it will increase 3rd quarter production by
10 percent (over 2008 levels), meaning it will manufacture 460,000 vehicles.
GM BANKRUPTCY MIND-NUMBING FOR STATE posted 06.02.09
According to an article on www.mlive.com the state of Michigan has lost a staggering 700,000 auto manufacturing jobs since 2000. Now with GM officially in bankruptcy Michigan will brace for even more job losses, including 3000 white collar jobs announced by CEO Fritz Henderson. GM will close 12 factories including six in Michigan, which puts another 9000 jobs at risk. General Motors will also close 2100 car dealerships in addition to the 1100 it announced last week. When taken fully into consideration, it’s a wonder the state is holding up as well as it is. In a statement, Governor Jennifer Granholm said, “We know now we are hitting bottom.” According to the bankruptcy filing, the U.S. government will loan General Motors $30.1 billion and the Canadian government will lend $9.5 billion to the auto maker. Chrysler has quietly moved through its bankruptcy process and could emerge from it as soon as June 15th. Experts say GM--which is twice as large as Chrysler--will have a much tougher time in bankruptcy. For example, in its filing GM reported that it has over 100,000 creditors, $172.8 billion in liabilities, and $82.3 billion in assets. The automotive industry continues to struggle with depression-level sales fueled by erratic gas prices. Should present sales trends continue, nine to ten million vehicles will have been sold in the U.S. market in 2009. By comparison, last year U.S. auto sales were just over 16 million. That alone is a reduction of 40 percent. According to David Cole from the Center for Automotive Research, the good news is therecontinues to be pent-up demand, and at some point the buyers will be back.
BANKRUPTCY FOR GM posted 06.01.09
The U.S. Treasury Department has given the go-ahead for General Motors to proceed with its bankruptcy organization plan. Down the stretch the company convinced 54 percent of bondholders to support the plan, which will give them a 10 percent stake in the new company. Bondholders have $27 billion invested in General Motors. Getting that many bondholders to sign on with the plan is a huge help and will make bankruptcy a little smoother. The bondholders will also get a warrant for an additional 15 percent stake in the company if things go well for GM post-bankruptcy. Still, there are many bondholders that will fight in bankruptcy court claiming the UAW health care trust has received favored treatment which goes against current U.S. bankruptcy laws. According to the bankruptcy filing, GM will receive an additional $30 billion in loans which is in addition to the $19.4 billion General Motors has already borrowed from the federal government. The U.S. government will forgive all but $8 billion of the loans, but will also take a 60 percent equity position in the new company. The Canadian government will have 10 percent of the new GM; the UAW health care trust will get a 17.5 percent stake with a warrant to receive an additional 2.5 percent; again it’s contingent upon how things go for the company post-bankruptcy. The company is expected to close 12 manufacturing facilities and eliminate 21,000 jobs. GM shares closed last Friday at 75 cents. General Motor shares peaked in 2000 at $93.62 a share. At one point in time GM had just over 50 percent of all U.S. auto sales. Today the company has around 19 percent of the U.S. market. With Monday’s bankruptcy filing, GM will be taken off the Dow Jones Industrials on the New York Stock Exchange. The company is an American industrial icon that has provided millions of jobs, tons of engineering innovations, and made numerous contributions to the country and the world. One of its greatest accomplishments was during WWII when GM manufactured the armament that helped win the war. While the auto giant has been humbled, GM has a chance to redeem itself. Chrysler, which filed from bankruptcy in late April, is expected to emerge from bankruptcy protection on June 15th and operate as the new Fiat-Chrysler.
WILL GM RELOCATE TO WARREN? posted 05.28.09
WARREN -- If he has his way, Jim Fouts will convince GM to move its corporate headquarters from the Renaissance Center to the city Warren. To provide incentive Fouts, the Mayor of Warren, will offer tax breaks and other perks to GM. In addition Fouts says that Warren--the third largest city in the state--has no city income tax and less crime. The suggestion is sure to draw fire from the city of Detroit, which is already facing a $300 million deficit this year. Losing GM would be a huge loss for Detroit. GM currently operates the Warren Tech Center, a sprawling research and development facility (constructed in the 1950’s), which features ample room for thousands of employees. It looks like newly-elected Detroit Mayor Dave Bing can add keeping GM in the Motor City to his long list of things to do.
MAJOR UAW CONTRACT CHANGES posted 05.27.09
In a new settlement agreement just agreed to by the leadership of the United Auto Workers there are substantial contract changes with General Motors. The measure will be voted on by UAW membership this week. Part of the settlement agreement offers buyouts for all UAW-GM workers in a variety of payouts, including one program as high as $115,000. Also new is the amount of stock the UAW health care trust fund will receive, which is $6.5 billion in preferred stock. That amount will give the union a 17.5 percent stake in the company, substantially lower than a previous plan which would have given the UAW a 39 percent stake in GM. Also new is a 9 percent dividend structure, where the health care trust will receive $585 million every year for as long as the stock as held. GM will also commit $2.5 billion to a note payable in cash in 2013, 2015, and 2017. The settlement agreement also says that five Delphi facilities will be returned to GM ownership, including two plants in Michigan: Delphi Saginaw Steering and Delphi Power Train Systems in Grand Rapids. To review documents released by the UAW, click here. The UAW and GM are scrambling to avoid bankruptcy. GM borrowed $13.4 billion from the federal government last year and faces a June 1st restructuring deadline from the Obama auto task force. Other changes from the settlement agreement include reduced retiree health care benefits and the elimination of vision and dental benefits for retirees. To help offset health care costs, cost-of-living increases and performance bonuses will be suspended in 2009 and 2010. The traditional Easter Monday holiday will be suspended in 2009 and 2010, and payment of unused vacation entitlement will be discontinued. Also break time length will be reduced to 40 minutes per eight-hour shift and 50 minutes per 10-hour shift.
UAW-FEDS-GM MAKE A DEAL posted 05.22.09
The United Auto Workers has reached a tentative agreement with the Obama administration auto task force and General Motors. No details have been released but it is a crucial step in avoiding bankruptcy. However another major hurdle remains, and that is the GM bondholders who hold $27 billion in unsecured debt. 90 percent of the bondholders would have to agree to receive a 10 percent stake in the company -- a scenario most experts feel is unlikely. Bondholders don’t like the idea that their $27 billion is only worth 10 percent of the company. Per the plan outlined by the Obama administration auto task force, the UAW will receive 39 percent of the company. The problem is the value of their stake is only $10 billion, far less than the bondholders. The bottom line is that it isn’t fair. Furthermore, the only reason the UAW will even have an equity position is that General Motors graciously agreed to establish a trust fund (or Voluntary Employee Benefits Association) which is owned and operated by the union which pays for retiree health care costs. When it became clear to everyone that GM did not have the cash to fully fund the health care trust, company stock was considered a logical alternative…and indeed it is. The UAW is being aided and abetted by the Obama administration; their political ties are a matter of public record. The GM bondholders are within their rights to hold out: they should not be forced to make any sacrifice, particularly when the UAW is receiving preferential treatment from the Obama administration. On a side note, the stock market did react favorably to the UAW tentative agreement: GM shares traded up on the day, rising 10 percent to $1.60 a share.
STABENOW INTROS CASH-4-CLUNKERS posted 05.22.09
Michigan U. S. Senator Debbie Stabenow has introduced cash-for-clunkers legislation -- a voucher of up to $4500 toward the purchase of a fuel-efficient vehicle. The idea has been discussed more than once as of late as the auto industry struggles. An identical measure is being worked on in the House. According to an article on www.freep.com the voucher will be good for both domestic and imported vehicles. Under Stabenow’s bill the program would last for one year. Trade-in vehicles will be accepted, but must be drivable, insured, and registered to the same owner for at least one year. The trade-in must have a combined fuel rating of 18 m.p.g. or less. The amount of the voucher is determined by the difference in miles per gallon from the trade-in to the new fuel-efficient vehicle. For example, a trade-in getting 18 m.p.g. compared to a new vehicle with a 22 m.p.g.-rating, qualifies for a $3500 voucher. New cars with a 10 m.p.g. or better rating will get a voucher of $4500. The Senate will debate the legislation next week.
GM SHAKEDOWN CONTINUES posted 05.21.09
Last week 1100 GM dealers were notified their dealer agreements would not be renewed. Major events are coming daily for the auto giant, and how General Motors will be structured--assuming it goes to and emerges from bankruptcy protection--is beginning to take shape. The U.S. government will be the largest shareholder, followed by the UAW (with 39 percent of the company). The UAW gets that equity from its union-owned health care trust fund, paid for by General Motors, through cash and lots of stock…enough to give the union a 39 percent stake in the company. That’s the same circumstance that gave UAW workers a 55 percent share in Chrysler. Like some Chrysler bondholders, many GM bondholders are resisting the proposed 10 percent stake, claiming they will do better in bankruptcy court. That sets up another showdown between bondholders and the Obama administration auto task force. Both GM and Chrysler are out of money. As part of its bankruptcy agreement Chrysler requested and received $8 billion in government loams. General Motors has said it will need an additional $11 billion to continue operations.
CHRYSLER BANKRUPTCY -- UNION VERSES UNION
posted 05.21.09
In an ironic twist, the Chrysler bankruptcy proceedings have pitted teacher and police unions against the United Auto Workers. It all stems from the so-called holdout hedge funds of bondholders, some which include major stakes from the Indiana State Teachers Retirement Fund and the Indiana State Police Pension Trust. Attorneys for the hedge funds claim the UAW is receiving preferential treatment, at the financial sacrifice of Chrysler bondholders. They claim the Obama administration auto task force has made an unfair deal, which violates the bankruptcy code…and the Watchdog agrees. That being said, the times and events are unprecedented, and it may not make any difference. This week in New York, U. S. Bankruptcy Judge Arthur Gonzalez denied a motion from the Chrysler bondholders to delay the proposed sale of Chrysler’s assets to Italian car maker Fiat. Chrysler attorneys argued any delay will only hurt Chrysler.
OBAMA SQUEEZES BIG 3 – RAISES OPERATING COSTS
posted 05.19.09
WASHINGTON D.C. -- President Barrack Obama will announce tougher CAFE (Corporate Average Fuel Economy) standards of 35.5 miles per gallon by 2016. That means increased operating costs for General Motors, Ford, and Chrysler. The proposed legislation is being positioned as a favor to the car companies in return for California backing off its desire to set even higher standards than the federal government. The new pact would increase existing mileage standards by five percent every year through 2016. This is welcome news for the global warming supporters, but a disaster for the both domestic and foreign car makers. With Chrysler in bankruptcy and GM perhaps days from declaring, the move couldn’t come at a worst time. According to an Obama administration official, the new standards will raise the cost to purchase a car from $600 to $1300 dollars per vehicle. Because they accepted federal loans to stay solvent last December, GM and Chrysler are in no position to object. Regardless, the new standards are another example of the incessant chipping away at the American auto industry when it can least afford it. For some time, California and 13 other states have been pushing to raise their respective state’s mileage standards above the national standard. Raising CAFE standards requires more engineering and innovation from the car companies. It also forces the manufacturers to build lighter vehicles, while simultaneously maintaining complex safety standards. Lighter-weight vehicles are less safe, and put the driver and passenger at more risk. Improved mileage standards and maintaining safety are conflicting objectives. Until the recent surge in gas prices Americans clearly chose larger vehicles like trucks and SUVs. For an inclination of what the government requires of the American car companies, click here: www.nhtsa.dot.gov.
1100 GM DEALERS DROPPED posted 05.18.09
GM has informed 1100 dealers (20 percent of total GM dealers) that their franchise agreements will not be renewed. According to 24/7 Wall Street, with the total number of Chrysler and GM dealers slated to close, that will mean another 100,000 jobs lost in the auto industry. The move comes as GM scrambles to avoid bankruptcy, which seems almost inevitable at this stage. The company is working against a June 1st deadline to resubmit its restructuring plan to the Obama administration auto task force. Like Chrysler, trimming the number of dealerships was a painful but necessary step for General Motors. GM is also seeking concessions from bondholders and the UAW. In addition to the 1100 dealers that were just pink slipped, GM expects another 400 dealers to close voluntarily. Closures are also likely at Hummer and Saturn locations. GM’s dealer agreements do not renew until October of 2010; presumably if the automaker avoids bankruptcy those dealerships can remain open until next year. However if Chapter 11 bankruptcy does occur, those 1100 dealers could lose their franchise agreements in a matter or weeks. GM wants to reduce the number of its dealers by 2600 by 2010.
789 CHRYSLER DEALERS TERMINATED posted 05.18.09
Once Chrysler declared bankruptcy all 3,188 dealer contracts became null and void. That fact hit home on Thursday, May 14th when 789 Chrysler, Dodge, or Jeep dealerships were notified they were being terminated as dealers by the company. The move was criticized by Michigan Congressman Dave Camp, who felt the process should have taken place over a longer period of time. Listen to Congressman Camp’s latest MIwatchdog interview here. Congressman Camp also expressed concerns about the ability of the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation’s capability to handle GM and Chrysler’s pension obligations. The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation is the government agency that steps in when private pensions go bad and can’t pay their financial obligations. The 789 dealerships slated for closure were notified by letter via UPS. Officially their franchise agreement will be terminated on June 9th, which leaves the dealers 23 days to contest the decision in court. Chrysler has stated it will not buy back any vehicles, parts, or tools from the terminated dealers. To view the entire list of dealers go to the following link: http://msnbcmedia.msn.com/i/msnbc/sections/business/
Chrysler_dealers_list.pdf.
WILL CHRYSLER DROP 800 DEALERS? posted 05.13.09
In U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Chrysler will soon file a list of dealers that it wants to maintain. Currently there are 3200 Chrysler dealerships in the United States. By way of comparison, Toyota--which has more market share than Chrysler in the U.S.--has 1460 dealers. There is speculation that as many as 800 dealers will be dropped. According to an article published on MLive (www.mlive.com), bankruptcy attorney Steven Lerner has informed dealers that at least 800 franchise agreements are at risk. However, Chrysler spokesperson Kathy Graham says the 800 number was pure speculation. Chrysler filed for bankruptcy on April 30th and has been surviving on a $4 billion emergency loan from the federal government. The company has already lost 400 dealers since the beginning of 2008. Most experts believe dealerships in larger metro areas are most vulnerable. Evaluations will be based on how well-capitalized and how profitable the dealership is, the condition of the dealership’s facility, whether or not the dealer has hit its sales goals, and whether the dealership carries Jeep and Dodge in addition to Chrysler.
CAR DEALERSHIPS GET PINK SLIPS posted 05.12.09
DETROIT -- In an ongoing series of negative events, General Motors will soon notify individual car dealerships that it wants to close. Notices will be sent this week. The statement alluding to the closures was made by GM President & CEO Frittz Henderson. He also indicated that a bankruptcy filing was more probable. Just two weeks ago GM announced plans to reduce its number of dealers by 42 percent, from 6,246 to 3,605 by the end of 2010. The NADA (National Automobile Dealers Association) has launched an aggressive advertising campaign questioning the move. The ads target President Obama and his auto task force who have pushed for reducing the number of dealerships. With all due respect to car dealership owners, most experts agree there are simply too many dealerships to support the current market share of the domestics. For example in the 1950’s GM had a robust 50 percent share of all U.S. auto sales. Today General Motors U.S. market share is 20 percent. On the positive side – in the long run, those dealerships that do survive stand to benefit from less competition.
GM BANKRUPTCY COMING SOON? posted 05.12.09
DETROIT -- The evidence is mounting. In a May 12th statement, GM CEO Fritz Henderson said bankruptcy is a more likely scenario for the automaker. Also on Monday, six GM executives sold 200,000 shares of General Motors shares on the open market for prices ranging form $1.45 to $1.61 per share. According to press accounts in the Detroit Free Press (www.freep.com) General Motors is getting ready to issue massive amounts of new equity in which large stakes will be given to the U.S. government and the United Auto Workers retiree health care trust fund (a.k.a.VEBA -- or Voluntary Employment Benefits Association). GM plans to issue 62 billion new shares of stock and then do a 100-for-1 reverse stock split. The plan will make Uncle Sam the largest GM shareholder, followed by the UAW health care trust fund. Unbelievable!
TOUGH TIMES FOR GM posted 05.08.09
DETROIT -- GM celebrated its 100th birthday last summer. Almost one year later the auto giant is fighting to avoid bankruptcy in the midst of a depression-level sales environment. General Motors’ revenue has taken an amazing 50 percent fall so far this year. First quarter revenue was $12.3 billion, down from $24.5 billion in the first quarter of last year. Officially it’s a $6 billion dollar loss in the first quarter for General Motors. All this looms as the company scrambles to meet a June 1st government deadline to submit a revised restructuring plan. Their original plan, submitted earlier this year, was rejected by the Obama administration auto task force. As it stands now with the current restructuring plan that is on the table, the U.S. government will become the largest shareholder in GM, followed by the United Auto Workers. These are very tough times for all the stakeholders in the company: executives, salaried workers, shareholders, bondholders, and yes…the UAW. GM Chief Financial Officer Ray Young said although it is hard to quantify, bankruptcy fears are driving customers away from GM. In a nationwide survey by AutoPacific (www.autopacific.com) taken between March 31st and April 1st, 52 percent of consumers were concerned about buying a GM vehicle because of a possible bankruptcy.
23 GM FACTORIES TEMPORARILY CLOSING posted 05.07.09
DETROIT -- General Motors has announced it will temporarily close 23 engine, transmission, and parts factories across the country. Some of those will be partial shutdowns, but others will be the entire factory. According to a GM spokesperson, the move is directly related to the closing of 13 assembly plants for up to 11 weeks. That move was announced two weeks ago and affects 24,000 GM workers. The new closures will affect around 18,000 hourly and salaried workers. Members of the United Auto Workers will still receive most of their pay, thanks to the union contract that requires the company to cover the difference between state unemployment benefits and their wages. General Motors will also pay salaried workers 75 percent of their pay, providing they are furloughed under a new company policy. Those factories most greatly affected are in Baltimore, Toledo Ohio, and Michigan’s Ypsilanti Township. At the end of March, GM had a 123 day supply of vehicles. According to www.wardsauto.com U.S. auto sales are off 37.3 percent so far in 2009.
UAW WILL SELL STAKE IN CHRYSLER posted 05.05.09
DETROIT -- United Auto Workers President Ron Gettlefinger has stated the union has no intention of keeping its 55 percent stake in Chrysler. The union will sell the shares on the open market (when they have value) to fund the trust that will pay for retiree health care costs starting next year. Gettlefinger said the trust—or VEBA (Voluntary Employees Benefit Association)--will start with $1.5 billion from an existing health care trust, and will receive $300 million from Chrysler next year. The total health care obligation for Chrysler is $10.9 billion for 82,000 retirees, in addition current workers who will eventually retire. At a news conference in Detroit Gettlefinger said the trust has already eliminated some benefits including dental and vision coverage. He also challenged those who claim the union is getting a better deal than the secured debt holders because the union is taking a big risk with Chrysler stock which is currently worth nothing. Those debt holders are fighting back, read about it in the story below this one. Chrysler filed for bankruptcy protection last week and hopes to emerge in 30 to 60 days as a stronger company with alliance partner Fiat.
CHRYSLER LENDERS FIGHT BACK posted 05.05.09
A group of 20 lenders—who have $1 billion invested in Chrysler, that refused to accept 30 cents on the dollar for their investment--will fight the company’s planned bankruptcy sale. The group is lead by Tom Lauria, bankruptcy attorney for White and Case, based in Albany, New York. Lauria stated the proposed plan inverts the classic priority scheme referenced in the bankruptcy code where senior creditors are paid first, followed by junior lenders, administrative claims, unsecured lenders, and equity holders. Lauria asserts the senior secured creditors will receive 29 cents on the dollar while unsecured creditors are going to get $10 billion. He said this scenario has senior secured creditors subsidizing junior creditors, which conflicts with the United States bankruptcy code. The group of lenders Lauria represents includes Oppenheimer Funds, Stairway Capital, and other secured lenders including teachers’ credit unions, pension funds, retiree plans, college endowments, and retirement funds. In an interview on WJR radio in Detroit, Lauria claimed the Obama administration has put major pressure on one of his clients, claiming if they did not agree to the bankruptcy terms that the full force of the White House press core will be brought to bear against them. Fox News reports the person making the threat was auto task force member Steve Rattner.
HOW & WHY UAW OWNS CHRYSLER posted 05.04.09
Some are framing the Chrysler bankruptcy as a steal for the UAW and unjust treatment for the secured lenders who refused 33 cents on the dollar for their investment in Chrysler. They have a point. Under current bankruptcy law secured lenders or bondholders are to be paid before stockholders, but President Obama wants to change the rules. The bondholders have firm legal ground on which to object, and it's good that they are. There is no doubt that the UAW--with 55 percent of the shares of the company that emerges from bankruptcy--is the big winner. The Obama Administration was instrumental in making it happen.
The entire episode began with $4 gasoline which catapulted the automotive industry into the worst sales environment since the Great Depression. GM, Ford, and Chrysler were not prepared for such a sudden gyration in market demand; moving from hot-selling trucks and SUV’s to smaller, fuel-efficient cars, overnight. Critics would counter that for years the domestic industry has not paid enough attention to or provided sufficient resources to the development of smaller, fuel-efficient vehicles. $4 dollar gas was bad enough but when the housing crisis and foreclosure debacle ensued, people really quit spending money. The root cause of the housing crisis really dates back to the Carter and Clinton administrations, as both democrat presidencies wanted banks to eliminate the practice of red-lining, where banks would intentionally not lend to selected neighborhoods they deemed 'high risk'. Then, during the Bush administration, Congressmen Barney Frank and Senator Chris Dodd pushed hard to loosen up lending practices and insisted banks loan to higher-risk applicants. In the meantime government corporations Fannie May and Freddie Mac took some of these high-risk loans, bundled them with other mortgages, and sold them as derivatives to investors on Wall Street…and they were gobbled up like popcorn. When the foreclosures started (during the Bush administration), Wall Street knew the derivatives were bad, and thus began the bona fide banking bailout.
While $4 gas and the banking crisis played out, GM, Ford, and Chrysler were finally dealing with their own crisis which was legacy costs -- most notably retiree health care costs. It was a foregone conclusion that legacy costs had to be dealt with or the companies would fail. The concept of a VEBA (or trust fund), which would pay for retiree health care, was agreed to in principle by the companies and the UAW. The union would own and operate the trust fund but it would be paid for by the auto companies. Initially the plan was to fund the VEBA with cash and very little company stock, but then cash got tight, and the idea of funding a portion of the VEBA with more company-issued stock was pushed for by both the Bush and Obama administrations. In Chrysler’s case, so much of the VEBA is to be funded by company stock (close to $6 billion) that the VEBA trust fund will soon be the largest shareholder in the company.
From any measure, this is a huge victory for the UAW, and one that--given their record of labor strikes and adversarial relations with Chrysler--doesn’t seem deserved or just. But when a big company like Chrysler seeks and receives emergency loans from the federal government to stay solvent, they are subject to the whims and directions of who is in charge, President Barack Obama. $4 gas and the housing crisis put Chrysler in a very tough market situation that they simply could not climb out of. They needed a life-line from the U.S. government to stay in business. President Obama is saving Chrysler and simultaneously giving the UAW a huge prize. Timing and the convergence of these events has given the UAW a contemptible victory. They will have one seat on the board of directors and a 55 percent controlling interest in the company. UAW President Ron Gettlefinger has said the only way the VEBA will make it is if they can sell some company shares on the open market. Presumably those proceeds would be invested back into the VEBA, helping secure health care costs for existing and future Chrysler retirees.
FIAT MAY ACQUIRE GM EUROPE posted 05.04.09
Italian car maker Fiat has confirmed that they are in talks to acquire GM’s European operations. Fiat automobiles include Fiat, Alfa Romeo, and Ferrari brands. It is about to take a 35 percent in Chrysler without putting up any cash. Purchasing General Motor’s European operations, including Opel, is another bold step in making Fiat a major global automotive player. Like Chrysler in the United States, all is not well at Opel, which sells throughout Europe. Based in Germany, Opel says it needs $4.3 billion to get through the present economic crisis. The German government has said “no” to direct aid, but will assist a viable investor with loan guarantees. Fiat is not the only suitor for Opel. Canadian car parts maker Magna International has expressed interest and presented the German Economic Minister with a rough concept of how they would purchase and run Opel.
OBAMA IMPOSES BANKRUPTCY ON CHRYSLER posted 05.01.09
The breaking point for the Obama administration auto task force to impose bankruptcy was the holdout of hedge funds managers, who have a $7 billion stake in the company. Unlike many other financial institutions and stakeholders they would not agree to accept 33 percent for the value for their investment in Chrysler, which would have equaled around $2.3 billion. Now a bankruptcy judge will decide how much the hedge funds will receive. As per the bankruptcy agreement, Chrysler will receive an additional $6 to $8 billion more in federal loans to stay afloat. Chrysler had put itself in a tenuous position after borrowing $4 billion dollars from the U. S. Treasury Department in December of 2008. Since then the government has been involved with Chrysler and that involvement is scheduled to increase. For example, the U. S. government will appoint four new board members to the new Chrysler board of directors. New alliance partner Fiat will name three and the UAW and Canadian government will each name one. According to the Detroit Free Press one of the conditions of Fiat boosting its stake in Chrysler from 20 to 35 percent, was a requirement from the auto task force that Fiat-Chrysler design and build a 40-mile-per-gallon car in the United States. It’s plain to see that the Obama auto task force is taking an active and engaging role in running the company. This should be a huge red flag to General Motors if it wants to remain autonomous and independent – and avoid bankruptcy. If GM does go Chapter 11, the company will receive equal scrutiny. GM’s revised restructuring plan is due with the feds by June 1st. The other huge major twist in the Chrysler bankruptcy is who will become the largest shareholder -- and that will be the United Auto Workers, with a 55% controlling interest. That’s a result of the UAW agreeing to accept Chrysler stock instead of cash for a portion of the trust fund that will pay for retiree health care. Both the Bush and Obama administrations had been pushing the UAW to accept a portion of the trust in company stock, and for some time the union resisted. The VEBA, or Voluntary Benefits Association, is a $10 billion total amount for Chrysler, meaning the UAW is taking $6 billion in stock. It is an odd turn of events as the United Auto Workers employed by Chrysler -- with an long and adversarial history with their employer, will soon own the company. Some have suggested that President Obama made a sweetheart deal with the union, giving them controlling interest in the company. The holdout hedge funds get the raw deal, unless they previal in bankruptcy proceedings. It appears the union, ably assisted by the U.S. government has taken over the company. Quite a victory, particularly when you consider the trust fund is being paid for by Chrysler -- to pay for UAW retiree health care. The UAW will need to sell a good portion of their 55 percent share to fund their retiree health care trust fund. It will be interesting.
FEDS & UAW -- LARGEST GM SHAREHOLDERS posted 04.29.09
DETROIT -- In a move that must turn the stomach of many automotive insiders, the U.S. government is on track to become General Motors’ largest shareholder. The second largest shareholder is even stranger: the UAW retiree health care trust fund (VEBA). For some time President Obama’s auto task force has been pushing the UAW to accept a portion of the health care trust in the form of company stock. An agreement has been reached, and the result is the United Auto Workers will be second largest shareholder…right behind Uncle Sam. All this will come to fruition if GM’s restructuring plan is approved by President Obama’s auto task force, which is due by June 1st. In December, GM opened Pandora’s Box when it borrowed $13.4 billion from the federal government to stay solvent. One of the off shoots was the forced resignation of General Motors CEO Rick Wagoner, the designated governmental sacrificial lamb of the automotive meltdown. A GM spokesperson said he did not expect the auto task force to be in on day-to-day operations. How ironic that the United Auto Workers--with a history of extreme work rules and painful strikes--will be the second largest shareholder of the company. Does that mean the union will be able to strike or have a work stoppage against themselves? GM will need an additional $11.6 billion in government loans to keep operating after May 1st. If all goes well, long term the government loans willl be paid back, and the government will be out of the car business. We can hope.
GOODBYE PONTIAC posted 04.28.09
DETROIT -- In a much speculated move, General Motors has announced it will drop Pontiac as part of it restructuring plan. Not all is completely lost, as GM will likely try to find space for some of its more popular models like the G8. There is also speculation that the Vibe and the Solstice will become Chevrolets. Pontiac had some real winners in its past, most notably the GTO (designed and pushed by whiz kid John DeLorean) -- which remains one of the most popular muscle cars ever produced. The GTO was so popular it inspired the Beach Boys to write a hit song based on the American automotive icon. Most experts agree that Hummer and Saturn will either be sold or also shut down, leaving GM with four core brands: Chevrolet, Buick, Cadillac, and GMC. In a related move General Motors also announced it will eliminate 21,000 U.S. factory jobs. GM must submit its restructuring plan to the Obama administrations auto task force by June 1st.
UAW-CHRYSLER-FIAT-FEDS AGREE posted 04.27.09
DETROIT -- The United Auto Workers has reached an agreement with Chrysler LLC, Fiat, and the Obama administration regarding how to survive. Details have not been released, but according to the UAW the terms meet government requirements for reducing Chrysler’s debt. At issue for some time now has been how Chrysler will fund the $10.6 billion trust set up to pay for retiree health care. The Obama administration task force has been pressing the UAW to accept half of $10.6 billion in the form of stock rather than cash or debt for the trust. The trust fund, or VEBA, (Voluntary Employee Benefits Association) will be owned and managed by the UAW, and is an innovative step in helping resolve the legacy costs crisis that has so burdened the automotive industry. According to UAW President Ron Gettlefinger the deal/agreement will be presented to and voted on by members this week. Chrysler is facing an April 30th deadline to reduce debt and complete its alliance with Fiat, or face Chapter 11 bankruptcy.
GOVT PREPS FOR CHRYSLER BANKRUPTCY posted 04.24.09
NEW YORK CITY -- The New York Times is reporting that the U.S. Treasury Department is in the midst of preparing a Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing for Chrysler. Speculation is that proceedings could begin as early as next week. Chrysler, who borrowed $4 billion last year from the federal government, is facing an April 30th deadline to reduce debt and meet other terms laid out by the Obama administration’s auto task force. In order to stay solvent Chrysler has asked for additional emergency loans from the U.S. Treasury. The Times’ report says the Treasury Department has already worked an agreement in principle with the United Auto Workers which will protect pensions and retiree health care benefits. The Italian automaker Fiat would be allowed to complete its proposed alliance with Chrysler while the Detroit automaker is under bankruptcy protection.
GM WILL SHUT DOWN FOR NINE WEEKS posted 04.23.09
DETROIT -- General Motors is reportedly going to shut down most of its U.S. factories for up to nine weeks this summer. The reasons for the shut down are slumping sales and ample inventory of unsold vehicles. The exact date of the shutdown is not known, but sources say it will be around the normal two-week shutdown date in July as the automakers transition to the 2010 model year. GM has also been vigorously working to convince bondholders to voluntarily exchange $28 billion they are owed for a stake in the company. Regardless of the outcome General Motors has announced it will not pay June 1st-owed bond payments. So far this year industry sales have slipped 38.4 percent and GM’s U.S. sales are down 48.8 percent. During the nine-week idling, laid-off UAW workers will receive state unemployment benefits and company supplemental pay equal to roughly 70 percent of their gross pay.
General Motors operates 47 U. S. manufacturing facilities which employ 55,000 UAW members. In the last two years (2007 and 2008) GM has lost $70 billion.
AUTO TASK FORCE OUT OF CONTROL posted 04.20.09
DETROIT – The Obama administration’s auto task force is setting up a meeting with representatives of salaried retirees of GM, Ford, and Chrysler. The purpose is to hear the concerns of the salaried retirees who are deeply worried about their pensions, supplemental payments, and health care benefits -- particularly in light of possible bankruptcy. Unlike members of the UAW salaried retirees have little protection. A prime example is what happened to the salaried retirees of Delphi Corporation who lost their health care and life insurance benefits in 2005 as a result of bankruptcy. Sidenote, the cost savings for Delphi was $70 million per year. The auto task force has required Chrysler to complete their merger with Italian automaker Fiat by April 30th and show how the alliance of the two car makers would be profitable. The Obama administration has offered up to $6 billion in loans to the Chrysler-Fiat alliance, and it has been reported the government would also have a significant role in naming the new board of directors. Beyond having a the ability to loan--or more accurately, print--money, what qualifies the Obama auto task force to name who will sit on the board of Chrysler-Fiat? It’s a scary notion, and is only scarier when one considers the lack of any meaningful public outcry. General Motors faces a June 1st deadline to attain tougher concessions from bondholders and the UAW. GM will propose a bond exchange offer, which will be due by April 27th. No word on whether the auto task force has the courage or the will to help General Motors gain additional concessions from the United Auto Workers -- who still make $29 an hour plus benefits for unskilled labor at General Motors. Most analysts believe the wage should be closer to what foreign-owned car makers pay at plants in the U.S., which is around $10 less per hour. The salaried retirees will get the shakedown, as will the bondholders…but what about the UAW? It should be no wonder that the UAW has a pitiful public perception -- they deserve it. The auto task force should not treat the UAW as if it was a sacred cow, but at this point, it sure seems like they are.
AUTOS FACE SURGICAL BANKRUPTCY posted 04.14.09
DETROIT -- During a speech in Detroit Governor Jennifer Granholm said a surgical bankruptcy may be in the offing for the auto industry. Part of what the governor is hoping for is a willingness on the part of bondholders to bargain in good faith with the auto companies. She believes the deal bondholders will receive in pre-bankruptcy will be far superior to what they would receive from the courts in actual bankruptcy. Speculation has been heavy that GM or Chrysler will declare Chapter 11 bankruptcy. The auto companies need to gain concessions not only from bondholders but from active UAW members, who still are paid $29 per hour, plus benefits, at General Motors. Just like bondholders, the UAW will also get a better deal in pre-bankruptcy. The rank and file will be far better off to make a deal now, and give the auto companies a chance to survive without declaring Chapter 11. Bankruptcy court will not be anywhere near as accommodating. It’s time for both the bondholders and UAW to wake up and smell the coffee.
FEDS INVADE GM posted 04.09.09
DETROIT -- When a company borrows money from the federal government it leaves itself open to interference. Call it what you will, but the Obama administration has sent 15 members of the auto task force to Detroit under the supposition to help the company restructure by the June 1st federal deadline. An anonymous administration official says the auto task team members are being sent to accelerate the restructuring process. The group is lead by Harry Wilson, a former hedge fund executive. Other members include “experts” from the Boston Consulting Group and the investment bank Rothschild. Last week the Obama Administration rejected General Motors’ viability plan and also removed CEO Rick Wagoner in the process. The auto task force wants GM to gain further cuts from its bondholders and the UAW. The Obama Administration apparently has an idea of what the UAW wage should be, so why not circumvent GM and go directly to UAW President Ron Gettlefinger? Does the administration have the political will to deal with the UAW itself or will they leave that task to GM? From how it appears today, if GM is unable to gain wage concessions from the UAW, the Obama Administration may opt to force bankruptcy. If President Obama has the political will to remove Rick Wagoner then he should also have the courage and fortitude to help GM force wage concessions from the powerful UAW. New GM CEO Fritz Henderson says he expects members of the auto task force to be working at GM headquarters in Detroit straight through to the June 1st deadline to reorganize or else. Tough times at General Motors.
INTENSE BANRUPTCY PREPARATIONS @ GM posted 04.08.09
DETROIT -- According to Reuters, General Motors is in intense and earnest preparations for a possible Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing. A possible plan would be to split the company into a group of profitable units and a second entity comprised of less profitable units. Most experts agree GM’s successful units include Chevrolet, Buick, Cadillac, and GMC. Less profitable units include Pontiac, Hummer, Saab, and Saturn. Filing for bankruptcy protection would allow GM to start over with the UAW, dealers, and bondholders. While the UAW has made many substantial concessions, the one concession they have not backed down from is their hourly wage of $29 per hour for active UAW members -- which is about a third higher than what foreign automakers pay workers at U.S. plants. Moodys Investment Service believes there is a 70 percent probability of a bankruptcy in the automotive sector. Some experts believe the auto companies are just too big to emerge from bankruptcy and that the process will take longer than what people realize. In a Sunday appearance on Meet the Press GM CEO Fritz Henderson said that General Motors would not rule out the bankruptcy option, but that the company's preference would be to win in the markeplace.
MARCH AUTO SALES DOWN 36.8% -- ROCK BOTTOM? posted 04.03.09
DETROIT -- March 2009 U.S. auto sales dropped 36.8 percent from one year ago, but the overall sales slide actually significantly improved 24 percent from February 2009. Some feel that could be a signal the worst is over and that April sales could be stronger, aided by warmer weather which brings out more car buyers. The annualized selling rate in March was 9.9 million vehicles, contrasted with an annualized selling rate of 8.9 million last month. Specifically, GM was down 44.7 percent, Ford off 40.8 percent, and Chrysler’s sales slid 39.3 percent. By the raw numbers, in March 2009 U.S. car and truck sales were 857,735. That compares with March 2008 total U.S. vehicle sales of 1,356,926. The auto slump was clearly felt by foreign automakers as well. For March Toyota was off 37.7 percent, Honda down 36.3 percent, Nissan slipped 37.7 percent. Kia sales however were off just .6 percent, and its share of the U.S. market increased from 1.8 percent to 2.9 percent. Experts are unsure if the auto market has hit bottom, but point to the 24 percent increase in sales from February to March as a very positive sign.
CHRYSLER VIABILITY PLAN REJECTED posted 03.31.09
The Obama administration has rejected Chrysler’s viability plan. It listed several reasons for doing so including an over-reliance on North America for sales, shortcomings in quality, lack of products in the critical small car segment, and too little investment in vehicle architecture.
The auto task force did pledge $6 billion to Chrysler and allowed the automaker 30 days to complete its proposed alliance with Italian automaker Fiat. Fiat Group CEO Sergio Marchionne has said the alliance was forthcoming, which will improve Chrysler’s ability to offer smaller, fuel-efficient vehicles. While the report credited Chrysler for making some progress, it stated the automaker’s viability plan was insufficient due to several structural issues that the company faces--and is unlikely to overcome--as a stand-alone entity. The auto task force also said the viability report is based on overly optimistic assumptions. Some analysts have said bankruptcy is now more likely for Chrysler. Although the company itself may not survive analysts do believe some of its products will.
GM HAS 60 DAYS posted 03.31.09
The Obama administration’s auto task force will provide General Motors with an undisclosed amount of interim financing and 60 days to restructure the company. As part of the new government loan plan, it was required that GM CEO Rick Wagoner resign -- a move many claim will do more to impede than facilitate the automaker’s recovery. Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm characterized Wagoner’s forced resignation as being tantamount to that of a sacrificial lamb. It is also believed many members of GM’s board of directors will also step down. Obama’s auto task force wants GM to acquire additional concessions from the union, management, shareholders, bondholders, creditors, suppliers, and dealers. If those concessions are not acquired within 60 days, some type of bankruptcy may take place, that according to one official who spoke on the condition of anonymity. GM borrowed $17.4 billion and Chrysler $4 billion from the federal government late last year and now find themselves in the worst sales environment in 27 years. In its recently-submitted viability plan GM requested an additional $16.6 billion in government loans, and Chrysler an additional $6 billion. Together both companies employ 140,000 U.S. workers. Last month General Motors announced plans to eliminate 47,000 jobs around the globe (almost 20% of its work force), close hundreds of auto dealerships, and focus on four core brands: Chevrolet, Cadillac, GMC, and Buick.
GM'S WAGONER RESIGNS AT WHITE HOUSE REQUEST posted 03.30.09
Effective immediately General Motors Chairman Rick Wagoner will step down at the request of President Barack Obama. Late last year GM and Chrysler borrowed $17.4 billion in government loans in order to avoid bankruptcy. More recently the auto companies have requested an additional $21.6 billion. On the CBS news show Face The Nation, President Obama said stakeholders in the companies need to take additional steps and restructure to become more competitive. According to David Cole, Chairman of the Center for Automotive Research, Wagoner’s departure is tantamount to taking one for the team, and that he was disappointed because he believes Wagoner is a very capable leader. Many industry analysts credit Wagoner with doing more to restructure the industry than any other executive, most notably gaining historic concessions from the UAW on wage and retiree costs. Critics say GM has relied too heavily on truck and sport utility vehicles and that the companies were not prepared for the drastic market shift when gas hit $4 a gallon. Members of the auto task force say bankruptcy is still an option if management, workers, creditors, and shareholders fail to make sacrifices. Both GM and Chrysler are required to present their restructuring plans to the auto task force by March 31st. Since the President and his auto task force have the influence to remove the General Motors Chairman, it seems only appropriate they take the same action against UAW President Ron Gettlefinger. To date, the union has still not backed off it's $29 an hour wage plus benefits. Apparently the task of dealing with the over reach of union is GM's problem, not the president's auto task force. General Motors has lost an excellent dedicated chairman and executive, and there will likely be more resignations. Wagoner started with GM in 1977 and became Chairman in 2003.
GM WORKERS CALLED BACK posted 03.27.09
Some positive news from the auto industry: General Motors plans on bringing back to work an unspecified number of laid-off employees starting sometime in April. This is partly due to a new round of 7,600 hourly workers agreeing to a buyout or opting for retirement. Those agreeing to a buyout receive $20,000 in cash and $25,000 towards the purchase a new GM vehicle. Workers retiring will receive those same benefits plus health insurance and $3,150 a month pension. Since 2006 General Motors has shed 60,500 hourly jobs--approximately half of its work force--through buyouts and sweetend retirement offers. On another very positive note the automaker will also soon rid itself of retiree health care expenses, or legacy costs. GM is paying for a trust fund, or VEBA, which will be union-owned and managed, and will be responsible for covering retiree health expenses. The fact that GM is starting to call back some of its 7500 laid-off employees is a very positive development. Once all laid-off workers are called back, or retire, or accept a buy out, all new hires will start at $14.50 an hour; that’s about half of what active UAW members at GM currently make. The challenge is far from over, but recalling workers is a very encouraging sign for GM, and in that regard, also for the rest of the country.
BUICK #1 FOR DEPENDABILITY posted 03.23.09
In a JD Power vehicle dependability survey, Buick is the most reliable vehicle on the road, unseating Lexus after a 14-year reign at the top. The survey showed Buick and Jaguar had 122 problems per 100 vehicles, Lexus with 126, Toyota 129, and Mercury 134. The average was 170 problems per 100 vehicles. Despite Buick being rated number one for dependability, analyst say the market still has a negative bias against American car companies, and that it may take some time for the perception to change. The Buick Lacrosse was the highest rated mid-size car, while the Ford Ranger the most dependable midsize pickup. The Mercury MKZ was the top rated entry-level premium vehicle, and the Lincoln Mark LT was the most dependable large premium vehicle, a category comprised of trucks and SUVs. JD Power’s 2009 vehicle dependability measured problems experienced by owners of 2006 model year vehicles.
DECISION TIME FOR AUTOWORKERS posted 03.12.09
Autoworkers for GM and Chrysler have until March 24th and March 27th, respectively, to stay with their companies or accept a buyout. Sticking with their respective employer means taking a chance on whether GM and Chrysler will survive, or at least survive bankruptcy. Taking a buyout, meanwhile, means agreeing to a lump sum payment, but also looking for employment in a very tough job market. Chrysler's UAW members make about $29 per hour, or a base pay of $60,000. GM's UAW-represented workers make around $28 per hour. Right now Chrysler is offering buyouts of $50,000 to $75,000 plus a $25,000 car voucher. General Motors at one time offered buyouts of $140,000, but those numbers have been substantially reduced to $20,000 and a $25,000 car voucher. In a contract signed in 2007 the UAW agreed to allow some new hires to be paid $14 per hour with lower-cost pension and health benefits than older UAW workers. The auto companies are highly motivated to replace older workers with new workers at lower wage and benefit rates.
$71 AN HOUR FOR AUTOWORKERS posted 03.10.09
Press acounts have been wide-ranging regarding accurate hourly wages for an active UAW members of GM, Ford, and Chrysler. Recently $71 per hour has been quoted from a liberal and conservative source, namely the Detroit Free Press and Bill O’Reilly of Fox News. They both have cited that when retiree health care is factored in, the real number is $71 an hour, which equates to $156,000 per year. That is an overwhelming amount of money. The Free Press suggests that when retiree health is not factored in, the true hourly wage is less than $60 an hour…still a very attractive wage by any standard in this country. That means getting the VEBA--the trust fund funded by the car companies to pay for retiree health care--in place is crucial. Two years ago the car makers agreed to a figure of $56 billion which would fund the VEBA. Though Ford has already reached terms with the UAW on their VEBA, the $56 billion may not be enough to adequately fund the VEBA for GM and Chrysler. More than 540,000 retirees and spouses are expected to be covered by the VEBA, but that number will increase due to all the buyouts as of late. The auto companies are now discussing all options with the UAW, bondholders, and federal government on how to best proceed.
AUDITORS DOUBT GM CAN CONTINUE posted 03.06.09
The auditing firm Deloitte & Touche LLP has said there is “substantial doubt” that General Motors can continue operations due to massive losses and an inability to generate enough cash to fund operations. GM continues to battle on every front to survive and avoid Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Last year the company received a $13.4 billion bridge loan from the federal government, and has asked to borrow as much as $16.6 billion more. GM has until March 31st to submit a restructuring plan with the federal government, and many believe the deadline will be extended. Also of great concern is the financial health of the auto companies tier-one suppliers, which are now seeking $25.5 billion in federal loans. Experts say a breakdown in the automotive supply chain has the potential to drag down the industry by itself.
AUTO SLIDE CONTINUES posted 03.04.09
February auto sales continued to be dismal, with no improvement anticipated any time soon. The numbers are ugly: GM down 53%, Ford off 48%, and Chrysler slid 44%. For perspective, in raw numbers, GM sold 268,737 vehicles in February 2008, contrasted to 126,170 vehicles sold in February 2009. As reported previously on the MIWatchDog, numbers for foreign car makers are also way down. Toyota’s February sales fell 39.8%, Honda fell 38%, and Nissan was off 37%. On a positive note, according to the Southfield-based R.L. Polk & Company, the median age of a car in operation in the United States was 9.4 years old. This means that at some point, the pent-up demand for new vehicles may be the catalyst that lifts the industry out of its current slump. Another positive development, at least for the Big 3, is the sight re-emergence of a “Buy American” sentiment in the country, particularly in the automotive-driven states of Michigan, Ohio, and Indiana. Car dealers near Grand Rapids report increased customer sentiment to buy American.
GM LOSES $30.9 BILLION IN 2008 posted 02.27.09
General Motors reported a staggering $30.9 billion loss for 2008, the fourth straight annual loss for the automaker. The loss is emblematic of how tough times continue to rattle Detroit, the UAW, and the state of Michigan. Michigan leads the nation in unemployment at 10.6%. Since 2005 General Motors has lost $73 billion. Last year the company borrowed $13.4 billion from the government, and more recently GM has requested an additional $16.6 billion in additional federal loans. The housing crisis, $4 gasoline, and the credit crisis have all played a role in the downturn, which now has even extended to foreign rivals including Toyota. Toyota officials have stated they expect to lose $1.6 billion in fiscal 2008 (which ends in March 2009). Some press reports indicate the loss could be as high as $5 billion. It should be noted that Toyota is sitting on a mountain of cash, and is well poised to weather the current economic downturn; a dramatically different scenario then what American car makers face. Ford Motor Company posted a record loss of $14.6 billion for 2008. Some good news though -- GM, Ford, and Chrysler have all gained important concessions with the UAW, which will make them more competitive. However many of those concessions including lower hourly wages with the UAW will not kick in until 2010.
UAW & FORD AGREE ON VEBA posted 02.24.09
Ford has reached an agreement with the UAW on how to fund a trust that will pay for retiree health care costs. The agreement allows Ford to make cash payments to the union-managed trust with up to 50% of company stock instead of cash. This agreement frees up much needed cash for operations for Ford Motor. GM and Chrysler had already been directed to fund their respective VEBA with up to 50% of stock instead of cash, under terms of the $17.4 billion government loan. According to David Cole from the Center for Automotive Research, relieving auto companies from paying retiree health costs is a vital step in making them more competitive with foreign rivals. The money it will take to fund these trusts is immense. For example, Ford owes $6.3 billion to its VEBA at the end of this year. GM will have to pay approximately $20 billion into its VEBA, and Chrysler will pay around $9.9 billion. The trusts will pay health care for 800,000 UAW retirees, spouses, and dependents. GM has said it expects to save about $3 billion a year, and Ford says it will save $1 billion every year. The UAW and the auto makers deserve credit for battling through many tough circumstances as of late. Reaching an agreement on funding the Ford VEBA is another example of many concessions made by the union. The VEBA also represents a tremendous opportunity for the UAW. The union will be one of the largest purchasers of health care in the country, and could use the instrument of the VEBA and purchasing power to improve the nation’s health system and, in turn, the lives of millions of Americans. Read more about the UAW and it’s recent historical changes in this MIWatchDog editorial: Historic changes for UAW.
GM CUTS 47,000 JOBS - REQUESTS ANOTHER $17 BILLION posted 02.18.09
General Motors’ proud 100-year history is being tested. In a 100-page report (dated 02.17.09) submitted to the federal government, the automaker says it plans to close another five manufacturing facilities and eliminate 47,000 jobs. With GM employing 244,000 workers worldwide – that translates to one out of every five workers losing their jobs. GM also said it may need another $17 billion in loans in order to remain solvent; this would be in addition to the $13.4 billion the government has already agreed to loan the car maker. Chairman Rick Wagoner said the plan would make General Motors profitable within 24 months. On the flip side Wagoner said the bankruptcy option would actually require more funding -- as much as $100 billion to pull the company through bankruptcy proceedings. By 2012 GM will eliminate another 20,000 U.S. jobs and close 14 additional plants. General Motors plans on phasing out the Saturn brand sometime after 2011 unless the dealer network can come up with a better idea. The car company is also considering how to dispose of Hummer by the end of March. This is clearly the most difficult challenging time the American auto industry has ever faced.
CHRYSLER NEEDS ANOTHER $5 BILLION posted 02.18.09
In a report filed with the federal government, Chrysler LLC says it will need an additional $5 billion to remain solvent. The automaker has disclosed it lost $8 billion in 2008, and claims that if it does not receive the federal money by March 31st, that it will immediately seek a court-supervised liquidation. This sought after money would be in addition to the $4 billion that Chrysler received last year. The car maker plans to cut an additional 3000 jobs and eliminate Chrysler Aspen, Dodge Durango, and the Chrysler PT Cruiser as part of its restructuring plan. The company is also cutting costs by $700 million, will sell $300 million in assets, and slash its factory capacity by 100,000 vehicles. In the event of bankruptcy, Chrysler officials say Chapter 11 bankruptcy would likely cost the company $20 to $25 billion.
UAW FIGHTS TO KEEP FREE LEGAL SERVICES posted 02.17.09
The coveted benefit of free legal services for UAW members could be on the chopping block. In on-going talks with Ford Motor Company, the union is hoping to keep the benefit that has been used by three of four UAW members. Fully-paid legal services provided include residential real estate, wills, adoption, personal bankruptcy, probate proceedings, and consumer debt. The UAW Legal Services Plan was originally established in 1978 and currently provides personal legal services to 725,000 workers, spouses, and retirees. It is the largest pre-paid legal services program in the nation, which currently operates from 69 locations and employs 290 attorneys. The program is funded by automakers and is based on the number of hours worked by UAW members. Companies that currently offer the UAW Legal Services Plan to its union employees include Ford, GM, Chrysler, Delphi Corporation, and American Axle & Manufacturing.
AUTO COMPANIES-UAW-DEADLINE-PRESSURE posted 02.16.09
The pressure is on. For example there is the February 17th deadline GM and Chrysler have to submit their plans to the federal government on how they will survive and re-pay billions of dollars in loans. The plan could detail additional plant closures, potential elimination of brands, and the elimination of thousands of jobs. A final version of the plan must be submitted by March 31st. Also the car makers are in difficult and sensitive talks with the UAW regarding how to fund the new VEBA (Voluntary Employee Benefits Association) or trust fund that was set up to pay for UAW retiree health care. The auto companies want the union to accept company stock in place of cash payments to fund some portions of the VEBA, which the UAW will own and control. Meanwhile, January auto sales got off to a slow start -- down 37% from last year…and now Toyota and other foreign makers are caught up in the economic downturn. Toyota’s 2008 U. S. sales were down 15%, and the last two months have seen sales dip 34% and 37%, respectively. However, Toyota has ample cash reserves and can withstand a slow down much easier U.S. automakers.
JANUARY AUTO SALES HISTORIC AND MISLEADING posted 02.05.09
U.S. auto sales continued their poor performance; down 37% in January. But after taking a closer look at the numbers, the news isn’t quite so grim. For example, GM reported a sales decline of 49%, but retail sales through dealerships were actually off 38%. What skewed the numbers for GM was the drop in large fleet sales, down 80% in January. The car maker has vowed to reduce its fleet sales under the rationale that it lessens the appeal and value of vehicles sold at their dealerships. Ford Motor Company, meanwhile, saw its January sales fall 40% while Chrysler was down 35%. On a positive note, showroom traffic was up at Michigan dealerships. Local dealers in Cadillac, Saginaw, and Detroit all reported higher traffic, particularly towards the end of the month. On an annualized basis, January sales would equate to 9.8 million units sold in 2009. Another noteworthy statistic is that foreign automakers as well continue to struggle in the U.S. market. Toyota saw sales plunge 34% in January. Perhaps the most historic and overlooked statistic from January auto sales comes from China. According to a GM official, due to the U. S. economic downturn, for the first time in history more cars were sold in China than in the United States on a monthly basis. It is expected that January auto sales in China will reach 750,000 vehicles; that’s compared to 656,976 sold in the U.S. market for the same month -- the lowest monthly total in 26 years.
It could signal that China is on the verge of becoming the largest automotive market in the world. The same GM official estimates 2009 total vehicle sales in China should reach 10.7 million. 2009 estimates for U. S. sales have ranged anywhere from 9 million to 12 million vehicles. Both GM and Ford are well-positioned to compete in China. In fact, the number one selling foreign import in China is Buick. Due to historic and cultural differences, Japanese car makers are at a distinct disadvantage in China.
GM TO ELIMINATE (SUSPEND) JOB BANKS posted 01.29.09
One of the mandates of the $17.4 billion bridge loan reads as follows: eliminate "the payment of any compensation or benefits to U.S. employees of the company or any subsidiary who have been fired, laid-off, furloughed, or idled, other than customary severance pay." That language in effect invalidates job banks; so next Monday GM will eliminate its job banks program that pays laid-off UAW members up to 95% of their wage for up to two years. A GM spokesman said the existing 1600 GM workers enrolled in the program will need to file for unemployment. On January 26th Chrysler eliminated its job banks program. UAW officials declined comment about GM’s announcement, but earlier this week stated that job banks will only be suspended while the government auto bridge loans are in effect. Though Ford has not borrowed any money from the federal government, they too are expected to stop their job banks program. Though staunchly defended by the UAW, job banks has been a very controversial program that has triggered intense criticism of the auto companies.
STATES CLOSER TO INDIVIDUAL EMISSIONS STANDARDS posted 01.28.09
Following through on a campaign promise, President Barrack Obama has ordered the EPA to review California’s, and 13 other states, request to impose tailpipe emissions standards that exceed federal guidelines. The auto companies have lost a series of lawsuits to block California from setting their own mileage requirements, and have asserted that varying standards would be cost prohibitive – tallying as much as $30 billion. Under a 2007 energy law, the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration requires a fleet-wide average of 35 miles per gallon by 2020, but California’s standards go far beyond that to 42.5 miles per gallon by 2020. A spokesman for the National Automobile Dealers Association said varying standards will only further endanger an already fragile industry. The auto companies find themselves in another difficult spot, just one month after the government loaned $17.4 billion to GM and Chrysler to avoid bankruptcy; that’s a tough position from which to negotiate.
CHRYSLER JOB BANKS PROGRAM SUSPENDED ON JANUARY 26TH
posted 01.26.09
In a letter authored by a UAW vice-president, the union announced it will suspend the controversial job banks program with Chrysler effective January 26th. Stopping job banks, albeit temporarily, is necessary in order to comply with mandates in the federal loan agreement that gave Chrysler $4 billion in order to stay in business. Employees being paid in the job banks program will be placed on unemployment. Meantime, negotiations continue with the UAW and General Motors to suspend its job banks program. Last month UAW President Ron Gettlefinger agreed to suspend the job banks program, but also said the program had already been drastically scaled back and was a mere shadow of its former self. There are 3500 UAW members currently being paid from the job banks program, 1400 from GM, 1400 from Ford, and 700 from Chrysler. Going by statements made by Gettlefinger and other union officials it appears the UAW has every intention of reinstating job banks once the federal loans are paid back. Job banks has been a real sore spot with the American people, because it pays UAW members 95% of their wage for up to two years for not working. While some job banks participants volunteered in their local community, they are not required to volunteer. Chrysler and General Motors must present viability plans to the government by Feb. 17th and persuade the government they are viable by March 31 or face losing the loans.
UAW TALKS UNDERWAY WITH GM & CHRYSLER
posted 01.22.09
Only days ago UAW President Ron Gettlefinger said that reaching federally-mandated wage concessions by February 17th was unattainable. His tone has changed and now Gettlefinger says talks are not only underway with GM and Chrysler, but also that an agreement will be reached by the February 17th deadline. However, he stressed the union will not be the only stakeholder that makes a financial sacrifice. Terms of the $17.4 billion government bridge loan require UAW members to have pay, benefits, and work rules similar to U.S. autoworkers at foreign-owned auto plants. In a separate matter, Gettlefinger announced the UAW Chrysler National Training Center on Jefferson Avenue in Detroit is for sale. The center, which opened in 1985, was used for educating and training UAW members.
CHRYSLER & FIAT ALLIGN posted 01.21.09
In a huge development, Chrysler and Fiat have agreed to form a new strategic alliance. The agreement gives the Italian auto maker a 35% stake in Chrysler with the possibility of full control down the road. Fiat will not invest any cash but will gain access to the huge U.S. market. Chrysler benefits by having access to smaller cars made by Fiat in addition to a network of dealerships to sell vehicles outside the U.S. market. Fiat shares on the Milan stock exchange were up 4% on the news, to $6.04 share. The alliance provides both companies with crucial new market access that they need to be global players in the competitive automotive industry. Chrysler sales were down 30% in 2008 and that includes a whopping 53% drop in December alone. Fiat’s 3rd quarter sales were up 1.8%. However, since then, Fiat has laid off 50,000 workers for one month due to a sales slow-down in their key Italian home market. This isn’t the first alliance Fiat has had with an American car company. In 2005, Fiat dissolved an alliance agreement with General Motors, which was concluded with GM paying Fiat $2 billion.
GETTLEFINGER, “UAW CAN’T MEET DEADLINE” posted 01.20.09
UAW President Ron Gettlefinger says the February 17, 2009 deadline to complete their restructuring plan with the auto makers is unattainable, and that no formal talks have even begun between union and the car makers. Last month the Treasury Department gave $17.4 billion in loans to GM and Chrysler, and per the agreement the companies are required to submit a detailed restructuring plan by February 17th, which includes significant concessions from the both the UAW and bondholders. Should GM and Chrysler not achieve “viability” by March 31st, the loans may be called back by the government. Gettlefinger said that the union is currently reviewing the loan documents, but that the union is clearly opposed to wage concessions (which would make them competitive with U.S. employees at Japanese auto plants). It’s appears the UAW will request the Obama Administration to re-open the agreement. Gettlefinger stated, “All we want is for the Obama administration to be fair, as opposed to somebody taking a shot at organized labor”.
NEW GM PLANT IN MICHIGAN -- 100 NEW JOBS TO START posted 01.13.09
General Motors, Michigan’s largest corporation and the third largest in the world, will soon be reinvesting in the state by constructing a new battery plant at a yet-to-be- determined location in Southeast Michigan. It means GM will be the first automaker on the planet to build its own lithium-ion batteries. The facility will be small by automotive standards -- costing $30 million dollars to construct and employing 100 workers, at least initially. Construction will begin later this year with the first batteries set to be produced sometime in 2010, which will be installed in the revolutionary Chevy Volt -- GM’s new extended-range electric vehicle. The Chevy Volt can travel 40 miles by battery power, meaning many Americans with shorter commutes will not have to fill their gas tank again. According to Michigan Economic Development Corporation President James Epolito, the GM battery plant could become the first of many alternative-energy manufacturing operations in the state, an industry that could employ as many as 50,000 workers in the next five years. In addition to the new battery plant, GM will also be constructing a 31,000 square foot development and testing lab, the largest of its kind in the world.
UAW MUST LOWER WAGES...OR ELSE posted 01.09.09
Previously-undisclosed terms of the $13.4 billion auto bridge loan for GM calls for the UAW to agree to lower wages commensurate with those paid to auto workers at foreign-owned US plants. Initial reaction from UAW President Ron Gettlefinger has been that the union will not re-open contracts. Another provision of the bridge loan is that the UAW cannot strike against the auto companies (the union already has a no-strike clause in its contract with GM thru September 2011), and also that the union is required to accept two-thirds of the money due for the health care trust fund (VEBA) in company stock rather than cash or company debt. The agreement requires the UAW to accept the terms no later than by February 17th, 2009 and that the new wage concessions take effect no later than December 31st, 2009. GM has until December 29th, 2011 to pay back the $13.4 billion loan to the federal government. The union has vowed to push congress and the incoming Obama administration to change the terms in the auto bridge loan.
DECEMBER AUTO SALES SINK 35.5% posted 01.06.09
As anticipated, 2008 December auto sales dropped 35.5% from 2007, culminating a miserable year for the industry. Even the foreign manufacturers were down substantially in December; for example Toyota sales plunged 36.7%; Honda was off 34.7 %; and Nissan December sales fell 30.7 %. For the domestics, GM fell 32.7 %; Ford down 32.2 %; and Chrysler off a whopping 53.1 %. For the 2008 year, total industry sales were 13.2 million; that compares to 16.1 million vehicles sold in 2007, which represents an overall 18% drop -- the worst industry sales levels since 1992. Analysts are predicting even lower sales for 2009, possibly around 12 million total vehicle sales. On the positive side, lower gas prices have helped stimulate large pickup and crossover vehicle sales, which had previously been the lifeblood of the industry, prior to $4.20 per gallon gasoline. In addition, the $5 billion cash infusion to GMAC by the US Treasury Department is helping to loosen up the credit markets.
|
|
GRANHOLM WANTS FEDERAL BAILOUT FOR STATE BUDGET
posted 7.22.10
It’s a familiar story. As the October 1st state budget deadline draws near, Michigan faces another substantial budget deficit. For fiscal 2011 Michigan is in the red $1.3 billion. It marks the ninth year in a row Michigan has faced a budget crisis (which includes the entire term of Governor Jennifer Granholm). To fix the 2011 budget dilemma Granholm is turning to the same old playbook, including a partial bailout from the feds. The governor is hoping Michigan will receive $560 million from the federal government in the form of Medicaid funding. It doesn’t take care of the entire shortfall, but it does address a sizeable portion. The feds have already given Michigan $3 billion in bailout money in the last two fiscal years, 2009 and 2010.
Michigan’s problems will continue until politicians have the guts to implement a complete tax overhaul. The state needs a multi-faceted plan similar to one outlined by Business Leaders of Michigan. The political favoritism—like not taxing private and public pensions—has to stop. Every individual and every business should pay their fair share, including retirees. Taxing pensions would generate $700 million in annual revenue for the state treasury. Also, Michigan can’t afford to have state employees retire at 50 years of age or younger. Healthcare costs for retired state employees are a big part of the problem, along with escalating prison costs and entitlement programs for the poor. The Dems want to tax services, which would make sense, but only in conjunction with a complete tax overhaul. This piecemeal, tax-quilt approach of bad legislation is leading Michigan into a dark economic hole. Adding another layer like taxing services would be cataclysmic. Ultimately Michigan needs to eliminate all income taxes and replace it with a consumption tax (you pay a tax on anything you purchase or consume). That’s an economic model that will lift Michigan, and make it more competitive with other states.
US SENATE CLOSE ON UNEMPLOYMENT EXTENSION
posted 7.21.10
Despite a bulging federal deficit, the US Senate passed a cloture vote to extend unemployment benefits at a cost of $34 billion. While more votes will be necessary it appears the Democrats have won this fight. Benefits will be paid through November and the cost will be added to the federal deficit. Republicans are pushing any extension of jobless benefits be paid for from federal stimulus funds, and not be added to the national debt ($13.2 trillion, FYI). The National Debt Awareness Campaign predicts that the US debt will rise to $19.6 trillion by 2015.
Paying someone not to work disincentives them to seek employment. It keeps them in a false comfort zone and lessens their state of urgency. A social safety net is reasonable, but extension after extension is not good for those receiving benefits, or the country as a whole. Poverty is a hell of a motivator. At some point the unemployed must take a look in the mirror.
OBAMA BLAMES REPUBLICANS FOR BLOCKING JOBLESS EXTENSION
posted 7.20.10
How many times can you extend unemployment benefits? By President Obama’s standards, benefits should be maintained so long as the nation’s unemployment rate is 9 percent or above. That’s specifically what Press Secretary Robert Gibbs stated during a White House press conference. Obama has been vilifying Republicans for blocking the extension of unemployment benefits. But the argument isn’t so much about whether or not to extend the benefits as it his how to pay for the $34 billion extension. Republicans want to tap unspent federal stimulus dollars for the cost (there is still $400 billion left to spend), while the Democrats want to add it to the burgeoning federal deficit.
There is a limit to excess spending, and the U.S. government has crossed the line. Social Security, the U.S. Postal Service, Medicare, and Medicaid are financial failures that are draining the U.S. Treasury. The federal government’s 2010 fiscal deficit is $1 trillion; that’s $1000 billion, a number of astronomical proportions. Americans are deeply concerned about the federal deficit and justifiably so. The country simply cannot keep spending money it does not have regardless of how good the cause may be – not without severe economic consequences. Republicans should stand their ground and at least force the President to tap remaining federal stimulus dollars to extend unemployment benefits.
MI UNEMPLOYMENT DIPS TO 13.2 %
posted 7.15.10
There continues to be modest signs of economic improvement in Michigan. The state’s June unemployment rate fell to 13.2 percent, down from 13.6 in May. It marks the ninth consecutive month that Michigan’s jobless rate has fallen or held steady. The rate is down two full percentage points from a recent high of 15.3 percent, reached in September of 2009. On a national basis Michigan no longer leads the nation in unemployment; after six years that dubious distinction is now held by Nevada, which posted a 14 percent jobless rate for May.
According to the Department of Energy, Labor, and Economic Growth, between June 2009 and June 2010, payroll jobs in Michigan increased slightly by .6 percent. It is a net gain of 23,000 jobs over the last twelve months, a dramatic turnaround from calendar 2009 when the state lost an astounding 230,000 payroll jobs. The biggest job gainer for Michigan so far this year has come from the manufacturing sector, boasting 30,000 new jobs, followed by 24,000 in professional and business services, and 9,000 in education and health services.
WILL MICHIGAN LEAD NATION OUT OF THE RECESSION?
posted 7.06.10
Things are getting better in Michigan. For the first time in six years Michigan no longer leads the nation in unemployment; that embarrassing statistic now belongs to Nevada, with a 14 percent jobless rate (May 2010) compared to Michigan’s 13.6 rate. The number is still far too high, but it is down from a recent high of 15.3 percent in September of last year. After ten years of job losses, Michigan will actually gain jobs next year. According to U of M economist George Fulton, Michigan will add 41,000 jobs next year. The state endured a cataclysmic 2009 when a whopping 230,000 jobs were lost. Over the last ten years the state has seen a total of 900,000 jobs disappear.
Detroit car makers are making a recovery. Ford in particular has been on a terror with a $2.7 billion profit last year. GM has come back from the depths of government bankruptcy and has posted its first quarterly profit since 2007. Chrysler has partnered and survived. Both Ford and GM have moved up substantially in the J.D. Power rankings for quality and reliability. In fact, the domestics achieved their highest rankings in 24 years. Of equal importance is the solid market position of Ford and GM in the growing Chinese automotive market. China is now the largest automotive market in the world, surpassing the U.S. market last year.
Sure…anything can happen in Michigan. Some are predicting a double-dip recession, and that could derail the state’s economic recovery. The President could triangulate and maintain the Bush tax cuts, which would greatly assist. It would be a brilliant political and strategic move, but it is unlikely. At least the fear and job loss appears to be over in Michigan. Even treading water is better then sinking. We’ve stopped the bleeding and are on the mend.
ANOTHER DROP IN MICHIGAN UNEMPLOYMENT
posted 6.17.10
Hey, here’s some good economic news! Michigan’s unemployment rate fell to 13.6 percent in May. That marks eight consecutive months Michigan’s jobless rate has held steady or decreased, dating back to September 2009, when the jobless rate hit 15.3 percent. U of M economist George Fulton predicts Michigan will add 41,000 jobs next year, and that forecast will likely be adjusted upward. By contrast, in 2009 Michigan lost over 230,000 jobs, a devastating economic blow that the state survived. The state is far from being out of the jungle, but the downward unemployment trend is encouraging. Should the automotive recovery continue, Michigan may even lose the distinction of the having the highest unemployment rate in the nation. Other contenders include Rhode Island and California with seasonally adjusted April jobless rates of 12.4 and 12.3, respectively.
MI WILL GAIN 41,000 JOBS NEXT YEAR
posted 05.28.10
A month ago the acclaimed University of Michigan economic forecast predicted Michigan would add 20,400 jobs in 2011. The trending of good news continues with the revised May forecast, by economist George Fulton, which predicts the state will add 41,000 jobs next year. It is another positive development for Michigan’s recovering economy. It would be the first year of job growth in the state since 2000, ending a painful 10-year stretch of historic job losses. Michigan lost over 900,000 jobs in the last ten years, including a record loss of 230,200 jobs in 2009 (the year of GM and Chrysler bankruptcies).
The U of M forecast also predicts that by the end of 2011 Michigan’s unemployment rate, which now stands at 14 percent, will fall to 12.9 percent. Credit the auto industry for making a slow but steady comeback. Michigan is loaded with challenges on multiple fronts, but there are signs of improvement. Ford posted a $2.7 billion profit last year and GM posted its first quarterly profit since 2007 in the first quarter of this year. So far for 2010 the state of Michigan has collected more sales tax revenue than previously budgeted -- by $294 million. The state still has a $1.4 billion budget deficit in 2011, and our unemployment rate leads the nation. True, Michigan still has a long way to go, but there are small signs of encouragement…something to celebrate and be grateful for this holiday weekend.
(sources: Detroit Free Press, MIwatchDog)
MI JOBLESS RATE DOWN SLIGHTLY
posted 05.20.10
There is another sliver of good news for the Michigan economy. The state’s April unemployment rate fell slightly, by one-tenth of a percentage point, to 14 percent. It’s more validation that Michigan has stopped the bleeding when it comes to job loss. Since September of 2009, when the unemployment rate hit 15.3 percent, Michigan’s jobless rate has either held steady or decreased. April’s jobless rate of 14 percent is the lowest since June of 2009. The nation’s April jobless rate increased to 9.9 percent. Michigan’s economy has a long way to go, but with Ford and now GM showing profitability, the chances of recovery are much greater. Despite calls for greater diversity, Michigan is inescapably linked to the automotive sector.
(sources: Detroit News, MIWatchDog.com)
MI JOBLESS RATE HOLDS STEADY
posted 04.15.10
Michigan’s unemployment rate held steady in March, staying unchanged at 14.1 percent -- well above the U.S. jobless rate of 9.7 percent. The state seems to have stopped the bleeding when it comes to losing jobs, but still leads the nation with the highest unemployment rate. In March of 2009, during the intensity of the GM and Chrysler bankruptcy, the unemployment rate was 15.2 percent. On the down side, according to University of Michigan economists, the state’s unemployment rate will not appreciably improve until 2011. U of M forecasters project Michigan will add 20,000 jobs next year. For the rest of 2010 the state is expected to lose more jobs—about 39,000—which unfortunately compares favorably to 2009 when Michigan hemorrhaged 230,000 jobs. The state has been through the grinder, and the road to recovery remains a challenge. Michigan has a projected 2011 fiscal deficit of $1.8 billion. Try as we might to diversify, the fact remains the state’s fortunes remain closely tied to the automotive sector. If Ford continues to gain U.S. market share and GM’s comeback takes hold, the state’s recovery will begin, unless it is derailed by new taxes paid to Lansing or Washington D.C.
50% PAY NO INCOME TAX, SOME GET BONUS CHECKS
posted 04.13.10
The story has been making the rounds in print and on talk radio: According to the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center, 47 percent of Americans will pay no income tax for 2009. Two years ago 38 percent of Americans paid no federal income tax. It’s a disturbing trend, fewer tax payers responsible for a higher burden of the tax load. In fact some taxpayers in the lower 40 percent are receiving a bonus check from the federal government in the form of an earned income tax credit. For example, the $800 “Making Work Pay” credit is available for some working couples and provides a tax credit for purchasing a car, home, or energy-saving equipment. The long standing $1000-per-child tax increase remains intact, resulting in bonus checks of $4000 to $5000 on the extreme for some families. The U.S. tax code penalizes achievement and subsidizes slackers. Most people have no idea of how much they spend on taxes every year or the number of different taxes they are required to pay. Here’s a short list: federal income tax, state income tax, state sales tax, property tax, capital gains tax, the death tax (which will be reinstated next year), personal property tax, cable TV tax, landline phone tax, cellular phone tax, gas tax, and taxes paid on monthly utility bills…to name a few. The American people are overtaxed in an archaic system that rewards failure and pinches achievers. A consumption tax or fair tax that replaces all income taxes is the fairest and most viable economic tax model. The trend of more Americans who pay no federal income tax and fewer taxpayers shouldering a higher burden is a sign of a failing tax system. It is a model that cannot sustain.
(sources: Grand Rapids Press, MIwatchdog)
10-YEAR MICHIGAN JOB DROUGHT IS OVER
posted 04.08.10
According to a University of Michigan forecast, the state of Michigan will see job growth in 2011. That’s a change from the November forecast which called for a job loss of 16,300 in 2011. The updated economic forecast says Michigan will gain 20,400 jobs next year, which would reverse a 10-year continual period of job loss. The revised forecast also calls for a 2010 job loss of 39,300, which is down from the November estimate of 60,300. The report says an improving economy and stronger auto sales are and will continue to slow job losses. Stopping the bleeding is certainly welcome news, and hopefully the U of M report will be accurate. In 2009 the state withstood a record job loss of 230,200, which was devastating, particularly in the automotive corridor of Saginaw-Flint-Detroit. That led to a 3-percent decline in personal income and a 0.7 percent decline in consumer prices, the first deflationary calendar year in Michigan since 1949. The U of M forecast also predicts state personal income will rise 0.9 percent this year and 2.2 percent in 2011. However, those gains are also tempered by lower after-tax real disposable income, falling 0.6 percent this year, and 0.9 percent in 2011. According to the forecast the chief culprit is inflation and higher federal taxes. It’s worth noting the U.S. budget deficit is expected to reach $1.5 trillion for fiscal 2010. ObamaCare, the President’s moral imperative, will act as a hindrance to the nation’s economic recovery; though the American economy is so resilient, innovative, and productive, it could even outpace ObamaCare. But Americans could soon face additional taxes, not only in the form of healthcare, but also a new national type of sales tax. There’s been some high talk in Washington D.C. about pushing a VAT (Value Added Tax) or national sales tax. Obama advisor Paul Volcker says, “If at the end of the day we need to raise taxes, we should raise taxes.” A VAT tax is what many European countries use to fund their national health care, and many pundits suggest that is where the United States is heading. Nancy Pelosi is on record for supporting a national sales tax. Most Democrats have never met a new idea or increase they didn’t endorse. It’s what Democrats do: raise and think of new ways to tax the producers of this country so they can redistribute the money for their growing listing of moral imperatives in the name of the public good. We all want safety nets, and to take care of those who are unable to care for themselves. We all want health insurance abuse to end and for Americans to be treated fairly by their health insurance coverage providers. The push back from ObamaCare is real and not going away. Every legal and plausible avenue to repeal will be vigorously pursed. The Democrats should be careful not do derail Michigan’s and the nation’s economic recovery by taxing Americans so much they hole up in their houses and quit spending.
(sources: Mlive, MIwatchdog)
BAD ECONOMY STIMULATES SELF EMPLOYMENT
posted 04.05.10
Entrepreneurship is on the rise in Michigan and around the country. According to the Small Business Administration, the number of self-employed among people 55-64 jumped a whopping 52 percent from 2000 to 2007. That equates to a new record of 5 million self-employed people in the United States. The numbers will increase even more once 2008 and 2009 are factored in. Many of those starting their own business are in their 50s after working years with the same company. Downsizing and mergers has forced thousands to reexamine their future and take a completely unchartered course by opening their own business. Technology—including the computer, internet, and software—has made getting into business more practical. Traditionally only one-in-ten new businesses makes it past the first year. Most economists agree small business will be the engine of growth for the U.S. economy. To that end the rise in self employment is a very positive sign.
(sources: Kalamazoo Gazette, MIwatchdog)
MI JOBLESS RATE FALLS
posted 03.10.10
According to the Michigan Department of Energy, Labor, & Economic Growth, Michigan’s January unemployment rate dipped slightly to 14.3 percent. That’s down two-tenths of a percentage point from December’s revised rate of 14.5 percent, and also down one full percentage point of September recent peak of 15.3 percent. Good news for the state, and continues a four-month trend of a reduction in the state’s jobless rate. By the raw numbers, Michigan gained 11,000 jobs in January and lost 7000. Recent market gains and called back auto workers at Ford and General Motors have helped. For the last two years Michigan has lead or has been tied with another state for the nation’s highest unemployment rate. Maybe that’s about to change.
LIQUID WEB -- ON FIRE IN LANSING
posted 01.04.10
DELTA TOWNSHIP – Lansing-based Liquid Web was started by Matthew Hill at the tender age of 15. Liquid Web’s original focus was that of web design, but it quickly morphed into a web hosting company, which generated $1 million in revenue within only a few years. Now at 29 years of age entrepreneur Matthew Hill’s company is doing over $27 million in revenue and employs 165 employees. Liquid Web has 20,000 customers in more than 120 countries. The company is expected to grow to 600 total employees over the next few years. Liquid Web operates out of three facilities in the Lansing area including its new 90,000-square-foot headquarters, which has the capacity to hold 35,000 servers. INC Magazine named Liquid Web as one of the nation’s fastest growing companies for both 2007 and 2008. For more information go to their website: www.liquidweb.com.
(Sources: Lansing State Journal, Liquid Web)
MI UNEMPLOYMENT DROPS TO 14.7%
posted 12.17.09
LANSING -- Michigan’s jobless rate fell in November to 14.7 percent, down from 15.1 percent in October. 14.7 percent is the state’s lowest unemployment rate in the last six months. The nation’s November unemployment rate also dropped slightly to 10 percent, down from 10.2 percent in October. A .4 percentage point drop is significant and could be the start of a turnaround. Michigan’s unemployment rate topped out at 15.3 percent in September. The state has led the nation in unemployment for most of the last four years.
Here are the jobless percents from the last 12 months:
Dec. (’08) 10.6%; January 11.6%; February 12.0%; March 12.6%; April 12.9%;
May 14.1%; June 15.2%; July 15.0%; August 15.2%; September 15.3%; October 15.1%; November 14.7%.
According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, from a historical basis Michigan’s highest jobless rate was 16.9 percent, recorded in November 1982.
SAGINAW HOPES TO LAND 500 NEW JOBS posted 11.27.09
SAGINAW – GlobalWatt, a California-based solar panel manufacturer, will soon invest $177 million in either Saginaw, Michigan or an unnamed community in Texas. It will result in 500 jobs for the fortunate community. The new facility will develop technology for solar collectors for roofs and farms. It will also manufacture sun-powered irrigation material and military solar panel systems that can operate independent of traditional power sources. Should GlobalWatt choose Saginaw it will locate at the closed Enterprise Automotive Systems facility at 1200 Leon Scott. According to a company spokesperson 100 new jobs would be added every year from 2010 to 2015. Saginaw could also gain another 500 jobs in nearby Thomas Township. Norcross, a Georgia-based solar energy company, is considering investing $250 million to build a new facility near Hemlock Semi Conductor.
PONTIAC SILVERDOME SOLD FOR $583,000 posted 11.24.09
PONTIAC -- What a bargain...what a deal! Canadian Company Triple A has purchased the Pontiac Silverdome for $583,000. The 80,300-seat football stadium was built by the City of Pontiac in 1975 for the Detroit Lions at a cost of $55.7 million. Triple A is a Toronto-based company lead by Andreas Apostolopoulos. According to Pontiac Emergency Manager Fred Leeb, Triple A will attempt to bring professional soccer to the Silverdome. Music concerts and other sporting events are also planned. The deal had been held up in Oakland County Circuit Court from an injunction filed by Silver Stallion Corporation, which made a $20 million offer to buy the facility last year. But Circuit Court Judge Edward Sosnick refused to grant the injunction, allowing the deal to move forward for Triple A. The sale had also been challenged by an injunction filed by H. Wallace Parker, a Bloomfield attorney, which claimed he signed a $17 million purchase agreement in August of 2008 that was still valid. Wallace’s injunction was also denied. In 2002 the Lions moved to Ford Field in downtown Detroit, leaving the Silverdome with no permanent tenant. The Silverdome had been costing the City of Pontiac $1.5 million every year in maintenance and upkeep.
U of M ECONOMISTS PREDICT AUTO RECOVERY posted 11.20.09
ANN ARBOR -- University of Michigan economists predict the U.S. economy will add 600,000 jobs in 2010 and another 2.5 million jobs in 2011. That’s great news when you contrast it with losing five million jobs in 2009. The information was released in the annual economic forecast during the Economic Outlook Conference in Ann Arbor. To see the report click here. U of M economists also forecast modest growth in the gross domestic product, 2.3 percent next year and 2.6 percent in 2011. On the positive side for Michigan, they project a mild recovery for the auto industry. After dismal sales of 10.2 million in 2009, projections are that U. S. auto sales will increase to 11.2 million next year and 12.1 million in 2011. Another bright spot for Michigan, the report recognized four consecutive months of job growth in the state.
MI OCTOBER UNEMPLOYMENT DIPS TO 15.1% posted 11.19.09
Michigan’s October unemployment rate fell slightly to 15.1 percent, down two-tenths of a percentage point from September’s jobless rate of 15.3 percent. By the raw numbers the state gained 25,000 jobs. A year ago--in October of 2008--Michigan’s unemployment rate was 9.3 percent. According to the Michigan Department of Energy, Labor, and Economic Growth, Michigan has lead or at least shared the nation’s highest unemployment rate for three-and-a-half years. In addition to the slight reduction in unemployment, total employment for the state rose for the first time since May 2007.Michigan’s unemployment rate for the last five months: June, 15.2 %; July, 15.0 %; August, 15.2 %; September 15.3 %; October, 15.1 %.
DETROIT TIGERS’ TICKET PRICES WILL NOT GO UP NEXT YEAR posted 11.19.09
DETROIT -- Due to the rough times the auto industry, Detroit’s Big 3 auto companies decided to pull their advertising at Comerica Park for the 2009 season. But in a gesture of goodwill Detroit Tigers’ owner Mike Illitch waived the charges so GM, Ford, and Chrysler could maintain their advertising presence at Comerica Park. For this coming season the Tigers have announced they will freeze season ticket prices and actually reduce some season tickets in two rebranded sections. The new lower baseline box seat will be reduced by up to $9, and the upper base box seat will be reduced by $5. Discounts will be offered on season ticket packages of 81, 41, and 27 games. In 2009 the Tigers drew 2.5 million fans, fifth highest in club history. 2008 was a record-setting year when 3.2 million attended Tigers’ games. The 2010 baseball season opens on April 4th when Detroit will play at Kansas City. The home opener will be April 9th against Cleveland. GO TIGERS!
MICHIGAN EXPORTS TO CHINA ARE BOOMING posted 11.12.09
Over the last nine years Michigan exports to China have exploded by 500%…from $212 million in 2000 to nearly $1.3 billion in 2008. The increase largely stems from growing GM and Ford auto sales in China…and the trend is continuing. So far for 2009 GM’s Chinese auto sales are up 55% to nearly 1.3 million, while Ford has increased by 32%, with sales of 316,639 vehicles. With a population of 1.3 billion and an emerging middle class demand for autos in China will continue to be strong for several years. GM is very popular in China, particularly Buick, which is a status symbol for many Chinese people. Autos are not the only Michigan export to China, but it’s certainly the largest export by a wide margin. Gaylord-based Mark One recently sold a multi-million dollar steel cleaner to a U.S. company operating in China. Also Atwell-Hicks, an environmental consulting firm based in Ann Arbor, has been working with the Charlan Technology Development Group to improve water quality for municipalities in Chongquing, China’s largest provincial-level municipality.
$290 MILLION TO REVITALIZE MICHIGAN NEIGHBORHOODS posted 11.09.09
The state has applied for $290 million in federal grant money to revitalize neighborhoods in 12 Michigan cities. The money would go towards redeveloping more than 6000 foreclosed, abandoned, and vacant properties; demolish 2500 structures, and rehabilitate 1500 homes. Cities that would benefit include Detroit, Hamtramck, Highland Park, Wyandotte, Pontiac, Battle Creek, Benton Harbor, Kalamazoo, Lansing, and Saginaw. The application for funding is among hundreds seeking part of almost $2 billion to mitigate the effects of home foreclosures, vacancy, and abandonment. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development could decide on funding decisions as early as December 1st.
1500 JOBS FOR MICHIGAN posted 10.28.09
The Michigan Economic Growth Authority has approved another round of monthly state tax incentive packages which will clear the way for 1500 new jobs in Michigan. Here is a summary of the new jobs:
DETROIT - 200 new jobs with Ohio Module Manufacturing at the former Arvin Meritor plant. The company is investing $21.4 million and will manufacture chassis modules for Chrysler’s Jeep brand.
DETROIT – 437 new jobs with Strategic Staffing Solutions. The company will invest $7.3 million to open a new information technology center.
LANSING – 800 new jobs with Auto Owners Insurance Group. The company is expanding its corporate headquarters in Delta Township.
OAKLAND COUNTY – 72 jobs will be maintained with aerospace engine manufacturer Williams International Company. The company will make a $12 million renovation to its facility in Commerce Township.
HOLLAND – 1000 jobs over 15 years will be created by from a joint venture between Johnson Controls and Advanced Power Solutions LLC. The partnership will be involved with lithium-ion batteries.
WIXOM – 3250 jobs with Clairvoyant Energy Solar Panel Manufacturing and Xtreme Power at the idle Ford Wixom plant. The companies work in the solar and energy-storage sectors.
The Michigan Economic Growth Authority also approved three tax-capture Brownfield redevelopment projects…
SAGINAW – In nearby Buena Vista Township, just east of Saginaw, the Fort Saginaw Mall will be demolished for new development. The project will generate $9 million in new investment
MOUNT CLEMENS – Tax captures will renovate the historic downtown fire station. Officials has the project will create $820,000 in new investment and up to 10 new jobs.
KALAMAZOO – In nearby Parchment, tax captures will use close to $50 million to redevelop the contaminated 93-acre Crown Vantage paper factory into a 30,000 square-foot office building, along with a residential development.
The $100 million project is expected to create up to 60 jobs.
MICHIGAN UNEMPLOYMENT UP SLIGHTLY TO 15.3%
posted 10.15.09
LANSING --The states jobless rate crept up slightly by a tenth of a percentage point in September to 15.3 percent. Since 2006 Michigan has had the dubious distinction of leading the nation in unemployment. The nation’s September unemployment rate was 9.8 percent. If there is a silver lining in the September numbers, it would be that the rate has stabilized and has not gotten appreciably worse in the last four months.
Here’s a quick look at Michigan’s monthly unemployment numbers for 2009:
January 11.6%; February 12.0%; March 12.6%; April 12.9%; May 14.1%;
June 15.2%; July 15.0%; August 15.2%; September 15.3%.
MICHAEL MOORE’S NEW DOCUMENTARY DEBUTS IN BELLAIRE posted 09.21.09
BELLAIRE – Flint, Michigan-native Michael Moore debuted his latest film documentary, “Capitalism: A Love Story,” in Bellaire on September 19th.
The film will open nationwide on October 2nd. The premise of the film documentary is that greed and corruption have subverted the U.S. economic system. There were two showings with more than 500 people in attendance. By the way, $25,000 in proceeds will be given to the Antrim County Democrat Party. According to an article by the AP, the film traces America’s economic woes to President Ronald Reagan’s deregulation policies and greedy business executives that undermined the free enterprise system. Moore suggests business execs pushed policies that benefitted the richest one percent of Americans, while simultaneously hurting the lower and middle class. Moore grew up in Flint, where his father worked for GM at a spark plug factory. The filmmaker started his career with the documentary “Roger and Me”, which accused GM Chairman Roger Smith of fleecing his hometown and creating economic chaos. His other films include “Bowling for Columbine”, which offered a critical view of America’s love affair with guns and “Fahrenheit 911”, which challenged the Bush Administration’s Iraq war effort. Moore, who has a home in Antrim County, has been the driving force behind the renovation of the historic State Theatre in Traverse City and the Traverse City Film Festival. He is also coordinating a future comedy event in Traverse City. Even if you disagree with his liberal politics and persuasion Michael Moore is a self-made man with enormous worldwide influence that is very thought-provoking. Michael Moore is opening the dialogue and making people think about issues that need debate and public discussion; no matter what side you’re on, that’s good for America and for Michigan.
MICHIGAN UNEMPLOYMENT CREEPS BACK TO 15.2%
posted 09.17.09
State officials have announced Michigan’s jobless rate crept up slightly in August by .2 percent, bringing the overall unemployment rate to 15.2 percent, the same rate from June of this year. By the raw numbers the state lost 43,000 non-farm payroll jobs, including 25,000 manufacturing jobs. Michigan is on a string of 27 consecutive months of falling employment, a streak that started in May of 2007, when the state’s jobless rate was 8.6 percent. Michigan has lead the nation in unemployment for 41 consecutive months. For the nation, August’s unemployment rate increased to 9.7 percent, up from 9.4 percent in July.
Michigan’s unemployment rate for the last three months:
June 15.2 %
July 15.0 %
August 15.2 %
S.E. MI LANDS RENEWABLE ENERGY PARK – 4000 NEW JOBS posted 09.11.09
WIXOM -- An inactive Ford assembly plant in Wixom will soon be redeveloped into a renewable energy park. The $725 million project includes two companies, Clairvoyant Energy and Xtreme Power, which will create 4000 jobs for Southeast Michigan. The plant is situated on 320 acres and features a massive building that consumes 4.7 million square feet. The state approved $100 million in tax credits to make the deal happen, which Governor Jennifer Granholm and Ford Chairman Bill Ford Jr. helped facilitate. It is an important green energy development and a BIG WIN for Michigan. Xtreme Power, based in Austin, Texas, will manufacture advanced energy storage systems for renewables like wind and solar. Clairvoyant Energy, based in Santa Barbara, California, will manufacture thin film solar panels in cooperation with Oerikon Solar U.S.A. Thin film solar panels is an emerging technology which maximizes productivity and lowers maintenance requirements. Redevelopment of the idle Ford assembly plant will begin in 2011.
MI JULY JOBLESS RATE DIPS TO 15% posted 08.20.09
LANSING -- A measured piece of good news for Michigan’s economy:
the state’s monthly jobless rate did not increase from the previous month.
July’s unemployment rate actually dipped to 15 percent; that’s down from 15.2 percent in June – and the first monthly decrease since June of 2008. Unfortunately the state will likely lead the nation in unemployment once again for the month of July. According to state officials Michigan’s unemployment rate has lead the nation for 26 of the past 27 months. The national unemployment rate also fell slightly in July to 9.4 percent from June’s rate of 9.5 percent. Some experts credit the Cash for Clunkers program for helping the state; 18,000 auto workers were called back to work in July.
GENESEE COUNTY IN WORST RECESSION SINCE 1930’s
posted 08.12.09
FLINT -- According to an article by Ron Fonger in the Flint Journal, Genesee County Controller George Martini has projected the county will face a $15 million deficit for fiscal 2010, which begins October 1. He is recommending county offices be shut down for six days and that 59 positions be eliminated, some of which are currently not filled. Martini blames a precipitous drop in property values as the main setback, which he expects will continue into next year. He went on to say Genesee County is in the midst of the worst economic recession since the 1930’s and may not have yet hit bottom. The Genesee County Commissioners--which is a nine-member board--must balance the budget no later than the end of September. Its choices are limited to cutting costs, raising taxes, or dipping into the county’s rainy day fund to cover the $15 million shortfall. If the county opts to spend its reserves, it will trigger the county’s bond rating downward, costing the county millions more to borrow money for future projects.
JULY UNEMPLOYMENT SOARS TO 15.2% posted 07.30.09
Unfortunately, but without surprise, Michigan’s jobless rate grew to 15.2 percent in June, the highest rate in 26 years. The Great Lake state retains the dubious distinction of leading the nation in unemployment. By the raw numbers there are 740,000 people officially out of work in Michigan. The nation’s June unemployment rate was 9.5 percent. The state has been on a wicked one-year increase in unemployment. Just one year ago, June 2008, the state’s unemployment rate was 8.1 percent. Michigan lost jobs in all major categories including manufacturing, construction, professional, and business services. There was one category that did gain jobs: government added 5000 jobs in June.
MICHIGAN UNEMPLOYMENT PREDICTED TO HIT 15.8%
posted 07.07.09
A University of Michigan economist is predicting Michigan’s economic woes will continue well into 2010 and that the state’s jobless rate will average 15.8 percent next year. Should the prediction come true, it would be the highest jobless rate since Michigan began tracking unemployment back in 1970. In an article published on www.mlive.com U of M Economist George Fulton claims Michigan will lose 311,000 jobs this year.
MICHIGAN UNEMPLOYMENT UP TO 14.1% posted 06.18.09
According to the Michigan Department of Energy Labor & Economic Growth, Michigan’s May unemployment rate increased to 14.1 percent; that’s up from a 12.9 percent rate in April. It’s the highest jobless rate the state has seen in 26 years (July 1983). By raw numbers, the state lost 24,000 jobs last month -- and over the last 12 months Michigan 303,000 jobs have vanished. Quite a change when you consider only a year ago (May 2008) the state’s jobless rate was 8.2 percent. On the national front, May’s unemployment rate grew to 9.4 percent, the highest level in 16 years according to the U.S. Department of Labor. That’s up from 8.9 percent in April. Despite the painful stats there is some important POSITIVE NEWS FOR MICHIGAN. Chrysler, which emerged from bankruptcy on June 10th, has announced it will reopen seven assembly plants. The plants, which include the Sterling Heights and Warren assembly plants, have been idled since Chrysler filed for bankruptcy on April 30th. There were some sectors in the state that did produce jobs in May. 7000 jobs were created in business and professional services, leisure/hospitality, and government. In an article published on www.mlive.com Comerica chief economist Dana Johnson said she expects the economy to bottom-out sometime between July and September
RETAIL SALES INCREASE 0.5 % IN MAY posted 6.12.09
The U.S. Department of Commerce reported that sales rose 0.5 percent in May. It is a potential sign the worst may be over for the economy. Retail sales were lead by gardening products, which increased 1.3 percent; clothing and assessor retailers sales were up 0.4 percent. The welcome news comes at a time when both Chrysler and GM have sought Chapter 11 bankrupt protection. For more details on retail sales in Michigan and the country, click on the following links:
http://www.retailers.com/
http://www.nrf.com/
GM/CHRYSLER BANKRUPTCY=TROUBLE FOR FEDS
posted 04.24.09
WASHINGTON D.C. -- There’s potential trouble for the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, the government-sponsored corporation that pays retiree incomes to those workers who have lost their original pension/retirement. Right now PBGC is responsible for the retirement incomes of 1.3 million people. If GM and Chrysler file Chapter 11 bankruptcy that would mean an additional 900,000 workers would fall under the protection of the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation. According to reports in the Detroit News, General Motors’ and Chrysler’s pensions are currently under-funded by around $29 billion. It all adds up to a major dilemma and in the end leaves the problem of legacy costs with the federal government and the Obama administration. That’s why many suggest bankruptcy should be avoided. Michigan Congressman Dave Camp, who opposes bankruptcy, is concerned with the notion of pushing the PBGC close to insolvency, which would not only hurt the autoworkers but also all other retirees being paid through the government program.
MICHIGAN UNEMPLOYMENT UP TO 12.6% posted 04.17.09
LANSING -- According to the Michigan Department of Energy, Labor and Economic Development, the state’s unemployment rate for March increased to 12.6 percent, up .6 percent from February. The nation’s unemployment rate for March was 8.5 percent. Ironically in Michigan the only sector that added jobs was manufacturing. About 2000 jobs were added in March as many furloughed auto workers were called back to the job. In the past year Michigan has lost 96,000 manufacturing jobs, although more than half of that loss (54,000) occurred in just two months, December-January. The silver lining in the March unemployment report is that the rate of job loss is slowing. There were 34,000 jobs lost in the two-month period of February-March. The state’s March 2008 unemployment rate was 7.6 percent. That means Michigan’s unemployment rate is up five full percentage points in one year. In proper perspective, the state has experienced a 60 percent increase in unemployment in just one year, the fastest one-year increase since 1980.
6826 NEW JOBS FOR MICHIGAN WORKERS posted 04.15.09
LANSING -- The Michigan Economic Development Corporation has approved tax incentives for four separate battery production facilities. The value of all four projects is about $1.7 billion. A123Systems will build a new plant in Livonia that will create 5000 jobs. The second battery production plant is being lead by KD Advanced Battery, a new a joint venture between Midland-based Dow Chemical, Kokam America, and Townsend Ventures. Their plans include investing $665 million into an 800,000 square-foot facility that will employ 885 workers. The third battery facility is being developed by General Motors, Korean firm LG Chem and Troy-based subsidiary Compact Power. This will be an investment of $244 million into a 660,000 square-foot facility that will create 443 new jobs. The fourth will be built by Milwaukee-based Johnson Controls, named Saft Advanced Power Solutions. Johnson Controls will invest $220 million into a new Holland facility that will employ 498 workers. Credit should be given to the Michigan Economic Development Corporation and Governor Jennifer Granholm for taking the initiative and helping secure these valuable vehicle battery facilities. The state is clearly leading the nation and in fact the world in the engineering, development, and manufacturing of lithium-ion batteries. Well done.
STATE PER CAPITA INCOME SINKS posted 04.15.09
ANN ARBOR -- Over the last 10 years Michigan has lost 350,000 manufacturing jobs, and the contraction has sunk the state’s per capita income 11 percent below the national average. That is the state’s lowest showing since per-capita statistics were first collected in 1929. The study was conducted by the Ann Arbor-based think tank Michigan Future. It says that in 2000 Michigan ranked 16th among states in per-capita income, but by 2007 the state had fallen to 33rd, ouch! The state’s largest labor market, Detroit (which also includes Ann Arbor and Flint in this study) has a per-capita income of $38,549 for 2007, which is statistically identical to the national per-capita income of $38,564. However all other labor markets around the state are well below the national average. For example, the 2007 Grand Rapids per-capita income is $32,613 and Saginaw-Bay City is $29,626. High-wage, low-education jobs have been leaving the state for the last ten years. Michigan Future says manufacturing is shrinking, but a surprise number of “knowledge-economy” industries such as information technology, technical services, finance, insurance, health care, and education are springing up.
FEBRUARY UNEMPLOYMENT UP TO 12% posted 03.26.09
LANSING --The Michigan Department of Energy, Labor, & Growth says Michigan’s February unemployment rate increased to 12 percent, up from 11.6 percent in January. True, 88 percent of people are working but unfortunately that’s a string of eight consecutive months that Michigan’s unemployment rate has risen. Just a year ago the state’s jobless rate was 7.4 percent. By raw numbers the state has added 215,000 to the unemployment roles. The report also says the number of Michigan workers has declined every month since January 2007. Bad as the numbers are -- there may be a silver lining. According to Rick Waclawek of the Michigan Department of Energy, Labor, & Growth the February increase was less than the monthly advances of the last three months. He also indicated that recalls from temporary auto layoffs helped moderate February job losses. The nation’s jobless rate for February is 8.1 percent -- up from 7.6 percent in January.
IT’S OVER FOR THE ANN ARBOR NEWS posted 03.23.09
ANN ARBOR -- Starting in July the Ann Arbor News will no longer publish news print, but instead will be replaced by a web-based media company called AnnArbor.com. (www.annarbor.com.) The Ann Arbor News was first published in 1835 and today has a circulation of 45,000. Employees were told of the closing during a Monday morning meeting, where emotions ran very high. The Ann Arbor News has 272 employees. Publisher Laurel Champion said January revenues were down 20% and that the current business model could not sustain profitability. Champion said employees are welcome to apply with AnnArbor.com but that there would be substantial job losses. In a related development the Flint Journal, Saginaw News, and Bay City Times announced local print editions will only be published on Thursday, Friday, and Sunday -- the highest readership days for newspapers. Several months ago both Detroit newspapers announced they would limit home delivery around the state to the Thursday, Friday, and Sunday editions. With the advent of the internet and limitless news on the web (albeit not always accurate or sourced) local newspapers have experienced a dramatic drop in paid subscribers and have also had difficulty maintaining advertising revenue. The internet is changing everything including the once mighty newspaper industry.
MICHIGAN UNEMPLOYMENT HITS 11.6% posted 03.06.09
As anticipated, Michigan's unemployment rate increased to 11.6% in January -- up from a revised rate of 10.2% in December. That’s the states highest jobless rate since May 1984, when unemployment also hit 11.6%. The state lost 36,000 jobs in January, primarily due to widespread shutdown of auto plants and their suppliers. The numbers are from the Michigan Department of Energy, Labor, & Economic Growth. The nation’s jobless rate in February increased to 8.1 percent. Some economists predict the nation's jobless rate could reach double digits. There are four states with double digit unemployment including Michigan, South Carolina, Rhode Island, and California in that order.
MICHIGAN UNEMPLOYMENT UP TO 10.6% posted 01.22.09
As expected, Michigan’s jobless rate increased one full point in December -- rising to 10.6%, from 9.6% in November. Michigan does have the dubious distinction of leading the nation in unemployment. 10.6% is the state’s highest monthly jobless rate since December 1984. The nation’s unemployment rate also went up to 7.2% in December, up from 6.7% in November. In response, Governor Jennifer Granholm said a fourth unemployment call center will open next week in Lansing. Michigan currently has unemployment call centers in Detroit, Saginaw, and Grand Rapids. The current system is handling about 12,000 people per day with claims, but the phones have been getting one million attempted calls a day. Others have tried to process their claims through the unemployment website, but have found the site to be very slow due to heavy volume. To combat this, the state is upgrading its internet service, adding new phone lines, and hiring 276 new workers to help process claims. There are currently 476 workers processing unemployment claims in the state.
STATE MAY GET THREE NEW MOVIE/TV STUDIOS posted 01.05.09
Last Spring Governor Jennifer Granholm signed legislation that made Michigan the most lucrative state in which to make movies and television shows. In essence, the bill allows movie makers to receive a tax credit of up to 42% of their production expenses. According to the Michigan Film Office, within two months of the new legislation 49 requests were submitted to film movies in Michigan, compared to just three requests for all of 2007. There now are plans to build three movie production facilities: in Ann Arbor, the Grand Rapids-Grand Haven area, and Detroit. The endeavor is being led by Michigan-born filmmaker David O’Malley, a partner in the Los Angeles-based V-One Entertainment Group. V-One Entertainment does not produce movies but creates infrastructure for filmmakers. O’Malley does own his own his film company, Safe Harbor Productions, which is in the process of opening a Michigan office. O'Malley is a well-known and respected Hollywood television and film writer and director. He directed "Kalamazoo?" a 2006 movie comedy that was shot on location in Kalamazoo. According to Tony Wenson, Chief Operating Officer for the Michigan Film Office in Lansing, there are currently 10 to 12 different discussions taking place in regards to building studios in Michigan, but nothing concrete has come across his desk.
800 JOBS NOT COMING TO DETROIT posted 12.29.08
The plunge from nearly $150 per a barrel of oil to less than $40 dollars has stopped a joint venture between Dow Chemical and the Kuwait government. The Kuwaiti government, which has seen a 35% drop in the value of its stock market, pulled the plug on K-Dow Petrochemicals -- which had promised to provide 800 high-paying jobs (at an average of $95,000 per year) for metro Detroit. The $17.4 billion investment was slated to begin in January 2009. Dow Chemical took another hit not long ago as the company laid of 11% of its workforce, closed 20 plants, and sold several businesses.
U of M PURCHASES PFIZER PROPERTY – 2000 NEW JOBS posted 12.22.08
The University of Michigan has taken another bold step in bolstering its profile as a high-tech research hub by purchasing Pfizer’s Research Facility in Ann Arbor. The University paid $108 million for the 177-acre property on Plymouth Road, adjacent to U of M’s north campus. Over the next ten years, the university says it will hire 2000 full-time researchers and support staff. According to the National Science Foundation, the University of Michigan is the fifth largest research university in the country, spending $876 million per year. According to Michigan State Economist Charles Ballard, the expansion comes at a welcome time, particularly when considering that the state has lost 500,000 jobs since 2000. He also said the expansion of U of M’s high-tech research will help transform the perception of Michigan to the rest of the world.
MICHIGAN UNEMPLOYMENT UP TO 9.6% posted 12.18.08
According to Michigan’s Department of Labor, not surprisingly, the state’s unemployment increased slightly in November to 9.6% -- that’s up from 9.3% in October. Michigan leads the nation with the highest jobless rate in the country, followed by Rhode Island, which has a 9.3% unemployment rate. Other states with high unemployment rates include California at 8.2 %, South Carolina at 8%, Nevada at 7.6 %, and Alaska at 7.4 %. Three states, Illinois, Ohio, and Oregon each have unemployment rates of 7.3%. The states with the lowest unemployment rates are South Dakota and Wyoming with 3.3%. The U.S. November unemployment rate was 6.7%. From a historical basis, it’s worth noting that during the Great Depression one in four people (or 25%) could not find work. It was not until 1941, or while WWII was underway, that the U.S. unemployment rate fell below 10%.
|
TIME TO QUIT BASHING TEACHERS
posted 06.08.10
Teachers have taken more than their fair share of hits lately. It has become commonplace to bash teachers and blame them for the state’s economic woes. The truth is Michigan’s structural deficit is linked to three areas: entitlement programs for the poor, exploding prison costs, and public education. The fund that pays retired teachers’ salaries is actually in good financial shape, but that’s not the case for the fund that pays school employee retirement healthcare -- that is underfunded, but not as severely as entitlements and prison costs
It’s easy to blame teachers, but outside of paying for retirement healthcare the accusations are without merit. Yes, it’s true that MEA teachers have coveted MESSA insurance, considered to be the best health, optical, and dental insurance in America. It is also true that 40 percent of current MEA teachers do not pay anything towards their monthly insurance premiums. Setting those points aside, at least for now, school districts are able to pay the premiums. Also the pressure to have teachers pay for a portion of their monthly healthcare premium is very strong, as evidenced by Speaker Andy Dillon’s proposal to pool all municipal employees into one healthcare plan. That proposal has put Dillon in the MEA doghouse, and persuaded the union to endorse Lansing Mayor Virg Bernero for governor.
Lost in the story is what teachers have done to help Michigan out of its financial crisis. The average teacher spends $500 of their own money on classroom supplies every year. Most are dealing with substantially higher numbers of students in the classroom. Teachers have had to deal with the needless paperwork of No Child Left Behind, a Bush administration education initiative with mixed results at best. Many teachers have been laid off, as Lansing lawmakers reduce per-pupil funding; the latest cut came in October of last year, when a $165 per-pupil cut was initiated.
Teacher’s biggest problem is also the source of their strength, the MEA. While the union protects and advocates for teachers, the MEA also prevents exceptional teachers from receiving higher compensation. Merit pay, which has been endorsed by the Obama administration, provides additional compensation for teachers who excel in the classroom. The MEA strongly opposes merit pay. The union is leery of how excellence would be defined and of too much emphasis being placed on student achievement. Whether it’s in the classroom or manufacturing a widget, results matter. Merit pay allows the best to be rewarded, and also for students to learn more in the classroom. Teachers need to break from the MEA and endorse merit pay, and the general public needs to quit bashing teachers.
SWEETENED DEAL FOR TEACHERS TO RETIRE
posted 05.14.10
Lansing lawmakers are close to reaching an agreement that would increase pension benefits for retiring teachers and other school employees. School districts lower costs substantially when they can replace long-term employees with new hires. The school system saves by paying a reduced salary, and has slightly lower retirement costs for the new employee.
If implemented the increased pension benefits would apply to 50,000 school employees. Half are expected to accept the offer and retire before the start of the next school year. 25,000 retiring school employees will have an immense financial affect. For example it would save Michigan $600 million a year. That amount is equal to 33 percent of the state’s $1.8 billion deficit for fiscal 2011. The bill also includes a provision that requires employees who chose not to retire to pay an additional 3 percent of their salary towards retiree health care. The legislation is opposed by the Michigan Education Association.
The state can’t pay its bills, and the school aid fund is short $450 million for fiscal 2011. School systems around the state are scrambling to balance their budgets through layoffs and dipping into their fund balances. Michigan cannot ignore saving $600 million a year, not when the state budget is over budget by $1.8 billion. Over ten years, the savings could total $3.1 billion. The legislation should be passed and signed into law by the governor. The retirement reform bill is being brokered by Speaker of the House Andy Dillon and Senate Majority Leader Mike Bishop.
(sources: Detroit News, Detroit Free Press, MIWatchDog)
MEA CHANGES COURSE -- BACKS RACE TO THE TOP
posted 05.11.10
The powerful MEA has reversed course and will back Michigan’s Race to the Top second round application to the federal government. The MEA should be congratulated on their reversal; it could mean a minimum of $400 million for K-12 public education at a time when Michigan needs it the most. The teachers union did not support Michigan’s first round RTTT application, and was chastised by many, including the MIWatchDog.com, for not doing so. Now MEA President Iris Walters says she supports RTTT, but also says that each local union must decide on their own whether to support the education reform effort. Apparently the union was persuaded to support Michigan’s second round application after language concerning teacher and school evaluations was modified to the unions liking. State Superintendent Mike Flanagan says there has been misinformation regarding teacher evaluations, with some fearing teachers would be fired if students did not show progress in specific areas. The American Federation of Teachers supported Michigan’s first round RTTT application and as a result has had a seat at the table of education reform working extensively with the State Board of Education. Not having a seat at the table of education reform is certainly not in the best interest of the MEA, and that was also likely part of the union’s motivation to reverse course. But the fact that the MEA now supports President Obama’s education reform initiative is a major development. Only two states, Tennessee and Delaware, were awarded funding in the first round of RTTT applications. The federal government will dole out $4.3 billion. Yes, it is another federal giveaway, but at least it has some strings attached that will result in meaningful public education reform. RTTT calls for more effective teacher and school evaluations, merit pay for teachers, and additional charter schools. Reforming public education is a process, a series of modifications designed to improve the system. We salute the MEA for getting on board with RTTT, and for putting Michigan’s children first.
ROBERT BOBB PREVAILS IN COURT OF APPEALS
posted 05.07.10
In a crucial reversal by the Michigan Court of Appeals, Detroit Public Schools Emergency Manager Robert Bobb will be allowed to control the district’s academics. The ruling reversed a temporary injunction granted to the Detroit School board by Wayne County Circuit Court Judge Wendy Baxter, which barred Bobb from making any academic decisions in the district. The Court of Appeals reversal was absolutely key in order for Bobb to continue his steadfast effort to turn around Detroit public schools. Had the injunction stayed, it would have threatened $50 million in federal funding and summer school for thousands of Detroit students. The Court of Appeals reversal is a huge win for Detroit students and the state’s largest school district. Bobb has done a remarkable job. His accomplishments include reducing the districts operating deficit by millions (though it’s still some $200 million); has exposed widespread corruption; spearheaded a huge volunteer mentor readership program, and has restored a sense of order to the school district. He needs to be given sufficient reign to manage the district, which is in dire straits -- buoyed by a 33 percent high school graduation rate. Detroit is ground zero for transforming big city schools in major trouble. Bobb is the best hope the district has had in years. His contract runs through March of 2011. Part of the long term plan is to have Detroit Mayor Dave Bing become responsible for the school district. The Court of Appeals ruling is a major breath of relief and gives Bobb the authority he needs to keep improving the district.
(sources: Detroit Free Press, MIwatchDog)
WILL THE MEA SUPPORT RACE TO THE TOP -- ROUND 2?
posted 05.06.10
On May 7th Michigan will submit its second round application for the $4.3 billion Race To The Top initiative. If successful it would mean millions of dollars—possibly as much as $400 million—f or K-12 public education funding in Michigan. But unless there is a change from the powerful MEA, Michigan again will likely not make the cut. The Obama administration, through the U.S. Department of Education, is seeking broad cooperation from all stakeholders in the education community. Most important are local school boards, superintendents, and teachers unions. But the MEA waffled in the first RTTT application. Near the conclusion of the application deadline the teachers union firmly withdrew their support. The MEA then went on a major media blitz, purchasing a statewide radio advertising campaign promoting the fact that teachers spend an average of $500 on classroom supplies every year. The advertising campaign also takes a shot at Lansing lawmakers for reducing K-12 public education funding. It’s a political dogfight that just keeps escalating; meantime the state is running out of money. The school aid fund is short $432 million for fiscal 2011. The state’s 2011 fiscal budget deficit is $1.8 billion. The MEA could surprise, but at the end of day they will likely not sign a memorandum of support for RTTT -- Round 2. That will translate in the loss of millions of dollars for K-12 public education funding at a time when Michigan needs it most. One important component of the RTTT initiative, which the MEA strongly opposes, is having teachers evaluated by their students’ performance. The MEA also opposes a RTTT provision that allows states to take over the poorest academically performing school districts in the state (the lowest 5 percent). Both measures call for additional teacher accountability, which the MEA has fought at every turn. The MEA should join the AFT (American Federation of Teachers) and sign a memorandum of support for Michigan’s second round of RTTT. Let’s put Michigan’s children first.
ANOTHER LOW FOR DETROIT PUBLIC SCHOOL BOARD
posted 04.23.10
The Detroit Public School Board’s preliminary injunction halting Emergency Manager Robert Bobb from taking over academics is unfortunate. The school board gained a short term political win when Wayne County Circuit Court Judge Wendy Baxter granted the injunction. Detroit schools have the nation’s lowest high school graduation rate (about 33%), are mired in widespread corruption, and the district has failed financially too for years. Bobb has reduced DPS’s 2011 fiscal deficit by a substantial one-third; but DPS still faces a whopping $218 million deficit. Appointing Robert Bobb as DPS Emergency Manager is one of the best decisions Jennifer Granholm has made during her tenure as governor. He has done more to change the culture, attitude, and direction of DPS than any other person. He also has the potential to turn around the lowest performing school district in the nation. Bobb’s original authority was limited only to the district’s finances, not to academics. But after more than a year on the job Bobb felt he needed control of both finances and academics. He is supported by notable educational foundations, Governor Granholm, and Detroit Mayor Dave Bing. He is opposed by the Detroit School Board and, too often, by the Detroit Federation of Teachers. Judge Baxter’s preliminary injunction and ultimate decision are crucial and will dramatically affect the future of the children enrolled in Detroit Public Schools.
(sources: Detroit Free Press, MIwatchdog)
MEA CULPABLE IN MI LOSING RACE TO THE TOP FUNDING
posted 04.01.10
It's official. The MEA's lack of support in Michigan's Race to the Top application was a key factor in the state losing out in $400 million for K-12 public education. On March 31st the official scoring document was released by the U.S. Education Department, and it notes lack of union participation as a 'big factor' in Michigan losing out. In fact Michigan didn't even make the list of 15 finalists. Only two states were awarded funding, Tennessee and Delaware. The Obama initiative calls for many reforms, most of which the MEA does not support, including a takeover of the poorest academically performing districts in the state (the bottom five percent). Michigan's application had 99.5 percent of school districts sign a memorandum agreeing to accept RTTT changes, but only eight percent of union leadership did. Michigan also did not score well under its teacher evaluation plan, noting that districts only requested a rigorous review process, without a clear plan to implement teacher evaluations. By its lack of support in the RTTT application the MEA has done a great disservice to its members and more importantly to the children of Michigan. The school aide fund is short $432 million for fiscal 2011. Had Michigan been successful in its RTTT application, that shortfall would have been lessened by 92 percent. Most teachers are dedicated to their careers and are deeply concerned about doing an effective job in the classroom. But the union that represents them, the MEA, is clearly more concerned about protecting jobs at the sacrifice of Michigan's children. There can be no question now that the MEA is directly responsible for Michigan losing out on the first round of Race to the Top funding, which cost K-12 public education $400 million. To its credit, the AFT (American Federation of Teachers) did sign a memorandum of support as part of Michigan's RTTT application. In round two, Michigan will get another chance to vie for up to $4.3 billion in RTTT funding from the Obama administration, but without the support of the MEA, the state will lose out once more, and Michigan's children again will pay the price.
(sources: Grand Rapids Press, MIwatchdog)
MAYORAL ‘TAKE OVER’ OF DPS RECOMMENDED
posted 03.12.10
Excellent Schools Detroit, a coalition of non-profit organizations, has released its educational plan to rebuild the city’s failing school system. It is a true overhaul of DPS, and transfers control and accountability from the school board to the mayor of Detroit. It is a ten-year, $200 million initiative that includes the opening of 70 new schools and pressure to close poor performing schools. The plan does need voter approval, 4000 signatures to get the measure on the ballot. It would be funded by members of the non-profit coalition including the Skillman Foundation, W.K. Kellogg, McGregor Fund, and Kresge. The plan is also backed by DPS Emergency Manager Robert Bobb and influential Detroit charter schools advocate Doug Ross. If asked by voters, Detroit Mayor Dave Bing said he will oversee the district. Excellent Schools Detroit is exactly what DPS needs, and has support from all the key players. Another measure of the plan calls for the establishment of a Standards and Accountability Commission, an advocacy group designed to educate parents and also push schools to meet basic standards of performance. The proposal also recommends the district offer pre-kindergarten classes and associates college classes. It also establishes a high school graduation rate goal of 90 percent. Excellent Schools Detroit is a bold innovative plan that can work. Many of its tenants are taken from New York City and New Orleans, two big city school districts with dramatic turnaround stories. From Excellent Schools Detroit to the Volunteer Reading Corps program, the adults are stepping up to help the children at DPS. It’s the best blueprint for success the district has had in years, and is very refreshing.
MICHIGAN LOSES 1ST ROUND IN RACE TO THE TOP
posted 03.05.10/updated 03.06.10
The federal government has announced that the District of Columbia and 15 states have qualified for the first round of the $4.3 billion Race to the Top Funding; Michigan will not be among them. It means the state loses out on $400 million for K-12 public education. Race to the Top is President Obama’s initiative to improve public education, and many of his proposals within the program are despised by the teachers union. Charter schools, merit pay for teachers, and possible takeover of the lowest performing academic school districts are three initiatives the union has fought at every turn. The state struggled with its application and could not persuade the MEA to sign a letter of support, which--while not required--was encouraged to be part of the Race to the Top application. The MEA first waffled, then said it would support the application, and then at the 11th hour withdrew its support. That move undoubtedly hurt Michigan’s chances. U. S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan encourages states that didn’t qualify to improve their applications when the second round of qualifying states is announced in September. It is a true irony that President Obama, liberal in every sense of the word with the notable exception of public education, finds himself at political odds with the MEA. Race to the Top resembles conservative education reforms, certainly not liberal ideas. The MEA has obfuscated the truth and placed the blame on lawmakers for using federal stimulus money to cover the state’s public education, while simultaneously cutting K-12 public education, thereby irritating the Obama Administration. One thing is clear: State government and public schools are running out of money. If not for the U.S. Treasury printing press, Michigan could not have paid its bills last year, and the states faces a $1.8 billion deficit in fiscal 2011. Michigan is not in a position to turn down $400 million in federal funding for K-12 public education. The MEA doesn’t get a pass on this one; the state's largest teachers union played a key role in Michigan losing the first round of Race to the Top funding, and that stinks. To their credit the AFT (American Federation of Teachers) did sign a formal letter of support which was included in the states application with the federal government.
(sources: The Grand Rapids Press, MIwatchdog)
DETROIT VOLUNTEER READING CORPS SWELLS TO 4300
posted 02.08.10
In the news business, controversy and despair sells, and conversely positive stories tend to undersell. Case in point: the Detroit volunteer reading corps story, which continues to unfold. The national media and late night talk shows love to blast Detroit; high unemployment, high poverty rate, urban despair have made the Motor City an easy target. But the positive stories like Detroit’s incredible volunteer effort are--not surprisingly--underreported, which is sad on a variety of levels. The endeavor, organized by the Detroit Free Press and supervised by DPS Emergency Manager Robert Bobb, has over 4300 volunteers from all over Metro Detroit. The massive effort was initiated after Detroit kids scored embarrassingly low on reading test scores. The volunteers include Yvette Bing, wife of Detroit Mayor Dave Bing. On January 23rd there was an orientation held at Detroit Renaissance High School. 2500 volunteers showed up. The Detroit Reading Corps is an inspirational story, a call to arms among people, with a magnificent response. Salutations and reverence to the 4300 volunteers, the Detroit Free Press, and Detroit Public Schools for making it happen. If you would like to volunteer call 313-870-5669, or go to www.detroit12.org/readingcorps.
READING MENTORS STEP UP HUGE FOR DETROIT KIDS
posted 01.29.10
There are 3,639 reading corps volunteers stepping up to mentor Detroit’s children, whose reading skills drastically lag behind the rest of the country. In total they represent 434,187 volunteer hours. The group has been organized by DPS Emergency Manager Robert Bobb and facilitated by the Detroit Free Press. The volunteers, who were addressed by Bobb in a January 24 meeting, are from all over Metro Detroit including:
• 1100 Detroiters
• 215 from Southfield
• 127 from Royal Oak
• 120 from Farmington Hills
• 104 from West Bloomfield
In total, the volunteers come from 138 different municipalities and jurisdictions surrounding Detroit and even some as far away as Chicago and Cape Coral, Florida. Robert Bobb has established a 2015 goal of having every child in Detroit Public Schools reading at grade-level or above by third grade. The program is invigorating, and amidst the economic turmoil, a faltering school district, and poverty in Detroit almost feels heaven sent. Special recognition should be given to Robert Bobb for his unrelenting push to save Detroit schools, and to the Detroit Free Press which has taken the responsibility to the help vulnerable, disadvantaged children.
(source: Detroit Free Press)
BUILDING BOOM AT SOUTHWEST MICHIGAN SCHOOLS
posted 01.18.10
Despite being cash-strapped for operations some school districts in southeast Michigan are spending millions of dollars to upgrade some facilities. The reason why? Money for capital improvements comes from local property taxes (which are determined by local voters) while money for operations primarily comes from the state. Despite cutting staff, Portage Public Schools is spending $120 million, which voters approved in November of 2007. Current projects include a new elementary school, replacement buildings for Portage Central High School, Lake Center Elementary School, and extensive renovations at Portage Northern High School. Kalamazoo schools are in the midst of spending $85 million on various repairs and upgrades throughout the district, plus one new elementary and one new middle school. The improvements were part of a bonding proposal passed in 2007. With talk of pending layoffs it does seem ironic to have some school districts in the state spending money on capital improvements. But for now capital improvements and funding for operations comes from two distinct, different sources. School districts also have a fiduciary responsibility to tax payers that approve local mileage increases to spend those dollars judiciously.
MEA WITHDRAWS SUPPORT FOR ‘RACE TO THE TOP’
posted 01.14.10
It has been an up-and-down battle to get the MEA to support the Obama administration’s Michigan’s Race to the Top program. Race to the Top is the president’s bold initiative to bring fundamental change to public education which would include adding more charter schools, linking a portion of teacher compensation to student performance, and allowing states to take over the low performing school districts. Last week it looked liked the MEA would support the proposal…but not anymore. MEA President Iris Walters has sent a memo to union members calling Michigan’s application flawed and incomplete. Specifically the MEA is concerned that collective bargaining rights would be at risk when Michigan takes over low performing school districts. That fear is well founded; collective bargaining would be at risk in the lowest performing school districts (bottom 5%) and for completely rational reasons. While it is patently unfair to blame teachers exclusively for the problems in failing school districts, it is also naïve to think teachers do not play a role in that failure. Race to the Top is a reasonable, measured program proposed by a liberal Democrat president and supported by Democrat Governor Jennifer Granholm. It could mean up to $600 million in funding for public education. It is not required that union leadership support Race to the Top, but it would help Michigan’s chances. It is unfortunate that some kind of compromise could not be reached. There is still time though -- Michigan’s application is due January 19th.
PROGRESS MADE ON RACE TO THE TOP FUNDING FOR MICHIGAN posted 01.07.10
Michigan’s application for Race to the Top (RTTT) federal funding for public education is due January 19th with the U.S. Department of Education. The state hopes to receive as much as $600 million from the Obama administration initiative. An important part of the RTTT application is a ‘memorandum of understanding’ signed by the Board of Education president, superintendent, and union leadership. The MEA and AFT however have balked at signing the document. Most troubling to the teachers union is the proposed takeover of Michigan’s lowest academically performing schools. The lowest five percent could be taken over by a specially appointed manager who would manager and oversee the district’s finances. The MEA and AFT want some assurance that their collective bargaining agreement will remain in tact when the state takes over an underperforming district, which only seems reasonable. To that extent Michigan’s School Superintendent Mike Flanagan has suggested the ‘memorandum of understanding’ be replaced by a less-binding ‘letter of intent.’ According to a statement posted on the MEA website, President Iris Walters reacted favorably, "We are appreciative that State Superintendent Mike Flanagan has agreed to the reasonable request that districts and their employees get to read a final plan before signing on to it." Public education, particularly in urban districts like Detroit, is a huge challenge, so presenting a unified front on the RTTT is critical and will go a long way to helping Michigan’s most at-risk and vulnerable children.
GOVERNOR WILL SIGN MAJOR EDUCATION REFORM
posted 12.31.09
LANSING -- The public education reforms that Governor Granholm will sign into law on Monday, January 4th will prompt fundamental changes to schools throughout Michigan. Those changes include:
• Allowing the state to take over the lowest academically performing school districts, specifically the bottom five percent. Those schools could then be placed under the supervision of a state school redesign officer, not unlike Robert Bobb’s role as emergency manager of Detroit Public Schools.
• The addition of 20 university-authorized charter schools. Currently, the state is limited to 150 charter schools.
• Allowing existing high quality charter schools to become Schools of Excellence, and in turn, permit a new charter school to open in its place. 10 additional Schools of Excellence will be allowed to open in the next five years.
• The state’s dropout age will increase from 16 to 18.
• Opening two cyber schools designed to help high school dropouts. Proposed student population would range between 400 to 1000 students.
Without the reforms Michigan would not have been eligible for up to $400 million in Race to the Top (RTTT) federal funding from the Obama administration. Many public education reformers have been pushing for more charter schools for years. Normally President Obama, Governor Granholm, and the MEA are in lockstep on most issues. But most of the education reforms the MEA opposes, in particular the state takeover of low academically performing school districts. The MEA has been a long-time opponent of charter schools. The union was involved heavily in crafting the public education reform legislation. Here is a statement from the MEA website:
It took hard lobbying by MEA members and staff to turn the various RTTT-related proposals around from their original forms, many of which could have been very detrimental to both students and school employees.
President Obama and Governor Granholm deserve credit for their willingness to oppose a strong political ally in an effort to help vulnerable at-risk children. The MEA only hurts its public image by opposing these education reforms. It is most unfortunate because exceptional teachers are underpaid and underappreciated. For the most part teachers are paid based on their degree and number of years teaching. A good teacher is very valuable to society; an exceptional teacher is even more valuable. Their ability to inspire and motivate children generates immeasurable positive results and untold good. But good teachers are held back by the MEA. As a result of a wage ceiling, exceptional teachers are not allowed to advance--at least pertaining to their salary. Good teachers are just like good doctors or lawyers, they are worth more. Merit pay, another education reform supported by President Obama but opposed by the MEA, will address that failure in the system. Maybe that’s next.
(Sources: Associated Press, Michigan Education Association, MIwatchDog.com)
FINNEY HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS LEARN SELF-DEFENSE
posted 12.28.09
DETROIT -- In October 2009 a 20-year-old Detroit man sexually assaulted a 15-year-old female student walking to Finney High School. There were also two other attempted rapes near Finney in the same time period. Those events struck fear into Finney High, and many female students threatened to transfer. That catapulted Finney teacher Cynthia Williams into action. Williams, who also serves as program coordinator at Alkebu-Lan Village Community Center, helped organize free martial arts classes at the facility for any girl wanting to attend. 75 girls signed up for the free classes, which emphasize various escape techniques. The students also receive a free safety kit which includes a whistle and flashlight. The City of Detroit’s Department of Health and Wellness is also sponsoring free self-defense classes. For more information on the click here.
(Sources: Detroit Free Press, Alkebu-Lan Village Community Center)
MICHIGAN PUBLIC EDUCATION REFORMS PASSED
posted 12.21.09
LANSING -- To become eligible for Race to the Top federal funding for public education, Michigan lawmakers have passed significant education reforms. Race to the Top applications have to be submitted by January 19th, and Michigan schools are expected to seek up to $400 million in funding. Without the reforms--passed Saturday, December 19th--Michigan schools would not have qualified for Race to the Top funding from the Obama administration. The new education reforms include teacher merit pay, the addition of 20 new university-authorized charter schools (the state now has a limit of 150 charter schools), and raising the dropout age from 16 to 18. In addition, Michigan’s lowest academically performing schools (the bottom 5%) could be placed under the supervision of a state school redesign officer. Under the plan, the local school board, superintendent, and teachers union would have 90 days to turn around the underperforming school using one of four Race to the Top intervention models. If a plan is not implemented, the school redesign officer could impose one. Such education reforms have been strongly opposed by the MEA and AFT, but supported by Governor Granholm.
SHEPARD SMITH OF FOX NEWS STEPS IN IT posted 12.18.09
After a discussion of record-low test scores at Detroit Public Schools, Fox News anchor Shepard Smith offended many Detroiters with the following statement, “If my kid were in Detroit, I’d try to burn the place down.” That irritated many, including DPS Emergency Manager Robert Bobb who reacted by saying, “To hell with him. Who the hell does he think he is? There’s nothing wrong with these kids’ minds. Maybe something’s wrong with adults.” After taking lots of flack from defenders of Detroit schools Shepard Smith fired back by saying, "The real story here, Detroit, is seven out of ten of your fourth graders answered math questions with no greater accuracy than one would had a person not even read the question, as if at random. Seventy percent. Some parents say teachers and administrators should be jailed. The basic truth of all this is Detroit: you have a problem. Diverting attention to the sideshow that is outsiders' observation of this crisis will not make it go away. You fail tomorrow's leaders in the fourth grade…it's all lost."
If the Shepard Smith statement--and comments like it--stir enough anger, perhaps it will actually help. Let’s hope Michigan can use any such angst it feels towards the critics and pundits as a catalyst to change things at Detroit schools. Emergency Manager Robert Bobb is on the mission, with a strong backing from Detroit Mayor Dave Bing and Governor Granholm. Bobb already has financial control and also asked the government for academic control, which he should be granted. The Detroit Free Press has joined the fight and wants to help facilitate 100,000 volunteer hours to help Detroit children improve their reading skills. Michiganders need to help: Our future depends on it. The MIwatchDog calls on all Michiganders and Detroiters to help in any way they can.
BOBB PLEADS FOR A ‘READING REVOLUTION’ IN DETROIT
posted 12.14.09
DETROIT -- The struggle continues for Robert Bobb, Emergency Manager of Detroit Public Schools. Just days after it was announced 4th and 8th grade DPS students posted the lowest math scores in the history of the standardized test, Robert Bobb announced a massive volunteer program where tutors will assist with reading. More is expected to be announced this week about the program. Also, the Detroit Free Press has joined the fight and has established a goal of generating 100,000 hours of donated time for next year and all subsequent years. Without a doubt, the challenge at DPS is immense, and is underscored by a lack of adult role models and proper parenting. Detroit’s 1-in-3 high school graduation rate and low test scores have caught the nation’s attention. The nation is watching to see what happens at DPS.
WILL MICHIGAN SCHOOLS REVERT BACK TO AUGUST START DATE? posted 12.10.09
LANSING -- In the wake of low test scores and dwindling funding, there was talk in Lansing of changing Michigan’s 2005 law that requires all schools to begin the school year after Labor Day. That position seems to be waning, with the exception of some of the state’s lowest academically performing school districts like Detroit. The state’s tourism lobby pushed lawmakers hard to maintain the post-Labor Day start date, allowing families to extend summer vacations and boost the state’s important summer tourist trade. The issue is particularly important for Northern Michigan’s tourism-based economy.
VERY SAD REPORT FROM DPS posted 12.10.09
DETROIT -- Encouraging as the progress has been under DPS Emergency Manager Robert Bobb, the state’s largest school district has reached a new low. Detroit students now have the dubious distinction of scoring the lowest math scores in the history of the standardized test. The results are from 4th and 8th grades. According to the Detroit News 69 percent of 4th graders and 77 percent of 8th graders scored below basic math skill levels on the standardized test. One question for 8th graders asked: “In a box of six red pencils, four green pencils, and five blue pencils, what is the probability of randomly selecting a green pencil?” Just 34 percent of Detroit students answered correctly, compared to the national average of 77 percent and a large-city average of 67 percent. The results were so bad it prompted Michael Casserly--Executive Director of the Washington D.C.-based Council of the Great City Schools--to jump on a plane to discuss the results with DPS officials in person. Casserly said the Detroit test scores were only slightly better than expected assuming the kids had never gone to school and simply guessed. He called for a complete overhaul of the school system. In response to the test results Mayor Dave Bing called on parents, teachers, administrators, and lawmakers to rally together and address the situation. DPS Emergency Manager Robert Bobb called the test results a “wake-up call” for the city of Detroit.
DETROIT FEDERATION OF TEACHERS CONSIDER NEW CONTRACT posted 12.07.09
DETROIT -- An initial meeting at Cobo Hall with the Detroit Federation of Teachers (DFT) garnered a cool reception on a new tentative three-year contract proposal. The biggest objection; $10,000 in deferred compensation over the next two years which will help the district cash flow and avoid bankruptcy. The deferred compensation would be paid upon the teacher’s departure. Under terms of the agreement teachers would avoid a pay cut, but $250 pre-tax per paycheck would go into a Termination Incentive Plan or TIP account. The full $10,000 would be paid when the teacher leaves the district or retirees. DFT will be voting on the tentative agreement over the next two weeks. According to Emergency Manager Robert Bobb, if ratified the new agreement will save Detroit Public Schools $62.8 million. DPS is facing a deficit of $218 million. Bobb has indicated without a significant restructuring, the district could be headed for bankruptcy.
DPS AND TEACHERS UNION AGREE TO NEW CONTRACT
posted 12.04.09
DETROIT -- A historic tentative agreement has been struck between the Detroit Federation of Teachers union and Detroit Public Schools. According to DPS Emergency Manager Robert Bobb the three-year agreement saves the district more than $30 million in expenses and an additional $28 million in health care costs. The agreement calls for a one percent salary increase in the third year, and additional incentives, teacher evaluations, and a school-based bonus system. Union leaders hope to have teachers ratify the new contract before leaving for the holiday break on December 18th. Accolades go to both the Detroit Federation of Teachers President Keith Johnson and Emergency Manager Robert Bobb for negotiating this historic tentative agreement.
LAWMAKERS SCRAMBLE FOR FEDERAL EDUCATION FUNDING posted 12.03.09
LANSING -- Time is running out for Michigan to qualify for ‘Race to the Top’ public education funding from the federal government. It could mean as much as $400 million for public education. But there are conditions to qualify for the program -- conditions that need to be met by the end of 2009, like allowing more charter schools in the Michigan, and making it easier for non-teachers to get a job in the classroom provided they have the necessary skills to be successful. Both proposals have been vehemently opposed by the MEA. Under existing state law, Michigan cannot have more than 150 charter schools. The Senate has passed legislation allowing successful charter schools to open new ‘schools of excellence’ and also authorize the takeover of school districts that are academically failing. Both chambers have agreed in principle to allow people with four-year degrees to become teachers so long as they complete a semester’s worth of university education classes and have two years of supervised time in the classroom. In order to quality for ‘Race to the Top’ funding, the legislation must be passed by December 31, 2009. To her credit, Governor Granholm--a steadfast supporter of the MEA--has indicated she will support the legislation. ‘Race to the Top’ is an Obama administration initiative designed to improve school performance.
DETROIT PUBLIC SCHOOLS -- ‘AN ACADEMIC EMERGENCY’
posted 11.25.09
DETROIT -- DPS Emergency Manager Robert Bobb has characterized Detroit Public Schools as an ‘academic emergency’. The school system’s pending deficit is $218 million, but that’s an improvement over $300 million, the size of the deficit before Robert Bobb took over. Bobb has been extremely effective. He has reduced the district’s budget deficit and convinced Detroit voters to pass Proposal ‘S’, a $500 million bond proposal. Proposal S bond funding is targeted to build eight schools, renovate 10, demolish around two dozen schools, and update security and technology district-wide. The plan will be executed over the next three years. Bobb continues to chip away, and that includes negotiating a new contract with the teachers union. According to the Detroit Free Press a new labor contract will be voted on by teachers on December 5th or 6th. Union President Keith Johnson said negotiations are 99 percent complete, though no specific numbers were released.
The new contract is expected to have the following provisions:
• peer assistance and review
• professional staff development programs
• school-based performance bonuses
• a fellowship program to bring in professionals to team-teach with educators
• a comprehensive teacher evaluation system
• development of new schools
Detroit is the state’s largest school system. It has 172 schools and an enrollment of 85,851 students. DPS’ high school graduation rate is a dismal 1-in-3; but expect that to improve under Bobb’s leadership.
DPS DEFICIT REDUCED BY $81 MILLION posted 11.16.09
DETROIT -- In what should be characterized as spectacular news, for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2009 Detroit Public Schools Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb has managed to reduce the district’s deficit from $300 million to $219 million. He accomplished it by imposing deep cuts in union contracts, employee reductions, and school closings. Bobb has only been on the job for nine months (he started in March of 2009). He was hired and appointed by Governor Granholm, and recently agreed to a contract extension through March 2011.
MEA BLOCKS $600 MILLION IN FEDERAL EDUCATION FUNDS posted 11.09.09
Governor Jennifer Granholm finds herself at odds with the MEA, Michigan’s largest teachers union and arguably one of the most powerful teachers unions in the country. The disagreement comes from Michigan’s pursuit of $600 million in grant money from “Race to the Top”, a federal program and a tool used by President Barack Obama to enact education reforms. Specifically the MEA objects to the provision that makes it easier for non-teachers to get a job in the classroom provided they have critical skills needed to be successful. According to MEA spokesperson Doug Pratt, "This is not a union issue, this is a fundamental belief...that teachers who go through a traditional teacher prep process are going to be better for students in the long run." According to the Detroit News urban school districts like Detroit are having trouble finding qualified science and math teachers. Last week the W.K. Kellogg Foundation announced it is investing $16.7 million to establish a statewide program to provide 240 teachers placement in hard-to-staff schools. All this comes at a time when K-12 public school funding has been substantially cut, and with the almost certain prospect of additional cuts next year. Michigan needs every education dollar it can get, including the $600 million in grant funding from “Race to the Top.” It is regrettable that the MEA has taken this position. On this issue the teachers union is in conflict with steadfast political allies -- President Obama and Governor Granholm.
STUDENT COUNT HIGHER THAN EXPECTED AT DPS
posted 10.27.09
DETROIT – Detroit Public Schools officials had projected their latest student count would come in near 83,777…so they were pleasantly surprised when 85,851 were actually counted on October 24th. That’s good news given the fact that thousands of parents have moved their kids to charter schools in Detroit, private schools, and districts outside the city. Detroit schools are challenged by high drop-out rates, school safety, and poor test scores. Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb--appointed by Governor Granholm in March--has been working diligently in a very difficult position. His task is to turn around an aging school system riddled with years of fiscal mismanagement, corruption, and a high school graduation rate of 1-in-3. Detroit has an unemployment rate of 27 percent and an unprecedented number of home foreclosures. Given all that Detroit is facing the higher enrollment number is good news, and another sign that Robert Bobb is doing an outstanding job for Detroit, Michigan, and most of the all for the kids who attend Detroit Public Schools.
DPS EMERGENCY MGR ROBERT BOBB READY TO EXTEND CONTRACT posted 10.16.09
DETROIT --Detroit Public Schools Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb has said he is willing to extend his contract one more year, which is very encouraging news. Bobb, who was appointed in March of 2009 by Governor Granholm, has done more in eight months to turn around the district than any other school board or superintendent has accomplished in years. He faces one of the biggest educational challenges in the nation, as DPS is a district riddled by scandal, corruption, and incompetence. One year is just not long enough, so it is absolutely fabulous news that Bobb is willing to stay on the job. This past spring he expressed interest in running for Mayor of Oakland, California, where he formerly served as city manager. In Detroit, Bobb inherited a school district with $430 million in past debt, which he has whittled down to $259 million. Thus far Bobb has uncovered massive payroll fraud and erroneous health insurance enrollees that have cost the district millions of dollars, presumably for several years. Upon his arrival, of the 194 schools in the district, only five properly complied with district requirements regarding expenditures, bank reconciliations, and proper signatory on checks. He also walked into to a district with a dismal high school graduation rate of 1-in-3. Bobb has brought stability and a sense of direction to the state’s largest school district. He has reduced annual operating costs by $19 million. He also has organized a November 3rd referendum asking voters for a $500 million bond which would aid in building new schools, improving others, and—perhaps most importantly—closing as many 60 schools. The people of Michigan and the City of Detroit owe a high degree of gratitude to Robert Bobb; he is worth every penny of his $260,000 salary. Governor Granholm deserves credit for making his appointment, and she should agree to terms for the second year of his contract forth with. At one time Detroit schools had over 150,000 students; today the student count is around 94,000.
DETROIT SCHOOLS NEED ROBERT BOBB TO STAY ANOTHER YEAR posted 10.08.09
DETROIT -- Detroit Public Schools Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb’s contract with the state runs out in March 2010. He was appointed by Governor Granholm for a one-year term. His assignment, take on the Herculean task of fixing the Detroit Public School system, which has been riddled with corruption and incompetence for years. The state’s largest school district has one of the nation’s worst high school graduation rates,
an appalling 1-in-3. Bobb has said he will not commit to staying beyond his contract, but that he has been in talks with Governor Granholm’s office. The Emergency Manager has made some very difficult decisions including laying off 2400 school employees. He also conducted a payroll audit that revealed 246 probable fraudulent employees, and closed 20 schools. He has addressed and made many tough decisions…and many more are forthcoming. DPS has lost 33 percent of its student enrollment; down from a high of just over 150,000 students to 94,000 – and than number continues to dwindle. A commensurate reduction of teachers and support staff is needed. DPS is facing a $259 million budget deficit. Bobb has been sued by the Detroit School Board and was threatened by a teachers’ union lawsuit. He has foes from many sides but has hung tough in the face of intense adversity. The state of Michigan, the city of Detroit, and students that attend Detroit Public Schools need Robert Bobb to stay on for another year.
MACKINAC CENTER: TEACHERS BLEED BUDGET DRY
posted 10.05.09
In a new study released by Midland-based Mackinac Center, public school teachers are bleeding the state budget dry. The study asserts Michigan public school teacher salaries are the fourth highest in the nation, $12,000 above the national average. That means if the state’s nearly 110,000 teacher salaries were lowered to the national average, Michigan would save $1.3 billion a year. The juxtaposition is even more dramatic when factoring in teacher benefits, where Michigan teachers are paid 41 percent above the national average, at a total cost of $2.6 billion a year. House Speaker Andy Dillon has proposed all municipal employees be pooled into one health insurance plan, which he believes will save $900 million per year. The MEA has soundly rejected Dillon’s plan and has also rebuffed the concept of merit pay, where exceptional teachers would be paid more than what the union contract calls for. The average Michigan teacher salary is $58,482. In the aggregate, labor costs comprise 80 to 85 percent of a typical school system budget. Many school districts have already cut most other budgetary items to the bone and have nowhere else to cut except teacher salaries or benefits. Michigan budget woes, which are still are not settled for 2010, will be even more severe in 2011 when there will be no federal stimulus dollars to bail out the state. The 2010 budget will use $1.6 billion in federal stimulus money. The teaching profession is incredibly important, and exceptional teachers indeed deserve additional pay. As Michigan continues to slide economically, teacher compensation--most notably teacher benefit--will continue to face increased public scrutiny, and deservedly so. 40 percent of MEA members do not pay a dime towards their health insurance premium costs, and their health insurance coverage is the coveted MESSA plan, considered by many to be the best health insurance coverage in the nation.
A VERY SUCCESSFUL SCHOOL IN DETROIT posted 09.22.09
DETROIT -- Amidst the meltdown at Detroit Public Schools, there is one school that is graduating 90% of its high school seniors, and every one of those graduates moves on to attend a two or four-year college. The school is Catherine Ferguson Academy, an alternative all-girls school that operates out of a 90-year-old building in less than adequate condition. What the school does have is a principal who cares, who is a realist, and knows most of her 300 students by name. 59-year-old Asenath Andrews has been principal since the school opened 24 years ago. Andrews insists the 15 teachers in the school take an active interest in every student, not just the ones in their respective classroom. Each student is assigned a homeroom teacher who stays with the student until she graduates. There is a dress code: plain white tops and navy or black bottoms. Classroom sizes are smaller than most schools; 18 students per class, which allows teachers more time and attention to every student. At Catherine Ferguson Academy there is an on-site clinic, two nurses and counseling, as well as parenting and personal development classes. There are also four early education classrooms for more than 150 toddlers and infants. While their mothers are in class, the babies listen to stories to build their vocabulary and rock to classical music. The school grounds also includes a four-acre hobby farm with ducks, rabbits, chickens, goats, geese, turkeys, and one horse. Students are taught how to grow fresh fruits and vegetables such as raspberries, sweet potatoes, egg plant, broccoli, spinach, peas, and carrots. The school sells the produce at nearby Eastern Market. In a school district riddled with scandal and corruption, plus a 1-in-3 graduation rate, Catherine Ferguson Academy is succeeding at a very high level, while being faced with adversity from every side. DPS Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb is doing an effective job, but it should also be recognized that Principal Asenath Andrews, her 15 teachers, and the 300 girls who attend Catherine Ferguson are succeeding in a big way. That means that it is possible to turn around Detroit Public Schools -- Catherine Ferguson is proof it can be done.
ROBERT BOBB WILL SUE DETROIT SCHOOL BOARD
posted 09.01.09
DETROIT -- In a defiant move against Detroit Public Schools Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb, the Detroit School Board has voted 8-1 to appoint acting superintendent Teresa Gueyser as the permanent superintendent. Bobb has been in control of the district’s budget since being appointed by Governor Granholm in March of this year. His lawsuit will seek to rescind Gueyser’s appointment as permanent superintendent and have the Detroit School Board comply with his authority over all fiscal matters in the district. Bobb wants to conduct a nationwide search for a new superintendent. He has been at odds with the school board over a number of issues. His lawsuit asserts the school board is violating the law and his order to not recognize Gueyser as the permanent superintendent. Bobb has done a courageous job in the face of multiple adversaries which include the teachers union, the school board, and even some parents from the district. During his short tenure he has uncovered corruption and scandal, and also identified 29 failing schools within the district which he intends to close this fall. He is the district’s best hope of turning around arguably the worst performing school district in the nation. Detroit’s high school graduation rate is an abysmal 1 in 3.
DETROIT SCHOOL BOARD SUES ROBERT BOBB posted 08.18.09
DETROIT -- Robert Bobb, the Emergency Financial Manager of Detroit Public Schools, is being sued by the Detroit Public School Board. The suit alleges he violated state law by failing to consult with the school board regarding financial matters as required by law. Bobb--who was appointed by Governor Granholm--took over the district which is embedded with corruption, red ink, and a 25 percent high school graduation rate. Specifically the suit claims Bobb exceeded his authority by involving himself in matters of academics, curriculum, and educational policy. The lawsuit also requests that Bobb refrain from making decisions regarding academics, and reinstate the $125,000 budgeted for the school board to retain outside counsel. Robert Bobb has reduced the district’s $400 million dollar deficit to $259 million and has irritated the teachers union by laying off 2500. He deserves credit for making difficult decisions in a precarious political minefield.
ATTORNEY GENERAL APPROVES MORE CHARTERS SCHOOLS IN DETROIT posted 07.21.09
State Superintendent Mike Flanagan requested a legal opinion from state Attorney General Mike Cox regarding whether more charter schools can be opened in Detroit…and the answer is yes. Cox cited the fact that DPS dropped below 100,000 students, which means the district lost its designated first-class district status. Last year enrollment in DPS dropped to 93,000 students. The drop requires the Michigan Department of Education to allow for state funding if a Detroit Community College wants to open a charter school in the district. Currently there are 46 charter schools in Detroit with enrollment close to 21,000 students. Robert Bobb, Emergency Financial Manager of Detroit Public Schools, welcomes the competition from charters, but also said it is important they are held to the same academic standards as regular schools.
DETROIT PUBLIC SCHOOLS MAY DECLARE BANKRUPTCY posted 07.10.09
DETROIT -- DPS Emergency Manager Robert Bobb is considering the option of declaring Chapter 9 bankruptcy for the state’s largest school district. It would make Detroit the first big-city school district to declare bankruptcy and permit DPS to avoid millions owed to vendors, employees, and bondholders. Detroit Public Schools is facing a $259 million budget deficit and a threatened lawsuit from the Detroit Federation of teachers. Officials say the district has three alternatives: raise more money, cut costs, or declare bankruptcy. Given the fact that the district is predicted to lose another 12,000 students and face anticipated state funding cuts, bankruptcy may in fact be the most prudent option According to the Michigan Department of Education no school district in Michigan has ever declared bankruptcy. The bankruptcy filing could allow the district to change employee contracts, and clean up the district, which is riddled by scandal and corruption. The district’s 2009-2010 budget is $1.2 billion, and also requires $21.8 million in debt service payments to bondholders sold to eliminate past deficits.
DETROIT TEACHERS UNION THREATENS LAWSUIT
posted 07.09.09
The Detroit Federation of Teachers is threatening to sue Detroit Public Schools unless the district rescinds its directive to lay off 394 teachers. The union contends that the district did not follow proper procedure in the layoff process. They claim the union contract was violated because the laid-off teachers were not notified within the required 60 days prior to end of the school year. The 394 layoff notices sent in June were ‘too late’ and therefore invalid. Detroit Public School spokesperson Steve Wasko says the district has followed proper procedure. Many of the laid-off teachers will likely be called back to work by fall anyway due to a record number of teachers expected to retire. Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb, who was appointed in March 2009, has been immersed in the financial nightmare, corruption, and scandal that permeate Detroit Public Schools. Just last month Bobb conducted a payroll audit which turned up 257 people that are likely involved in payroll fraud. For the 2009-2010 school year DPS is facing a 259 million dollar budget deficit. Robert Bobb is one of the best things that have happened to the troubled school district in years. District-wide Bobb has authorized layoffs for over 2400 workers. He has taken several important first steps to help bring a semblance of order and proper direction to the district. Rather than embrace Bobb’s efforts, the Detroit Federation of Teachers is now threatening to sue. Shame on the Detroit Federation of Teachers; they are clearly more intent on preserving jobs than educating children, even as they watch the school district collapsing around them. Detroit has one of the worst high school graduation rates in the country: only 1 in 4 attains their high school diploma. If Detroit teacher jobs were based on the high school graduation rate in the district, 3 in 4 teachers would be fired due to incompetence.
PAYROLL & HEALTHCARE FRAUD AT DPS posted 06.24.09
Robert Bobb, Emergency Financial Manager of Detroit Public Schools, continues to uncover deceit, fraud, and scandal in the state’s largest school system. The latest is 257 people being investigated for payroll fraud after they did not pick up their paychecks or direct deposit slips during a required payroll audit. The audit also acknowledged that about 2500 employees have received checks in the mail on a regular basis (some since 1999), but officials can only verify that 300 of those people had legitimate reasons to receive the checks. Bobb also pointed out that the district’s health care program is being audited in order to determine whether all dependents claimed by employees are legitimate. Currently DPS spends $127 million annually on health, dental, vision, and life insurance premiums. According to district spokesperson Steve Wasko there are 298 employees that earn more compensation through benefits than by salary. The district has decided to offer a grace period until July 15th where employees can come forward and have ineligible dependents removed from their health care plan. After that, employees who scam the system could face termination and be forced to repay the district for the costs of the fraudulent health care expenditures.
DPS DEFICIT NOW $430 MILLION posted 06.19.09
During a June 18th public appearance, Robert Bobb--emergency financial manager for Detroit Public Schools--announced the district’s deficit is closer to $430 million than $305 million. He also stated that some of the 40 schools he hopes to overhaul and reform could become charter schools, or could be managed by private companies. Bobb also stressed there is too much variation among schools in the district. Some are ragged and empty, while others have better facilities with waiting lists. Keith Johnson, President of the Detroit Federation of Teachers, asserts that DPS has not had a sustainable plan. He also maintains that charter schools will not accept behaviorally and emotionally challenged students, thereby leaving the public schools at a disadvantage. Bobb and Johnson did agree on one point. They both contend that school choice--which allows for charter schools and new models of public schools--leads to the charter schools selecting the students they want, leaving the challenged students no choice but to attend public schools.
PREDICTED SCHOOL FUNDING CRISIS NOW A REALITY posted 06.08.09
One-time Michigan Superintendent of Public Instruction Tom Watkins once warned that funding for Michigan schools would dry up in the event of an economic crisis in the state. His 2004 prognostication has come to fruition,
and he asserts it’s linked to Michigan’s sales tax once Proposal ‘A’ became law. For the next two years (2009 and 2010) President Obama’s $787 billion federal stimulus bill is covering Michigan’s debt and in the process subsidizing the public school system. But in 2011, according to Watson, the state’s school system could fall off a financial cliff. Watkins was forced out of his position in 2005 by Governor Jennifer Granholm after he fought with the State Board of Education about who had the authority to hire and fire a state superintendent. He now serves as CEO of TDW & Associates, a consulting firm that works on establishing educational links between Michigan and China. Watkins asserts that the state of Michigan determines education expenditures based on what’s available in the budget and not what it actually takes to educate a child. Watkin’s 2004 report called for two major changes in public education. First that the governor create a bi-partisan committee to review district boundaries, sizes, and costs. Second, that the legislature determine what it costs to educate a child in the state. According to Watkins the last such study was conducted in 1968 and was the impetus for modifications to school funding in the 1970’s. He also stressed that post-Proposal ‘A’, two-thirds of every new dollar for public schools will go towards health care and pension costs. The 2004 report also called for considering the privatization of some services and cooperation between neighboring school districts. To see his report click on the following link:
http://www.michigan.gov/documents/michiganschoolfunding_110803_7.pdf.
DPS -- A COMPLETE NIGHTMARE posted 06.04.09
Audits by Detroit Public Schools’ financial emergency manager Robert Bobb confirm the worst fears about the state’s largest school district: it is simply out of control. Only 5 of the 194 schools in the district properly complied with district requirements regarding expenditures, bank reconciliations, and proper signatory on checks. In some cases there has been deliberate misappropriation of funds, which could lead to criminal indictments. (five such cases have been referred to the district’s inspector general office). 23 DPS schools mistakenly paid sales tax (schools are tax-exempt) which cost the district millions. According to an article in the Detroit News Bobb stated that DPS is devoid of basic internal controls and that the audits are disturbing in many, many ways. To save money four years ago, the district abandoned its internal audit department. Bobb--who has been on the job since March--has made some changes, such as having school bookkeepers be direct employees of the district’s CFO. Bookkeepers will be trained annually and routine audits will also be brought back. Detroit Public Schools has been operating at a deficit for several years, including a projected $300 million deficit this year.
“A REAL FINANCIAL CRISIS IN DPS” posted 05.13.09
DETROIT -- In his toughest language yet, DPS Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb stated, “There is a real financial crisis in Detroit Public Schools.”
His statement was made in conjunction with the announcement that 29 schools will close starting next fall. Bobb also says there are another 40 schools that are failing miserably. Previously he has expressed the need to layoff 600 teachers. DPS is facing a $300 million deficit. The closures are expected to save $14 million annually staring with the 2010-2011 school year. Detroit Public Schools has one of the lowest high school graduation rates in the country, only 1 in 4 -- though Fox News has reported the graduation rate as 1 in 3. Education Secretary Arne Duncan has said he is extraordinary concerned about the poor quality of education in Detroit Public Schools. Duncan will be in Detroit this week as part of a Listening and Learning tour.
SUMMER SCHOOL @ DPS posted 04.16.09
DETROIT -- Robert Bobb, Detroit Public Schools’ emergency financial manager wants to spend 52 million on summer school for 41,000 students in the state's largest and most troubled school district. He proposes spending 52 million but most of the money, 44 million would come from unspent federal funding originally intended for students in poverty, known as Title I funds. The district must spend the money by September or lose it altogether. Since the time frame for some of the programs has come and gone, DPS was requested to return $16.3 million to the federal government. According to Bobb the summer school plan is a good way to spend the money and have the most impact on students. Some of the programs offered would be helping students with low MEAP scores; summer learning intervention; credit recovery for previous failure; addressing at risk and drop out students; ACT preparation for 11th and 12th graders, expanded tutoring; a Parents University with 6 training sessions, and several other initiatives. On the job for a very shot time, Robert Bobb is getting some results for DPS -- a very refreshing change. There is a long long way to go, but Bobb and his leadership has given some semblance of order to Detroit Public Schools. There is hope for the state’s largest school district.
MORE GOOD NEWS FOR DPS posted 04.08.09
DETROIT -- Billionaire philanthropist Eli Broad (pronounced like “road”) is stepping up big for Detroit Public Schools, pledging hundreds of thousands of dollars to help review the district’s finances. Mr. Broad will tap the Eli and Edyth Broad Foundation for a third of the $1.4 million needed for an outside firm to conduct a comprehensive financial review. A balanced budget and a five-year strategic fiscal plan will be developed. This is very welcome news for DPS which has been fraught with corruption and a 1-in-3 high school graduation rate. Mr. Broad is particularly pleased with the appointment of Robert Bobb as the district’s new financial manager. In just over a month on the job, Bobb--appointed by Governor Granholm--has uncovered $100 million in unaccounted payroll, bringing the districts current fiscal deficit to $300 million. Mr. Broad and Mr. Bobb have ties linked by The Broad Foundation Urban Schools Academy where Bobb did some training in 2005. Born in 1931 Eli Broad is a graduate from Detroit’s Central High School. He made his fortune in real estate and his net worth is reportedly just over $5 billion, making him the 93rd richest person in the world, according to Forbes Magazine. Mr. Broad has a fabulous record of giving: his foundations have $2.5 billion in assets – whoa…that’s major. Eli Broad’s success in business and his philanthropic efforts are monumental. To learn more go to www.broadfoundation.org. His efforts give hope for the kids and families in the Detroit Public School system.
MORE RED INK FOR DETROIT PUBLIC SCHOOLS posted 04.03.09
DETROIT -- Robert Bobb, appointed by Governor Granholm as the emergency financial manager for Detroit Public Schools, has uncovered $100 million paid to unbudgeted employees and unauthorized overtime expense. It means the state’s largest school district will have a budget deficit of over $300 million by the end of this fiscal year, and possibly more if additional unknown employees or expenses are uncovered. Specifically the district paid for 597 unbudgeted full-time employees including teachers and custodians. The district also over-spent its non-personnel budget by $89 million. In addition, DPS has $72 million in unpaid bills owed to vendors. Bobb, who has only been on the job for one month, says he is fearful other phantom expenses coming to light. He has already instituted a hiring freeze and has declared that 261 vacant positions will not be filled. Bobb’s team also plans to analyze lease agreements with the Fisher and New Center One buildings, where the district’s central offices are located for $2 million a year. Also planned are several structural audits, transportation fleet review; utilities audit, and food service review. Bobb’s team is also intent on routing corruption out of the district. They have received more than 500 tips to the newly implemented anonymous phone hot line which is (313) 870-3725. Reports of corruption or wrong doing can also be e-mailed to financialmanager@detroitk12.org. Over the next two years Bobb plans on closing 50 schools and laying off thousands of employees.
PROGRESS FOR DETROIT SCHOOLS posted 03.23.09
DETROIT -- Robert Bobb, Governor Granholm’s appointed financial manager for Detroit Public Schools, is making some waves in Motown. The state’s largest school district is immersed in $200 million of red ink, and has been hemorrhaging students for years. It is also graduating only one in four, though Fox News claims the graduation rate is one in three. Either way it’s been a real disaster, and is the reason why Robert Bobb has been appointed by the governor. Bobb has already implemented four important initiatives for Detroit Public Schools: a new tattling mechanism where district employees can report corruption; the elimination of thieves and problem employees who are being investigated for wrongdoing; the 2009 closing of 18 schools; and he has asked the school board to develop a comprehensive student achievement plan. Bobb’s appointment is for only one year, and his powers are limited to the district’s finances as the school board maintains power over academics. Bobb is a former city manager of Richmond, Virginia and has also served as former President of the Washington D. C. Board of Education.
MEA RETIREMENT PLAN LOSING LUSTER posted 03.16.09
Some Lansing lawmakers are backing away from an MEA proposal to boost pension benefits by one-third for the next two years in an attempt to entice thousands of older teachers to retire. The MEA estimates there are 20,000 older teachers at the top of the union wage scale that would likely take advantage of increased benefits. Factor in too that the new teachers coming in would be paid dramatically less and that would equal significant savings for school districts. The average Michigan teacher salary, according to www.teacherportal.com, is $54,739. Note that is the average salary: meaning top-of-scale would be above that number. The argument comes in on just how fast those new teachers will move up the wage scale. According to Donald P. Wotruba, Deputy Director of the Michigan Association of School Boards, school districts would save money for about five years, but then the salaries of newly-hired teachers would increase, negating any gains. How a teacher moves up the wage scale is different in every district.
OBAMA SAYS YES TO CHARTER SCHOOLS/MERIT PAY posted 03.12.09
Departing from traditional liberal philosophy, President Barack Obama is recommending more charter schools and merit pay for teachers. The president said as much in a speech this week to the Hispanic Chamber of Commerce in Washington D.C. The Michigan Education Association has long opposed merit pay, but the union says it is willing to talk about school-wide bonuses. The MEA is also leery of basing merit pay exclusively on test scores.
Charter schools are another issue the MEA strongly opposes and has for years. President Obama supports lifting the cap on university-sponsored charter schools, which in Michigan has significantly limited the number of new charter schools allowed to open. The state legislature has made numerous attempts to lift the cap, but the strong teachers’ union lobby has always flexed its political muscle, which prevented its passage. The Michigan Association of Public School Academies, which represents more than 200 charter schools (the majority of which are non-union), also supports Obama's endorsement for merit pay.
TEACHERS LURED TO RETIRE BY MEA IDEA posted 01.30.09
The Michigan Education Association and some state lawmakers are proposing a new idea that could induce many high-paid, older teachers to retire. Under the current pension plan teachers with 30 or more years of service are compensated 1.5% of their annual salary, meaning a 30-year teacher (30 years x 1.5%) would receive 45% of salary upon retirement. Under the proposed plan the compensation would be bumped to 2% (30 years x 2%); meaning the same teacher would retire with 60 percent of his or her annual salary. According to the MEA, it is estimated 90,000 teachers and other public school employees statewide would be eligible for the incentive. MEA spokesperson Doug Pratt said assuming 10% of those eligible took advantage of the incentive, schools would save $411 million in the first year, and the savings over the next 10 years could be $1.7 billion. The plan would require legislative approval. Lawmakers would have to determine how long of a period to offer the upgraded retirement incentive (two months has been mentioned), and who exactly would be eligible.
DETROIT SCHOOLS IN FINANCIAL EMERGENCY posted 12.24.08
Michigan State School Superintendent Mike Flanagan says Detroit Public Schools are in a financial emergency and as a result will be taken over by the state. A November 5th consent agreement between the state and the DPS board established benchmarks and time frames the district would need to adhere to in order to avoid a state takeover. Just a week later the school board submitted flawed budget documents which triggered Flanagan to proceed with the state takeover of Michigan’s largest school district. The next step involves Governor Jennifer Granholm appointing a manager that will take control of the district’s finances for one year. Flanagan will submit three names for consideration and a decision is expected in early January. Detroit Public Schools has a $1.1 billion annual budget, but is spending more than it takes in. The current fiscal year has a $138 million shortfall, with no resolution in sight. This will be the second takeover of Detroit Schools in recent years. During the last state takeover the fundamental remedy was appointing a new school board. It did not work. This is a very tough and complex situation -- and the WatchDog believes the best example of turning around a dilapidated school district is in Washington D.C., where Chancellor Michelle Rhee, and her innovative hiring and teaching methodologies, has made real progress. For more information, go the MIWatchdog editorial "New leadership and mindset needed for Detroit Public Schools" in the Editorials section at the bottom of this page.
DETROIT SCHOOLS CALLED TO LANSING posted 8.25.08
State School Superintendent Mike Flanagan has asked Detroit Public Schools' Superintendent Connie Calloway and school board members to meet with him on September 16th in
Lansing. Flanagan wants more details on the school districts two-year budget, which is $400 million short of meeting its expenses. The school district has been under pressure to close some school buildings, which it has not. Eight schools were supposed to be closed last year, but Calloway decided to postpone the closings. In addition, the state wants to know what the districts plan is for dealing with declining enrollment. The state will likely tighten its monitoring and accountability of the district. There has also been talk of appointing a financial receiver to take control of the district's finances.
DETROIT PUBLIC SCHOOLS IN SEA OF RED INK posted 8.19.08
Last Friday Detroit Public Schools submitted its two-year turnaround plan to the state, except it was still short of meeting expenses by $408 million. The plan does not include the closing of any schools, but does include an extensive layoff of teaching staff (818 total) plus pink slips for 900 non-teaching staff. In addition 142 central office jobs will not be filled. It also calls for union pay and benefit concessions that have as yet not been negotiated with the teachers' union. Critics say the
Detroit
Public
School District must close some school buildings and eliminate much of the staff that work in those buildings. Having the political courage to face those affected by such a closure is a difficult task, and one that Superintendent Connie Calloway and the board haven't been able or willing to address. The State took over the system once and couldn't fix it. Detroit Schools remain a delicate, difficult, and problematic situation.
VOLUNTEER CHAPLAINS ROAM SCHOOL HALLWAYS posted 7.29.08
Ten volunteer chaplains are assisting police, staff, and students in hopes of quelling crime and creating a better learning environment in the
Detroit
Public
School District. The volunteer chaplain corps also helps foster relationships with students and teachers in one of the most violent, crime-ridden school districts in the state. In 2004 Detroit Public Schools turned its Department of Public Safety into a certified enforcement agency. The creation of the volunteer chaplain corps is part of a multi-faceted approach by the district's police department to improve safety in Detroit Schools, which has seen a drop in violent crime. Assaults against students and staff have dropped recently, which the volunteer chaplains and other programs are credited for.
|
|
DETROITERS PURSUE THEIR OWN SECURITY
posted 8.23.10
DETROIT -- Russell Woods is one of the most stable and secure neighborhoods in the city of Detroit. So when a 90-year-old Russell Woods woman was raped and robed last week, it got the attention of everyone in the neighborhood. The outrage has resulted in over 300 local citizens volunteering to patrol local streets.
If Detroit police are unable to adequately protect local neighborhoods why shouldn’t home owners step up? The risk is vigilantly justice getting out of hand, but if your home was threatened, wouldn’t you be willing to protect your home and family? Mayor Dave Bing is positive about the development in Russell Woods, “Unfortunately, it took a tragedy to bring us to this point, but people are engaged. I hope they stay engaged."
Dramatic conditions call for dramatic solutions. Implementing local citizen patrols in the city of Detroit seems reasonable. Criminals need to put on notice that they do not have free reign, and that need to fear both law enforcement and local citizens. More power to the organizers of the Russell Woods neighborhood patrol project.
WITNESS COMES FORWARD IN MANOOGIAN MANSION PARTY
posted 7.28.10
The story that won’t go away just got new life. And it comes at a bad time for Mike Cox, who is seeking the Republican nomination for governor. For the very first time a witness, albeit of questionable character, has stepped forward with a signed affidavit stating former Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick did indeed throw a party at the Manoogian Mansion in the fall of 2002 where things got out of hand. The witness is identified as Wilson Kay Jr., a motorcycle gang member with a lengthy criminal record including breaking and entering, attempted arson, and weapons charges. The affidavit indicates Kay was working security at the party and that he witnessed Mike Cox receive a lap dance from stripper Tamera Green. Kay, who has received death threats and has filed for police protection, also states he saw Carlita Kilpatrick assault Tamara Green.
Mike Cox has repeatedly denied attending the party or impeding the investigation. Cox also questions the timing of the witness coming forward, just a week out from the August primary. The timing does seem suspicious, but so too is the way Cox ended his investigation of the Manoogian Mansion inquiry. Cox did not invite or even inform Michigan State Police of the meeting that concluded his investigation. He then issued a press release stating the Manoogian Mansion party was nothing more than an urban legend. Attendees at the meeting included Cox, Kilpatrick, and two other officials from the Attorney General’s office. The state police, who were an integral part of the investigation, were blindsided.
Tamara Green was murdered In April of 2003, six months after the alleged Manoogian Mansion party. Wayne County Prosecutor Kim Worthy has characterized Green’s murder investigation as woefully inadequate. In addition, former police dispatcher Sandy Cardenas is on record of saying she sent officers to a Manoogian Mansion disturbance in the fall of 2002. However the 911 tapes from the incident inexplicably vanished.
BILL GATES INVESTS BIG IN DETROIT START UP
posted 7.13.10
While many are captivated by the idea of electricity or even solar energy as a way to power vehicles, EcoMotors International has been steadfastly improving their innovative gasoline-powered Opoc lightweight engine. The main feature of the Opoc engine is opposed pistons and opposed cylinders, which gives it 20 to 50 percent more fuel efficiency than a standard gasoline engine. EcoMotors got a huge boost this week when Microsoft Corporation Chairman Bill Gates and Vinod Khosla, co-founder of Sun Mircrosystems, announced they would invest $23.5 million in the company. The two-year-old company is headquartered in Troy, and is currently working on its sixth generation of the Opoc engine.
EcoMotors Motors CEO Don Runkle is confident gasoline powered engines will remain on the market for a long time because gasoline meets the needs of consumers at a lower cost than competing platforms like electric and solar. Runkle expects the Opoc engine to be on the market within two years, and that the engine will have broad applications.
Al Gore’s belief that the internal combustion engine is ruining the planet is wrong. The internal combustion engine drives economics and lifts the poor from poverty all around the world through various applications. Improving the efficiency and simultaneously lessening emissions is the way to advance and improve the internal combustion engine, exactly what’s been happening at EcoMotors in Troy.
DETROITERS TAKE MATTERS INTO THEIR OWN HANDS
posted 7.07.10
DETROIT -- Volunteerism is alive and well in the Motor City. Some residents are mowing vacant lots, sweeping streets, and maintaining parks with their own time and money.
63-year-old Eddie Edwards, a retired Chrysler worker, is one example. He routinely cuts back weeds in empty lots, and sweeps the street and the alley behind his home using only a broom and dustpan. In the winter Edwards pays for snow removal, a gesture his neighbors are extremely grateful for, as it has been several years since the city has provided maintenance services on his street.
Another neighborhood volunteer is 56-year-old Dr. William Martin, who has steadfastly cared for the tennis courts at Palmer Park. Dr. Martin has spent thousands of dollars on filling cracks in the asphalt, putting up wind screens on fencing, and purchasing park benches. When thieves broke the chains which secured the benches he bought thicker chains. Dr. Martin helps organize an annual amateur tennis tournament at Palmer Park, and he pays a private company to cut the grass near the courts to make the park presentable. Martin is a native of Detroit but resides in Grosse Point.
Positive news isn’t sexy and doesn’t sell newspapers or attract viewers. You won’t find stories like these on the front page, or hear about them on late night talk shows. With all that’s gone wrong in Detroit its worth noting that that some Detroiters are willing to step up to invest their own time and money to improve and maintain their neighborhoods.
HOMICIDE DOWN 27% IN DETROIT
posted 6.28.10
DETROIT -- Despite the economic meltdown in Metro Detroit, so far for 2010 the murder rate is down 27 percent. Non-fatal shootings are also down 22 percent during the same period, January 1 to June 23. Much of the credit goes to Detroit Police Chief Warren Evans, and also Mayor Dave Bing who had the smarts to hire Evans. On the job for almost a year (he started July 6, 2009) Evans has employed new tactics for battling violent crime. Specifically, he created a mobile strike force made up of special units such as the gang squad and fugitive apprehension team. Both receive daily assignments based on crime hot spots. In addition, Evans uses local neighborhood data and statistics to help fight crime.
Nationally, the murder rate is also trending downward. In 2009 the rate dropped 10 percent, as compared to 2008 -- a pleasant surprise because many experts had predicated a rise in violent crime as a result of the recession, rising home foreclosures, and social despair. Accolades and salutations go to Detroit Police Chief Warren Evans and Mayor Dave Bing for reducing violent crime in Detroit.
DETROIT WILL CLOSE 77 PARKS
posted 6.25.10
DETROIT -- Due to a looming $300 million budget deficit, Detroit Mayor Dave Bing has announced 77 city parks will close, including the popular Palmer Park, Rouge Park, and Historic Wayne Park. The parks were chosen based on acreage and the level of maintenance required to operate them. For months Bing has been in a struggle with the City Council to resolve the 2011 budget crisis.
Unless a budget compromise is reached, Bing warns of other closings and cuts on additional city services. After years of sugarcoating and obfuscation, bad as it is, at least Detroit has a mayor that ‘tells it like it is.’ He is dealing with the problem head on and making tough choices like closing parks. The Detroit City Council needs to come to their collective senses and work with Mayor Bing on a budget compromise before more cuts to city services are implemented.
DETROIT OFFICE SPACE, CHEAPEST IN THE NATION
posted 6.14.10
DETROIT -- The economic downturn has resulted in a glut of available Class A office space downtown Detroit. Prices are $18 to $19 per square foot, one of the lowest in the nation—particularly for big cities—and roughly half of the going rate in Chicago. This has Detroit getting noticed by some business owners who are seeking to operate or expand in lower cost locations. One of those companies is Galaxe Solutions, a New Jersey software firm, which plans on bringing 500 jobs to downtown Detroit over the next five years. According to Chairman Timothy Bryan, “Detroit is now competitive with many of the off-shore locations. Companies are looking to bring back jobs from overseas and Detroit is in the best position of any city in the United States to compete for that investment.” In addition to cheap rent, Bryan was also attracted to Detroit by the pool of skilled workers from the battered auto and finance industries. On average, Galaxe Solutions pays its employees $63,000 a year.
Vacancy rates in downtown Detroit office buildings are a stunning 70 percent, bad news for landlords but positive and opportunistic news for potential tenants. The value employers can get in Detroit is making it worthy of consideration. At some point the market responds. The market would also respond favorably to a tax-free Detroit, suggested by Newt Gingrich. Specifically Gingrich mentioned a tax holiday on job creation, investments in Detroit, and capital gains. Working out the final details would no doubt be difficult, with four layers of government being involved -- city, county, state, and federal. But the economic gain from every private sector job created would be significant, and more than enough to justify a tax-free Detroit. It would also help put a big dent in Detroit’s 70 percent office vacancy rate.
HISPANIC POPULATION ON THE RISE IN METRO DETROIT
posted 6.11.10
The U.S. Census has released the latest estimates on counties nationwide, and there are some definite population shifts going on in the Tri-County area of metro Detroit. Most notably is the Hispanic population, which grew significantly in all three counties. In Wayne County from 2000 to 2009 the Hispanic population grew 30 percent, from 77,201 to 100,187. In Macomb County the Hispanic population grew from 12,435 to 17,876, and in Oakland County the increase was from 28,999 to 38,705.
That is contrasted with the black population, which dropped in Wayne County by 4.9 percent, but grew substantially in Oakland and Macomb counties. The biggest increase was in Macomb, where the black population more than tripled, from 21,572 in 2000 to 67,206 in 2009. The Oakland County increase was 122,061 to 153,918, a gain of 26 percent
Meantime the white population decreased in all three metro Detroit counties. From 2000 to 2009 the white population in Wayne County fell by 4.9 percent, from 1.115 million to 1.061 million. Macomb County saw the least decline, falling by 2 percent from 737,744 to 723,447. In Oakland County the white population dropped by 4 percent, from 1.004 million to 963,359.
(sources: Detroit News, Detroit Free Press)
KWAME COULD BE OUT IN JUST 90 DAYS
posted 6.10.10
MANISTEE -- One day after arriving at Oaks Correctional Facility in Manistee to serve a 14 month sentence, Kwame Kilpatrick may get another break. He may be a free man in 90 days. It would happen if a proposal from the Michigan Department of Corrections is approved by Wayne County Judge David Groner. The proposal is that Kilpatrick would serve 90 days in a boot camp, and then be placed on parole for 18 months. Wayne County Prosecutor Kim Worthy is strongly opposed, “We will certainly recommend to the judge that this not occur.” Meantime Kwame’s lawyer, Michael Alan Schwartz, is all for the idea; “I think that would be a proper thing to do. It would remove the unfairness to some degree of what Judge Groner did. Because I think Judge Groner simply went way beyond what was necessary.”
Throughout the text scandal that took up untold hours of city time and resources, not to mention an $8.4 million fine, Kilpatrick has been slithering and wiggling through the process. Like most bullies, he capitulated when cornered, and cried like a baby when it was time to serve his time and pay the fine. Here’s a little bit of unsolicited advice for the disgraced former mayor: Get the sliver spoon out of your mouth, shut up, do the time, and quietly restore your life. But this may not be the end of the legal trouble for Kwame. An investigation continues into his father’s consulting company, Maestro Productions, which purportedly received $150,000 in consultant fees from the City of Detroit. Stay tuned.
KWAME HEADS TO MANISTEE PRISON
posted 06.09.10
MANISTEE – Disgraced former Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick has taken up residence at the Oaks Correctional Facility in Manistee. Kilpatrick was transported to the state prison on Tuesday, June 8th, his 40th birthday. He is there for a probation violation stemming from his felony conviction in the text message scandal, which cost the City of Detroit $8.4 million, not too mention tons of wasted time and unwanted negative attention from the rest of the country. Oaks Correctional Facility is a level 4 facility, one level below maximum security, meaning inmates convicted of violent crimes are also housed there. According to the Michigan Department of Corrections, Kilpatrick is being held in a single cell and will not be among the general population. Presumably most of his 14 month sentence will take place at Oaks Correctional, the same state prison that housed Dr. Jack Kevorkian. Despite his felony conviction, Kilpatrick still has some support in Detroit, as evidenced by a prayer rally held in recognition of his birthday at the Little Rock Missionary Baptist Church in Detroit. The event was organized by Kilpatrick’s mother—U.S. Congresswoman Carolyn Cheeks Kilpatrick, and will feature satellite appearances by Reverend Jesse Jackson and Minister Louis Farrakhan. It’s easy to understand a mother’s unwavering support of her child, but Jackson and Farrakhan? That is shameful.
A TAX FREE DETROIT?
posted 06.04.10
MACKINAC ISLAND -- At the Mackinac Policy Conference, former U. S. Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich created quite a buzz with his suggestion that Detroit go tax-free for ten years. Gingrich suggested Detroit go tax-free on new job creation, on investments in Detroit, and capital gains. The idea was a hot topic on WJR’s Frank Beckman Show broadcast from Mackinac Island. Beckman’s guests, Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox and Detroit City Council President Pro-Tem Gary Brown, embraced the concept of a tax-free Detroit. How all the details would be worked out remains a question, but Mike Cox was supportive, “To make a tax-free entity there’s going to be some practical things to work out. Getting people to get out of their boundaries is more important than before. It’s absolutely something to look at.” Detroit Counsel President Gary Brown was also favorable on a tax-free Detroit. “I believe from the city councils standpoint, my job is to help businesses create the jobs. It’s not government’s job to create jobs. I’m certainly willing to look at anything new regarding job creation.”
A tax-free Detroit is a bold and aggressive strategy. It would be good for Detroit and also good for Michigan. It’s something that should be seriously considered.
GREEN MURDER INVESTIGATION ‘WOEFULLY INADEQUATE’
posted 05.13.10
Detroit -- The murder investigation of exotic dancer Tamara “Strawberry” Green was ‘woefully inadequate’ -- that according to Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy. Worthy used the phrase in a letter to Chief U.S. District Judge Gerald E. Rosen, who is deliberating whether certain sealed records in the case should be made public. The no-nonsense Detroit Prosecutor wants Judge Rosen to refrain from releasing sensitive information from the investigation. Specifically, Worthy wrote to Judge Rosen, "It is fair to say that the initial investigation into her murder was woefully inadequate. This is not the time, nor the proper forum to discuss the shortcomings of the work of any police agency or the possible reasons for the inadequate investigation. My concern is that at a time when this investigation is finally proceeding as it should have years ago, that this progress could be hampered by the improper disclosure of information crucial to the case."
Green has been linked to a long-rumored wild party at Manoogian Mansion, when she presumably entertained ex-Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick and his buddies. According to the rumor, presumably the mayor’s wife, Carlita Kilpatrick, walked in unexpectedly and proceeded to accost Green. It should be noted that none of this has ever been proven. No witness has come forward to say they attended the party -- but the investigation of Green’s murder continues.
The case has been kept alive largely in part by Birmingham attorney Norman Yatooma, who represents Green’s family. The family is suing ex-Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick, along with city and police officials for obstructing Green’s murder probe for political reasons. Things are heating up in the lawsuit and the investigation. For example, Judge Rosen has ruled that Carlita Kilpatrick and her father will have to testify under oath in the lawsuit brought by Yatooma. In addition, former police dispatcher Sandy Cardenas is on record of saying she sent officers to a Manoogian Mansion disturbance in the fall of 2002. However the 911 tapes from the incident inexplicably vanished.
An investigation by Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox, which included interviewing over 100 witnesses, turned up nothing. But it did add to the dose of the speculation in the case. Cox concluded his own investigation in an undisclosed meeting with Kwame Kilpatrick. The Michigan State Police, who were conducting the investigation, were not invited to the meeting, nor were they even aware of the meeting. Cox has characterized the Manoogian Mansion party as nothing more than urban legend. Yatooma has subpoenaed phone records from Cox in connection to the lawsuit. Cox’s attorney, Frank Monticello, claims he can’t supply the records because Cox doesn’t remember what phone company he used in 2003. He has provided records from his office phone and his personal cell phone. Check back -- this story continues to unfold.
A SLIVER OF OPTIMISM IN DETROIT
posted 05.03.10
DETROIT -- The problems are omnipresent -- but Detroit is in much better shape than it was one year ago. For the first time in years the city and DPS are being lead by honorable, hard-working people. Mayor Dave Bing and DPS Emergency Manager Robert Bobb face obstacles at every turn, but both men have made tangible progress for Detroit. Economically the auto industry is showing signs of life. Like it or not, Michigan is tied to the auto industry, and the state cannot diversify itself to prosperity, certainly not in the short term. That’s why Ford’s $2 billion 1st quarter profit is such welcome news. The City of Detroit still faces a $300 million deficit, but Dave Bing does have a plan to reduce the budget deficit to $75 million. Since peaking at just over 2 million people in the late 1950’s, Detroit has lost over half of its population. Former Detroit mayors have been unwilling to address the problem, and the unions that represent city workers (51 in total) have resisted downsizing - leaving Detroit with a bloated government. Mayor Bing does have a plan to downsize city services, but he needs the cooperation of the 51 different bargaining units to help make his plan a reality. He does have the cooperation of roughly half, but needs all the unions to agree to concessions or nothing happens. Meantime, DPS Emergency Manager Robert Bobb has done a fabulous job, exposing scandal; stabilizing the district and spearheading a volunteer reader mentor campaign that has attracted over 5000 volunteers. Bobb is providing the tough medicine Detroit schools need. He unfortunately is now involved in a heated court battle with the Detroit School Board. The board has won a temporary injunction preventing Bobb from taking over the district’s academics, which he insists is necessary for him to turn around Detroit Schools. He already has control of the district’s finances. The state and Detroit are a long way from full recovery, but at least in comparison to one year ago, the future looks a little brighter.
INDEPENDENT REPORT – ‘DETROIT MUST RESTRUCTURE OR ELSE’
posted 04.06.10
The non-profit Citizens Research Council has issued a 60-page report that echoes much of what Detroit Mayor Dave Bing has said since taking office: Detroit must restructure or face bankruptcy. The report stressed effective restructuring must account for a reduced tax base and limited ability of the state to provide shared revenue. It also stated that Detroit has been putting off dealing with its financial realities not unlike consumers that live off credit cards. The report validates Bing’s call for downsizing and rightsizing. Bing is the first mayor in years that has been honest with the people of Detroit, unlike his predecessors who didn’t have the guts, intelligence, or political fortitude to deal with the problem. Bing has fought bitterly with the AFSCME (American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees) who have refused to accept new concessions already ratified by 26 other unions. The problem is unless the AFSCME agrees to the same concessions, none of them can go into effect. In total there are 50 separate unions that represent various city workers. As the 60-page report indicates, the reduced tax base simply will not support the number of city workers, union and otherwise. “The Fiscal Condition of the City of Detroit” is available at www.crcmich.org. The report was requested by Business Leaders of Michigan and paid for by grant funding. From its peak of 2 million in the 1950’s, Detroit’s population is down 50 percent to 900,000. Detroit is facing a fiscal deficit of $300 million, and an undetermined amount of leftover debt from previous administrations. Detroit is the epicenter of America’s urban crisis, and is irrevocably linked to Michigan’s overall economic health and vitality.
DAVE BING SPEAKS OUT IN STATE OF THE CITY
posted 03.24.10
Here are the best quotes and an insightful assessment of Detroit, by Mayor Dave Bing in his March 23rd State of the City speech:
“This administration inherited a city near bankrupt financially, ethically and operationally."
"In my 10 months as your mayor, I see a city whose collective ideas, spirit and action are coming together as they have never before to turn the page and begin a new chapter."
“Blight is more than an eyesore: abandoned and dilapidated buildings are hot spots for crime and a living reminder of owners who turned a blind eye and neglected their properties."
"We're not giving away or selling any neighborhoods to anyone. We're not making decisions in a vacuum. Data alone is not enough. Any plan will require direct participation from our community, because that's where our real strength is. Every Detroiter has a voice in this process."
“In Washington, we have the support of President Obama, who I visited last week in the Oval Office. His promise of support and cooperation should give all Detroiters hope that more help is on the way. In fact, President Obama has committed to coming to Detroit to see first-hand the challenges we face and what we can do together to deliver the changes our community needs and deserves."
"Unfortunately, one union (AFSCME) continues to fight, delay and undermine our efforts to move forward. Their refusal to recognize the fiscal realities we face costs the city half-a-million dollars a month. Now is the time to end the gamesmanship and begin the real discussion about the future of our city."
"For too long, employers have had to deal with red tape, poor customer service and a pay-for-play culture that has prohibited us from attracting new jobs and investment. Those days are over. If you're looking to do business with the City of Detroit, here's a piece of advice for you: The best bid wins, period!"
“Tonight I am so pleased to announce we're putting funding in place and will announce a new Detroit Police headquarters in the next 60 days. This is something past administrations promised but this administration will deliver. This is also an opportunity to re-open the shuttered crime lab and provide our officers with the tools they need to get criminals off the street."
NO MORE PERFUME & COLOGNE FOR DETROIT CITY EMPLOYEES
posted 03.15.10
DETROIT -- It’s another version of political correctness run amuck. In 2008, Susan McBride, a Detroit city planner, filed suit under the American Disabilities Act alleging that a coworker’s perfume made it challenging for her to breathe and do her job. She won in federal court and was awarded $100,000, which is scheduled to be paid on or before April 12th by the City of Detroit. The lawsuit has also triggered city officials to place placards in three city buildings explaining what scented products city employees should refrain from using. The list includes colognes, aftershave lotions, perfumes, scented deodorants, body and face lotions, scented candles, perfume samples from magazines, spray and solid air fresheners. Since spray and air fresheners are no longer allowed, maybe the city should also post toxic air warning signs on the entrances of all public restrooms. The new no-scent policies will also be added to employee handbooks. It is a classic overreach, an indictment of the U.S. federal court system. As part of the settlement, the American Disabilities Act will also post advisories and warnings in new training materials. What crap it all is, a waste of time and resources, and borderline insulting. This case is another example of how sideways things can go in the U.S. court system, and the unreasonable ramifications that can result. Loser pay would probably not have stopped this lawsuit, but it would do more to straighten up the U.S. legal system more than any other measure.
DETROIT IS CLEANING ITSELF UP
posted 03.11.10
Detroit is slowly and steadily cleaning out the political corruption that plagued the city during the tenure of disgraced former mayor Kwame Kilpatrick. Kilpatrick, a convicted felon, has not lived up to the terms of his restitution, and thankfully the courts are holding him to account. There is also a federal probe that could land both Kwame and his father Bernard in new and much more serious legal trouble. On March 10th former Detroit City Councilwoman Monica Conyers was sentenced to 30 to 37 months in prison on felony accepting bribery charges. The sentence was handed down by U.S. District Judge Avern Cohn. In June of 2009 Conyers admitted to accepting $6000 in exchange for her city council vote in the Synagro sludge deal. She was the swing vote in the lucrative $47 million deal for Synagro from the City of Detroit. After sentencing, the irascible Conyers was her defiant self and promised to appeal. Conyer’s husband, U.S. Congressman and Chairman of the powerful Black Congressional Caucus, John Conyers, was nowhere in site during his wife’s time of need. Some have suggested Congressman Conyers at least knew of his wife’s illegal activity or worse, played a part in it. Most curious is the congressman’s flip-flop of approving a new hazardous waste injection well in Romulus. For years he was opposed, but in 2007 John Conyers changed his mind and sent a letter of support to the EPA. Suspicion arises because businessman Jim Papas, who was the developer of the waste well, was also involved in an illegal $20,000 payment to Monica Conyers and her former assistant Sam Riddle. Nonetheless, things are turning around in Detroit. After years of corruption, the U.S. legal system is serving notice that no one is above the law in Detroit. All these events provide semblance of order in what has been a good ole’ boys scandal, ridden-form of government. While rooting out corruption is good, even more encouraging is having honest hardworking leadership in place to help guide the city’s renewal -- Mayor Dave Bing and DPS Emergency Manager Robert Bobb.
(sources: Detroit News, Detroit Free Press, MIwatchdog)
STARTING OVER IN DETROIT
posted 03.09.10
Imagine former city blocks now rows of fruit trees and vegetable farms. What about large open fields and nature parks? That could be the look of a future Detroit if some urban planners get their way. Detroit is “ground zero” in the battle of urban blight and decay. By some estimates, there are 33,000 empty houses and 91,000 vacant residential lots. Some streets are lined by abandoned home after abandoned home, with the occasional dwelling still occupied by the owner. Detroit needs to start over. One plan calls for demolishing 10,000 houses and empty buildings over a three-year period. Stronger residential areas would be reinvested in. It is not known how many residents would be uprooted, but it’s likely over 1000 households. That phase would be very difficult; not all Detroit city dwellers will leave quietly. Some of the cleared neighborhoods would be converted into fields and farmland. According to the Detroit Housing Commission, Detroit was already awarded a $40.8 million for renewal projects, which includes the demolition of abandoned homes. Mayor Dave Bing supports the plan and will address some details later this month in his State of the City address. The Motor City’s population peaked in the 1950’s, reaching 2 million people -- today there are around 900,000 city residents. Mayor Bing has said the city simply cannot afford to offer police, fire, and other city services in all areas of the city. Detroit’s current fiscal deficit is $325 million.
(sources: Detroit News, MIwatchdog)
DETROIT DEFICIT GROWS TO $325 MILLION
posted 02.26.10
In May of 2009, when Dave Bing was first elected mayor of Detroit, the city was $300 million in debt. Not quite one year later, Detroit’s debt has grown to $325 million. That has lead Bing to suggest more layoffs are in the offing, “We’re spending money we don’t have, which means we have to lay off more people than we planned.” Bing is particularly irritated with the AFSCME (American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees), which has refused to accept concessions that other city workers have already agreed to. “Either they can’t read, or they can’t add, or they can’t comprehend. From my vantage point, it looks like some unions will stand in the way of our city moving forward.” There are 50 different unions that the City of Detroit must deal with -- a large task in and of itself. 26 of those unions have ratified new contracts with concessions. Those concessions call for 26 unpaid furlough days, but the plan cannot be implemented without the concurrence of the AMSCME. For years, Detroit’s political leaders have taken the path of least resistance by not dealing with a budget that is out of control. Detroit is still operating as if its population was still 2 million people. Dave Bing is a pragmatist. He comprehends the city’s population of 900,000 dictates the budget, and city services must be commensurate to the people it serves. Dave Bing is the only mayor who has had the courage to tell the truth about Detroit’s finances and, more importantly, offered practical solutions. The AFSCME has got to realize that you can’t pay what you don’t have, that is, unless you are the federal government. The inflexible position of the AFSCME, which just happens to be a strong political ally of Presidemt Obama, is why unions and organized labor have fallen out of favor with the American public. Apparently the union feels they deserve special treatment, regardless of the economic realities of their employer (the City of Detroit) is embroiled in.
NO RISK REWARD IN MASS TRANSIT FOR DETROIT
posted 02.25.10
The Obama administration has made it clear they want to help Detroit build a mass transit system. In fact, Federal Transit Administrator Peter Rogoff visited Detroit last week to meet with officials from the city and state. Since Michigan is so job hungry, any expansion/new jobs seems worthwhile, but a mass transit system may not be worth the risk reward. Taking into consideration that buses running in Detroit have onboard very few passengers, it doesn’t seem like there’s enough demand for such a system. Mayor Bing has been highly criticized at the suggestion of eliminating some bus routes. Developing the infrastructure for mass transit would indeed bring many jobs, and it seems criminal to be against any job creation in Michigan. Of course the key is sustained job growth, not short-term government subsidized jobs. A mass transit system would have to include Oakland, Macomb, Livingston and Washtenaw Counties. Those counties may view a mass transit system as something that benefits Detroit much more than themselves. Michigan and Detroit need to think carefully before investing in mass transit. Metro Detroit made an important step in the formation of the five-member regional authority to renovate and revitalize Cobo Hall. You may recall that effort took years and almost failed due to the incompetence of some Detroit City Council members, most of whom still serve. Mass transit is not a silver bullet, and has the potential to fail miserably unless there is a regional approach. The bottom line is that there must be adequate demand for ridership. Without that, mass transit in any form will fail in Metro Detroit.
(sources: Detroit Free Press, MIwatchdog)
700 WAYNE COUNTY WORKERS GET PARTIAL LAYOFF
posted 01.22.10
In the face of a $100 million deficit, Wayne County has asked for a 10 percent pay concession from all workers, including those represented by the AFSCME (American Federal of State County and Municipal Employees). But four of those unions Wayne County is affiliated with will not budge. Now Wayne County executives must take a more drastic action, which is a partial layoff of 700 union-represented employees. Those workers will be laid off every Friday until further notice. They were chosen based on seniority, job classification, and for the least disruption of service to citizens. According to Tim Taylor, director of the Personnel and Human Resources Department, the one-day layoffs could last through this fiscal year, particularly if the county is unable to reach an agreement with the union. Last year Wayne County laid off more than 300 employees. You can’t pay what you don’t have...unless you are the U.S. Treasury.
RACIAL DISCRIMINATION INCIDENT RESOLVED AFTER ALMOST 40 YEARS posted 01.10.10
In 1963 Hamtramck officials forced hundreds of African American families from their homes in the name of urban renewal. The homes were demolished and no replacement was offered. One of the families ousted was Ammie and Alonzo Flowers who lived on Dequindre with their seven children. The displaced families were outraged…and organized. They filed a class action lawsuit in 1968 (Garret verses Hamtramck) against the City of Hamtramck and Wayne County for racial discrimination. There were 144 plaintiffs in the successful lawsuit which was upheld by the U.S. 6th Court of Appeals in 1971. Since then there have been years of delays, disagreement on proper settlement amounts, and obfuscation by the City of Hamtramck. In fact it took until 2003 for Hamtramck, Wayne County, and lawyers for the plaintiffs to sign off on a plan to begin construction and replace some of the demolished homes. Now, finally, some homes are complete and will be given to the plaintiffs and their decedents, including to 60 year-old Sallie Sanders. Sanders, who was one of seven children to Ammie and Alonzo Flowers, was 14 when her family was forced to leave their home. She will move back to Dequindre this week into a brand new home. It’s a bittersweet moment for Sanders; neither of her parents are alive to enjoy the redemption. "It feels like I've gone full circle. I left home, and now I'm back where I started from." Her father, a construction worker, died in 1967 and her mother, a homemaker, passed in 1986. "It's sad they're not here to see what their hard work resulted in." The court ordered that 350 homes be built. The last phase is scheduled for the next two years, when 104 homes will be erected.
(source: Detroit Free Press)
62,000 ABANDONED BUILDINGS AND VACANT LOTS IN DETROIT posted 01.13.10
Different figures have been tossed around, but according to the U.S. Postal Service, Detroit has 62,000 uninhabited buildings and vacant lots. Other press accounts, including an article in Politico, have said there are 80,000 vacant properties—sometimes spanning full city blocks--in the Motor City. The glut of abandoned and foreclosed homes plus vacant land has brought plenty of media attention to Detroit, and prompted 28-year-old web designer Jeremy Pattendorf to purchase a vacant lot for $500. Pattendorf is now selling $1 per-square-inch sections of the lot. In fact, it appears to have been a good investment, as Pattendorf has already sold 7,000 square inches. The entire property includes one million square inches, so there’s plenty of inventory left. Interested buyers can log on to www.makeloveland.com.
(Sources: Detroit News, Politico, MIwatchdog)
SHARP-DRESSED MAN: ACCOMPLICE ON FLIGHT 253?
posted 12.29.09
Newport, Michigan resident Kurt Haskell and his wife Lori (originally from Manistee) were passengers on Northwest flight 253 from Amsterdam to Detroit. They were returning home from an African safari in Uganda. They were waiting at their gate in the Amsterdam Airport when the Haskells noticed a sharp-dressed man in an expensive suit accompanying a poorly-dressed younger man. The sharp-dressed man asked an airline ticket agent to permit Umar Farouk Abdul Multallab to board the plane without a passport. “He’s from Sudan and we do this all the time,” was how Haskell quoted the sharp-dressed man. He also theorized the man was trying to garner sympathy for Abdul Mutallab’s lack of documents, portraying him as a Sudanese refugee. The airline ticket agent referred the pair to her manager. A short time later Kurt and Lori Haskell boarded the plane and headed home to Michigan. The flight was uneventful until the plane was close to landing; at which time a flight attendant said she smelled smoke. Haskell--who was about seven rows back--got up to investigate. He saw flames shooting up the wall and touching the ceiling of the plane. He saw passengers jump on Abdul Multallab, who offered little resistance. The entire episode was over in about 30 seconds. At that point passengers hauled Abdul Multallab off to first class. Haskell didn’t get a good look at the perpetrator until he was being hauled off the plane in handcuffs by law enforcement. That’s when Haskell recognized the suspect. He was the same poorly-dressed young man he had seen near the gate and airline ticket counter in Amsterdam. That’s when Haskell immediately asked himself ‘who was the sharp dressed man with him?’ Kurt Haskell has been telling his story on CNN, CBS, NBC, the BBC, and Channel 4 in Detroit, among others. His story is strong evidence that Umar Farouk Abdul Mutallab did not act alone.
(Sources: Mlive.com, 9 & 10 News)
HERO ON FLIGHT 253 posted 12.28.09
Dutch video director Jasper Schuringa is credited with extinguishing a fire set off by Nigerian terrorist Uma Farouk Abdulmutallab on Northwest Flight 253. The Christmas day eight-hour flight—which had nearly 300 people on board--was from Amsterdam to Detroit Metro Airport. The fire was a result of Abdulmutallab’s failed attempt to detonate a device strapped to his body which was intended to blow up the plane. In an interview with CNN, Schuringa--who was seated on the right side of the plane--said he heard a pop. “I just jumped over the seats and jumped over the suspect. The whole plane was screaming. The suspect didn’t say a word. He was just ablaze. He was just entranced.” Schuringa used his hands to put out the fire, and suffered burns in the process. Schuringa was joined by other passengers and crew members who helped tackle Abdulmutallab and assisted in putting out the fire. They moved the terrorist to first class where he was strip searched for any other explosives on his body. When the plane safely landed at Detroit Metro, spontaneous applause broke out in the cabin. Passengers were detained and questioned for about five hours about the incident. On the social networking site Facebook, a ‘Jasper Schuringa fan page’ has been posted with more than 2500 fans.
(Sources: CNN, Huffington Post, Detroit Free Press)
MAYOR BING'S TASK IS DAUNTING posted 11.30.09
DETROIT -- Detroit’s vital stats are tantamount to being on life support. They include a 30 percent unemployment rate, a $280 million deficit, 80,000 vacant buildings, population losses of 10,000 per year, and a 30 percent poverty rate. Toss in one of the nation’s highest homicide and crime rates and you’ve a got a real challenge. However, for the first time in years, there is reason for hope in Detroit. Mayor Dave Bing is a realist. He took the job to turn the city around, not gain political favor. He is making tough decisions, not always popular, but in the best interests of the city. Bing says the city must downsize its workforce, which is designed to service a population of 1.6 million instead of the current 900,000. A classic example is the city’s transportation system which is subsidized by $80 million every year. That economic model is simply not sustainable. But there are already positive signs that leadership in Detroit is making a difference. Consider the following positive developments:
• Detroit’s homicide rate fell 23 percent in the 3rd quarter of 2009. Chief Warren Evans--appointed by Bing--is solving more murder cases and improving investigation efficiency. In addition Detroit’s violent crime rate in 2008 fell by 11 percent.
• After years of struggling, the new five-member regional authority—which includes the City of Detroit--will take over Cobo Hall. In addition to expanding the facility, one of the authority’s top tasks is to initiate much needed maintenance repairs to Cobo. Renovation and repairs are crucial in order to maintain the Detroit Auto Show at Cobo Hall, the most important economic event that happens in the region.
• In October Metro Detroit real estate sales increased by eight percent and the median home sale price increased six percent to $69,900.
To learn more about Mayor Dave Bing’s plans for Detroit click here to read an interview with him originally published in the Detroit Free Press on November 29, 2009.
MAYOR BING GIVES UNIONS 30 DAYS posted 11.06.09
DETROIT -- During an October 6th press conference Detroit Mayor Dave Bing said he would give unions 30 days to accept a 10-percent pay cut in exchange for 26 furlough days. If the unions do not agree, Bing said he would void their contract and terminate more employees. Detroit has 50 separate unions the city must deal with. Last month Mayor Bing ordered the city to stop withholding union dues from employee checks. But the unions, lead by the AFSCME (American Federation of State County & Municipal Employees), sued in Wayne County Circuit Court and Judge Amy Hathaway ordered the city to reinstate the withholding of union dues from city payroll checks and that the city make no other changes pending an expedited arbitration hearing. Bing has warned several times that unless changes are made, Detroit could find itself in some form of receivership. The city faces a $300 million deficit and dwindling tax revenues.
DAVE BING TAKES ON AMERICA’S TOUGHEST MAYOR JOB posted 11.05.09
DETROIT -- A $300 billion deficit, a shrinking tax base, tens of thousands of abandoned homes, and a 27 percent unemployment rate…just a few of the many troubles re-elected Detroit Mayor Dave Bing faces. Bing defeated challenger Tom Barrow by 16 percentage points, a convincing victory. In a speech made election night Bing told supporters, “I believe this is a defining moment in Detroit history. Now is the time for all Detroiters to commit to creating a better future for our city. I believe we can once again come together, rise to the challenge and make Detroit the city we all want it to be.” After his victory speech Bing told reporters that he would be back to work at 7am Wednesday. He reaffirmed on following through on a promise to impose contract terms on city unions that have not agreed to 10% wage concessions. Bing stated, “I did what I had to do. I knew it would cost me votes, but I wasn’t nervous about it because I think it was the right thing to do.” The MIwatchdog believes Mayor Dave Bing, as well as Detroit Public Schools Emergency Manager Robert Bobb, have already proven that they are unique, capable leaders that Detroit desperately needs. They are making very difficult decisions, practicing tough love to revitalize and rebuild Detroit. We reiterate that both men are worthy of our praise and support.
DETROIT MAYOR DAVE BING RE-ELECTED posted 11.04.09
DETROIT -- By a substantial margin Detroit Mayor Dave Bing has been re-elected, defeating accountant Tom Barrow in the November 3rd nonpartisan election. With 100 percent of Detroit’s 629 precincts reporting, Bing captured 58 percent (70,060) of the votes. Barrow, who was making his third attempt as mayor of Detroit, had 42 percent, or 50,757 votes. Bing was first elected mayor in a special election held in May of 2009 after Kwame Kilpatrick was forced to leave office after pleading guilty to multiple felonies. Bing also won the August 4th nonpartisan primary. With the November victory he will now hold the mayor’s office for the next four years. Detroit is facing a $300 million deficit. Earlier this year Bing took on the unions insisting they accept a 10 percent pay cut or be subject to widespread layoffs. This mayoral race was unconventional from the perspective there was no debate between the candidates. Bing refused to debate Barrow saying, “I don’t have time for that. I don’t want to play politics.” The re-election of Dave Bing is great news for Detroit and the state of Michigan, as he has been the first mayor to honestly address the city’s precarious financial condition in years. At its peak Detroit had a population of 1.8 million, but today that number is closer to 900,000.
MAYORAL RACE REFERENDUM ON PENSION ABUSE
posted 11.02.09
The mayoral race in Taylor, a suburb south of Detroit, will largely be a referendum on pension maltreatment. The incumbent Cameron Priebe is facing a tough challenge from Councilman Jeff Lamerand, who is strongly supported by both local and state police/fire fighter unions. The reason the unions want to defeat Mayor Priebe is because of his push to reduce pension benefits and reform. Currently pension benefits can be calculated from the highest two years of compensation, as opposed to an average over an entire career. In addition Taylor police can bank unused sick days over the career and then cash them in when they retire. Even more extreme is the liberal 20-year eligibility retirement requirement. That means retiring in early to mid 40’s for some and at a pension for substantially more than what they made during their career. Despite an average $60,000 base pay, many have pensions that pay $75,000 to $100,000 per year. Ironically Mayor Cameron Priebe is a retired Taylor police officer with a pension of $42,000 per year. Priebe is the leading advocate for reforming Pubic Act 312, a state law that favors public safety unions (police & fire) in contract negotiations by requiring binding arbitration decisions on unresolved issues. Portions of this posting were taken from Nolan Finley’s column in the Detroit News on 10-29-09, ‘Reform push puts target on suburb’s mayor’.
DETROIT POLICE ON HIGH ALERT posted 10.30.09
DETROIT -- Some family members and followers of Luqman Ameen Abdullah, who was killed by federal agents on October 29th, have threatened to retaliate against police officers to avenge his death. Abdullah, also known as Christopher Thomas, was armed and open fired on police during a raid at a Dearborn warehouse at the corner of Michigan Avenue and Miller. The raid followed a two-year investigation which resulted in a federal complaint against Abdullah alleging that he was the leader of the group called ‘Ummah’ with the mission of establishing a separate Islamic nation within the United States. U.S. Attorney Terrence Berg emphasized that people should not connect Muslims in general with the fundamentalist group or what it represents. Federal officials said ‘Ummah’ is a group of mostly African-American converts to Islam who seek to establish a separate Sharia law-governed state within the United States. Four other suspects surrendered in the raid without incident. In total, 11 men were criminally charged in the raids. Authorities have arrested one fugitive but still seek two suspects who remain at large. The investigation also revealed that Abdullah spoke of launching some kind of an attack during Super Bowl XL in Detroit.
DETROIT MURDER RATE DOWN 23% posted 10.27.09
DETROIT -- Some good news for Detroit -- for the 3rd quarter the city saw its homicide rate fall by 23 percent, to 96, down from 125 in the second quarter. Detroit Police Chief Warren Evans attributes the lower number in part to his department’s efforts of staying in front of crimes by identifying crime hot spots in the city and those responsible for non-fatal shootings. Evans also said he has assigned 20 additional officers to the Gang Enforcement Unit, specializing in collecting intelligence to help prevent gun crimes and apprehend shooters. The City of Detroit has improved its proficiency in the investigation and prosecution of murder cases, which is now closer to 60 percent, the national average. More recently the rate was only 27 percent. Chief Evans said more Detroiters are coming forward with information about homicides.
CHAOS AT COBO HALL posted 10.09.09
DETROIT -- Recently Detroit was awarded $15.2 million from the federally-funded Homeless Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing Programs which help pay rent, utilities, and deposits for families with an income of less than
$35,500. In Detroit that includes 58 percent of all households in the city.
On Wednesday, October 7th about 50,000 City of Detroit residents lined up at Cobo Hall in hopes of getting one of 5,000 applications for the federal programs. The amounts paid per-household range from a couple hundred to a few thousand dollars. The line stretched for blocks and at times was out of control as people pushed and jostled for a better position. Six people were taken away by ambulance and 150 police were called to assist in the mayhem. The economic pressure is on in the city of Detroit, as 1-in-3 lives in poverty and 28.7 percent are unemployed.
DETROIT “CRISIS TURNAROUND TEAM” RELEASES REPORT posted 10.08.09
DETROIT -- This past summer Detroit Mayor Dave Bing assembled 20 people to help him turn around the city’s financial crisis. Eventually the crisis turnaround team grew to 60 members and on October 7th they released a
145-page report -- a blueprint to turn around the Motor City. According to Mayor Bing the short-term savings from the plan will be $50 to $75 million per year, but the savings could increase to $250 million per year. He said the plan is evolving and will be modified as time and practicality calls for. The plan includes 150 recommendations and proposes to close facilities, purge the city of waste and fraud, privatize some services, and outsource others including payroll. Short-term goals, or those to be met in 90 days, include privatizing City Airport, closing the Mistersky Power Plant, reducing the number of city bank accounts by 50 percent, and hiring a chief procurement officer.
Medium-term goals, or those to be implemented in six months, include eliminating discretionary spending, consolidating city-wide services, increasing EMS outstanding debt collection, and consolidating the information technology services department. Longer-term goals, that will take up to a year to initiate, include restructuring city debt, seeking the reduction and consolidation of unions through various bargaining units, and consolidating city-wide leased and owned real estate inventory. Mayor Bing said the most surprising find in the report was the sheer volume of unused real estate the city owns. Prominent members on the crisis turnaround team include retired Ford executive Joseph Walsh, magazine publisher Denise Ilitch, and former Deputy May Freman Hendrix.
DETROIT MAYOR BING LAYS OFF 230 CITY WORKERS
posted 09.25.09
DETROIT -- In his difficult undertaking to right-size the number of workers serving Detroit’s shrinking population, Mayor Dave Bing will lay off 230 city workers effective October 2nd. The layoffs are in addition to the 436 city workers who have been laid off since Mayor Bing took office in May of 2009. The new round of layoffs will include 113 drivers from the Detroit Department of Transportation. Other departments affected are the Coleman A. Young Airport, the Mayor’s office, Department of Public Works, Lighting, Recreation, and Health. Part of Mayor Bing’s plan is to outsource the maintenance and repair of the city’s bus fleet. Responding to the layoffs, the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees Local 312 filed suit in Wayne County Circuit Court seeking an injunction to prohibit the City from subcontracting bus repairs while its members lose their jobs.
ERNIE HARWELL - A REAL CLASS ACT posted 09.17.09
DETROIT --Legendary baseball play-by-play broadcaster Ernie Harwell was honored at Comerica Park during the Detroit Tigers-Kansas City Royals game on September 16th, 2009. Harwell, 91, recently announced he had inoperable cancer. Ernie Harwell was a baseball play-by-play announcer for 55 consecutive years, a remarkable run that concluded with 42 consecutive years with the Detroit Tigers. He is well known to baseball fans around the nation, and is considered one of the top sports announcers in the nation. The ease, rhythm, and art of his play by play announcing were exceptional. He made a real personal connection with the listener. Harwell’s illustrious career started as the play-by-play announcer for the Atlanta Crackers in 1943 on WSB radio. In 1948 he was traded to the Brooklyn Dodgers for catcher Cliff Dapper. Harwell is the only announcer ever traded for a player in the history of the game. The Dodgers needed a substitute play-by-play man because their announcer, Red Barber, was hospitalized with a bleeding ulcer. In 1960 Harwell became the voice of the Detroit Tigers. His final Tigers’ broadcast was on September 29th, 2002. He has and will always be a fabulous ambassador for the state of Michigan, the Tigers, and the game of baseball. During a September 8th interview on WJR radio he stated, “I know we're all going at some time, and I'm ready for whatever God's got. I have a great feeling of peace about it. Serenity."
VIOLENT CRIME DOWN 11.6% IN DETROIT posted 09.15.09
DETROIT -- Amidst a reeling economy, violent crime in Detroit fell 11.6 percent in 2008 according to the Uniform Crime Report released by the FBI. Specifically murder fell 22 percent; rape was down 3.2 percent; robbery off 7 percent; and aggravated assault dropped 13.9 percent. Detroit lead the nation in 2007 as the murder capital, 40.7 murders for every 100,000 residents. The 2008 murder rate fell to 33.76 for every 100,000 residents. Burglary was the only crime category that did increase last year. That’s real progress during a trying time in Metro Detroit.
DAVE BING AND ROBERT BOBB SHOW COURAGEOUS LEADERSHIP posted 09.10.09
DETROIT -- Amidst the state’s economic malaise there are two individuals fighting very hard for Detroit: Mayor Dave Bing and DPS Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb. Both of these men are in their respective positions not for political gain but rather to help the people whom they serve, regardless of any personal or political price it may cause. For years and years previous mayors of Detroit, DPS school boards, and administrators have been cavalier about the finances they were responsible for -- and certainly were ineffective stewards for the people who they served. The City of Detroit faces a fiscal deficit of $300 million and decreasing revenues across the board. The population--once almost two million--has now fallen to 900,000. Detroit schools have seen a similar pullback; student enrollment has dropped from 150,000 in 2003 to 94,000 in 2009. Detroit Public Schools also faces a $259 million deficit, but many believe that number could be much higher. Both Dave Bing and Robert Bobb are working diligently, but face adversaries in every direction to complete the jobs their predecessors didn’t have the guts to do -- and that job is to right-size services for the number of people the system is serving. Both of these men deserve praise and admiration for what they have done so far, but their tasks remain daunting. Their principle foes are the unions, which refuse to deal in reality. For example, rather than roll up their sleeves and work with Bing and Bobb, the unions threaten they will strike. Here’s the reality: you can’t pay what you don’t have, and the City of Detroit and Detroit Public Schools are running out of money and are on the verge of bankruptcy. Yes, Barack Obama has a printing press, so he can get away with it -- Michigan can’t. Michigan citizens need to support Detroit Mayor Dave Bing and Detroit Public Schools’ Emergency Financial Manager Robert Bobb. Michigan needs a healthy Detroit, and right now our best chance is to get behind and support Dave Bing and Robert Bobb. Click here for audio version.
EITHER MASS LAYOFFS OR BANKRUPTCY FOR DETROIT
posted 08.31.09
DETROIT -- According to Joe Harris--a former city auditor--the City of Detroit has two ways out of its financial crisis: massive layoffs or bankruptcy. The city is facing a short-term $60 million cash shortfall and an expanding $300 million deficit for fiscal 2010. Harris claims Detroit is bleeding at a rate of $5 million per month. Mayor Dave Bing did lay off 205 city workers last week, but that number is expected to grow substantially: another 1000 could lose their jobs starting this week. Detroit has 13,000 city workers with a salary range of $30,000 to $50,000 annually. Including benefits, total costs per employee is around $80,000 per year. The City of Detroit is getting squeezed from all sides: falling property tax revenue, plummeting city income tax revenue, and steadily decreasing revenue sharing from the state. Those across-the-board diminishing revenue streams are contrasted with higher health care costs and overall operating costs. Bankruptcy remains an option that Mayor Dave Bing may be forced to select. That will also include substantial job losses as the city right-sizes to the population it serves. At its peak, the City of Detroit had 1.8 million residents; today there are 900,000 and the numbers continue to slide.
MAYOR BING LAYS IT ON THE LINE posted 08.28.09
DETROIT -- Mayor Dave Bing has laid it on the line -- unless concessions are agreed to by unions representing city workers, layoffs will begin Monday, August 31st. According to an article in the Detroit News, up to 1000 city workers could lose their jobs starting next week. There are already 319 previously-planned layoffs that begin Friday, August 28th. Detroit is facing a budget deficit of $350 million, not to mention across-the-board declining revenues. Mayor Bing has asked members of the Detroit City Council to accept a 10 percent decrease in their $81,312 salary and also a reduction in their per-member office budget, which totals $614,588. Bing has been highly critical of union leadership who he says is resistant to change. He is also admonished political leaders who have been in office for several years without dealing with the problem. Mayor Bing has identified $40 million in cuts which will keep the city solvent short term until some time this fall, December at the latest. Next week his ‘crisis turnaround team’, which includes Denise Illitch and Freeman Hendrix, will issue its finalized report. The report’s recommending actions include the elimination and/or merging of several city departments in addition to outsourcing of some services. Bing was quoted as saying, “There are people who think we’re suppose to be job providers. We’re service providers. Our people need to understand that entitlement is gone.”
DETROIT MAYOR BING CALLS FOR 10% PAY CUT ACROSS THE BOARD posted 08.11.09
DETROIT -- According to an article by Suzette Hackney of the Detroit Free Press, Detroit Mayor Dave Bing has told union leaders that all of his appointees will be getting a 10 percent pay cut effective September 1st. Bing also said the city’s 10,000 union employees will also have to accept a 10 percent cut. He made the announcement during a meeting with union leaders at Cobo Hall. In addition Mayor Bing asserts that at least 1000 workers will be laid off even if the union agrees to the 10 percent pay cut. The city has enough money to make it ‘til October, but without the 10 percent across-the-board pay cut, Bing says Detroit could end up in bankruptcy. Detroit is in the midst of right-sizing as it adjusts to its declining population, now estimated at 900,000. At its peak Detroit’s population was two million people.
COBO EXPANSION PLAN FINALLY MOVES FORWARD
posted 07.29.09
The Detroit City Council refused to vote against the plan to renovate and expand Cobo Hall, which means the legislation to turn over the convention center to a regional authority will move forward. The regional authority will include Wayne, Macomb, and Oakland counties, the City of Detroit, and the state. $300 million will be spent on deferred maintenance and expansion of Cobo, which is long overdue, and considered critical in order to maintain the North American Auto Show at the venue. The auto show is considered the most important convention event that happens in Metro Detroit and for that matter, the state of Michigan. The regional authority will make payments to the city of Detroit for leasing the facility. Credit should be given to Mayor Dave Bing and Council Members Ken Cockrel, Jr., Shelia Cockrel, Brenda Jones, and Alberta Tinsley-Talabi who all supported the plan. Cobo is the most important convention facility in the state, and this is a very positive move for Detroit and the state of Michigan.
ANOTHER WOMAN LINKED TO KWAME KILPATRICK
posted 07.28.09
DETROIT -- Former disgraced Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick has again been linked to having an “inappropriate” relationship with another woman. Sheryl Robinson Wood--whose title was ‘federal monitor’, overseeing the city’s police reforms and compliance--resigned her position last week. The text messages (from 2003 to 2005) obtained by the U.S. Department of Justice apparently reveal a personal relationship and evidence the two met in several U.S. cities, but not while working on official city business. In a media briefing from Saul Green, Detroit’s group executive of public safety, the text messages show the relationship was inappropriate and had several references to the pending litigation the city of Detroit was facing from a lawsuit brought by two police officers for wrongful dismissal. Under the direction of Kilpatrick, the lawsuit was abruptly settled and cost the city of Detroit $8 million. Shortly thereafter it was the basis of Kilpatrick’s conviction on two felony counts of obstructing justice by committing perjury, related to the settlement. Kilpatrick was sentenced to four months in jail, $1 million in restitution, and five years probation. It sounds like trouble is far from over for Mr. Kilpatrick.
DETROIT RED INK, $275 MIL – SERVICES WILL BE CUT
posted 07.22.09
DETROIT -- In a July 21st news conference, newly-elected Detroit Mayor Dave Bing said that without a doubt there will be a reduction of city services.
Detroit is facing a deficit estimated at $275 to $300 million, and the mayor believes it will take three to five years to eliminate the red ink. Bing has proposed a 26-day furlough for non-union, executive and legislative branch city employees and 36th District Court employees. The initiative equates to a 10 percent pay cut and would save the city $7 million. There are also on-going labor negotiations with AFSCME Local 27 with whom the city has requested wage concessions. So far union officials have resisted the proposed concessions. Mayor Bing said he campaigned on the preface that Detroit faces a financial crisis and now that he has access to all the information, it’s worse than he thought.
FEDS INDICT SAM RIDDLE -- DETROIT MOVES FORWARD
posted 07.16.09
DETROIT -- Disgraced former Detroit City Councilwoman Monica Conyers has already made her plea deal on bribery charges. As a result, she is a convicted felon and facing five years in prison. Now the feds have indicted Sam Riddle--a one time Conyers’ confidant--on multiple charges of bribery, extortion, mail fraud, and making false statements. He faces as much as twenty years in prison, and the feds say this is not the end of their corruption probe. Legal experts say Monica Conyers, wife of the powerful U.S. Congressman John Conyers, made a smart move on her plea agreement with federal prosecutors. Her name is mentioned throughout the lengthy court documents asserting that Conyers and Riddle conspired on four different scams seeking ill-gotten gains. The indictment claims the two conspired against a restaurant owner for $20,000; took another $20,000 from a technology company, $25,000 from a strip club; and also were making plans to extort money from a Detroit real estate developer. Bad as the PR hit is for Detroit, it is a positive step for the city of Detroit and the state of Michigan.
JOHN CONYERS ON THE HOT SEAT posted 07.01.09
John Conyers has served in Congress since 1965. His congressional seat is considered untouchable to any challengers. But now Conyers is feeling the heat from his wife’s felony conviction and another pending scandal. Conyers alleged non-role and non-awareness of his wife’s illegal activity just doesn’t pass the smell test. For example, Conyers was adamantly opposed to the notion of a hazardous waste injection well in Romulus in 2003 and 2004. In public hearings he said, “We are trying to keep the God-given resources that this area is blessed with as healthy and as clean as possible.” The well was being pursued by Jim Papas, whose company was to operate the well -- but needed approval from the EPA in order to do so. Why would John Conyers have a change of heart in 2007 and draft a letter to the EPA in support of the hazardous waste injection well? Clearly Mr. Conyers is entitled to change his mind on any issue at any time. But the fact that his wife set up a meeting with Papas and her political advisor Sam Riddle, which resulted in a $20,000 payment to Riddle, is suspect. It’s even more troubling when you consider Riddle’s claim that Monica Conyers demanded $10,000 as a finder’s fee from him. It begs the question…why would John Conyers--who so publicly opposed Papas’ efforts in 2003 and 2004--have a change of heart about the hazardous waste injection well just three years later? Did John Conyers have knowledge of the $10,000 financial transaction to his wife, and did that have anything to do with him changing his mind on this issue? Conyers did release a statement on June 30th, 2009 saying he thought the EPA should reconsider the issue based on his representational duty to his constituents. That statement sounds more like the congressman may be diving for political cover. First Kwame Kilpatrick went down in disgrace, then Monica Conyers. Slowly but surely Detroit is cleaning up its act. Is the powerful John Conyers next?
MONICA CONYERS COULD FACE MORE TROUBLE
posted 06.30.09
Despite a forced resignation from her Detroit City Council seat, becoming a convicted felon, facing five years in prison, and a $250,000 fine, it could get even worse for Monica Conyers. According to an article posted on www.mlive.com, her former aide Sam Riddle claims Conyers drove him to a meeting with Greektown businessman Dimitrios Papas. The meeting generated a $20,000 contract for Riddle, of which Conyers demanded he pay her a $10,000 finder’s fee. Riddle also claims that he drafted a letter in support of Papas, and that the letter was a group effort which included Monica Conyers and her husband, U. S. Congressman John Conyers. In addition, Riddle claims that Monica Conyers brokered many other similar deals on his behalf. There is no evidence that Congressman John Conyers is connected to the allegations that Riddle has asserted.
MONICA CONYERS RESIGNS FROM DETROIT CITY COUNCIL posted 06.30.09
According to the Associated Press, Monica Conyers will resign from the Detroit City Council effective Monday, July 6th. Conyers pleaded guilty to federal bribery charges in relation to the sludge scandal with Houston-based Synagro Technologies and faces up to five years in prison and a fine of $250,000.
She admitted to accepting bribes in exchange for her “yes” vote on Synagro’s lucrative $47 million annual contract with the City of Detroit. Her husband--influential Congressman John Conyers, who serves as Chairman of the powerful House Judiciary Committee--has said he knew nothing of his wife’s involvement with the scandal. According to the Detroit city charter, convicted felons--which Monica Conyers now is--must be removed from office. Had Monica Conyers not resigned, Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox said his office would have started procedures to remove her from office.
DOES CONGRESSMAN JOHN CONYERS NEED INVESTIGATING? posted 06.29.09
Detroit City Councilwoman Monica Conyers has accepted a plea deal and has been convicted on conspiring to commit bribery in the Detroit sludge scandal. She faces five years in prison and a $250,000 fine. At least one former Detroit Free Press columnist is on record suggesting that her husband, 14th District U.S. Congressman John Conyers, should be investigated by the FBI and the Justice Department as well. In 2006 Joel Thurtell wrote an op-ed comparing Conyers to Charles Diggs (who served prison time after ordering one of his aides to work at his family’s funeral parlor). Thurtell claims Conyers has done in essence the same thing. He asserts that Conyers ordered his congressional staff to perform personal work such as chauffeur he and his wife, babysit his children on a full time basis, and tutor Conyer’s oldest son. In a show of support, the 80-year-old Congressman (who was first elected in 1965) received a vote of confidence in his home district following his wife’s conviction. Thurtell has republished the essay which lays out the case against Conyers on his blog. It’s getting lots of buzz. To read it click here: http://joelontheroad.com/?p=2508.
REVISED COBO DEAL CLOSE TO FINAL APPROVAL posted 06.26.09
Desperately needed legislation to renovate and enlarge Cobo Hall (which will allow the venue to keep the vital North American Auto Show) is very close to final approval. A compromise was reached with newly-elected Detroit Mayor Dave Bing, the state legislature, and officials from Wayne, Oakland, and Macomb counties. It was just a few months ago when Council Member Monica Conyers led an effort to withhold Detroit’s support of the plan to regionalize Cobo with area counties and the state of Michigan. Conyers drew fire--and deservedly so--from many who have worked diligently for the last five years on the plan: a plan which includes paying millions for deferred maintenance and enlarging the facility. The new legislation creates an eight-member citizens advisory committee under the auspices it would oversee jobs and contracts related to Cobo, allowing preference for people who live in the three-county Detroit Metro area. Under the plan, the city of Detroit would lease Cobo for 30 years to the five-member regional authority (City of Detroit; Wayne, Oakland, and Macomb counties; and the state of Michigan), who would be responsible for running and renovating the Cobo Convention Center. If for some reason the legislation fails or the city of Detroit does not back it, speculation is the North American Auto Show will move to the Rock Financial Showplace in Novi. Having the plan go through would be a milestone for the city of Detroit, and a signal to the world that Michigan’s most important municipalities can cooperate and keep viable the most important convention center in the state. Way to go Detroit!
FEDS OFFER CONYERS PLEA DEAL – SHE SAYS NO posted 06.17.09
According to the Free Press, Detroit City Councilwoman Monica Conyers has been offered a plea deal in connection with the Synagro Technologies sludge scandal. At the time of this posting, Conyers had not agreed to accept the plea deal. The news comes just one day after Detroit consultant Rayford Jackson and his younger brother admitted to paying thousands of dollars in bribes in exchange for a “yes” vote on a proposed $1.2 billion annual contract with the City of Detroit. Initially Conyers opposed the contract, but then switched her position, making it a 5-4 vote in favor of the contract with Synagro Technologies. Rayford Jackson has vowed not to implicate any one person directly, but only that he engaged in the act of bribery. His younger brother is believed to have linked Conyers to the scandal. Sources close to the investigation also indicate they are questioning Conyers about the time she served as trustee to Detroit’s public pension funds. It seems like Monica is going down the same road as disgraced former Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick -- smothered in scandal. Not even her powerful congressional husband John will be able to save her from this one. For her part, Monica Conyers is not talking to the press, but did make the following statement on her WHPR television show:
“I just want to say that first and foremost publicly that I am a child of God, And that all these things that are going on right now that I believe in my heart that God will deliver me from them. And so I say to all of the people out there if you’re not praying for me, then you’re just adding to the problem. And I would just respectfully ask that you keep your comments to yourselves and if you’re going to speak about someone, speak the truth. If you don’t have the truth to say, then keep your comments to yourself. You can’t comment on me, my husband or my family because you don’t know us. And for those of you who do know us, you know how to speak appropriately about us. And so I just say for all of you who have kept me in your prayers, who continue to lift me up in Jesus’ name every day, I just want to say thank you.”
DETROIT SLUDGE DEAL CONVICTION -- MORE COMING
posted 6-17-09
Detroit business consultant Rayford Jackson has pleaded guilty to bribery for buying a Detroit City Council vote in favor of a $1.2 billion waste disposal contract with Synagro Technologies. In November of 2007 the Detroit City Council approved the deal by a narrow 5-4 vote despite strong objections by neighborhood residents. According to court records, Jackson made four payments to an unidentified Detroit City Council member. The last two payments were for $3000 each; the amount of the first two payments has not been disclosed. Jackson faces up to five years in prison and a fine of $250,000. Jackson’s lawyer, Richard Morgan, said his client will not cooperate with federal authorities in the investigation, and will not identify “Council Member A”. There has been wide speculation and press accounts including in the Detroit Free Press, that "Council Member A" is actually Council President Pro Tem Monica Conyers. It is known that federal investigators have questioned Conyers about the sludge deal, in addition to her former aide and political consultant Sam Riddle and Bernard Kilpatrick (father of former disgraced Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick). Given Jackson’s conviction, it seems a matter of time before Council Member A is identified and arraigned on bribery charges.
ANOTHER TRY FOR COBO posted 05.20.09
Cobo Hall will get another chance at desperately needed rehabilitation and expansion thanks to State Senate Republicans. Majority Leader Mike Bishop,
R-Rochester, helped introduce four bills in the Senate that calls for a $288 million renovation and expansion of Cobo Hall. The push is on before the Detroit Auto Show moves to the Rock Financial Showplace, which is where Oakland County Executive L Brooks Patterson has suggested the auto show could relocate to. In February the Detroit City Council, lead by Monica Conyers, rejected a similar plan 5-3. The vote destroyed four years of painstaking work, negotiation, and cooperation between the City of Detroit, the State of Michigan, along with Wayne, Macomb, and Oakland counties. Detroit Auto Show organizers Doug Fox and Rod Alberts have stated that the 2010 show will be at Cobo Hall, but if needed repairs are not made to the aging convention center, other alternatives will be seriously considered, perhaps as early as 2011. Should the legislation pass, Cobo Hall would be owned and supervised by a regional authority of the aforementioned five stakeholders. Conyers’ objection is that the city would be giving away a precious asset. The problem with her argument is that the asset (Cobo Hall) is an absolute liability; burdened by millions of dollars of deferred maintenance that must be addressed. The city has been an atrocious steward of Cobo Hall, and the proposed plan at least saves the convention center and provides some stability. Like the City of Detroit, and the State of Michigan, Cobo Hall can’t pay its bills -- and unless it is rescued, it will join the fate of the train station. Let’s hope common sense prevails.
DAVE BING WINS DETROIT MAYOR RACE posted 05.06.09
DETROIT – Motor City voters have elected Dave Bing as mayor. He defeated incumbent Ken Cockrel Jr. and will serve through the remainder of 2009, a term that originally belonged to disgraced former mayor Kwame Kilpatrick. Bing, 65, will run again in the regular August 4th nonpartisan primary and the November 4th general election. With all but two of 629 precincts reporting, Bing had 52.3 percent of the votes, verses 47.7 for Cockrel. Cockrel had been promoted to mayor after Kwame Kilpatrick was convicted of perjury. He had been serving as City Council President, which is a post he will now resume. Dave Bing was a stand out Detroit Pistons’ basketball player, is a member of the NBA Hall of Fame, started Bing Steel in 1980, and is founder/owner of The Bing Group. The Bing Group is a manufacturer and supplier to the auto industry with 500 employees.
COBO EXPANSION BLOCKED BY JUDGE posted 04.10.09
DETROIT -- Detroit City Council President Monica Conyers’ efforts to prevent a new regional authority from overseeing, running, and rehabilitating Cobo Hall just got traction. Judge Isidore Torres has blocked the new five-member regional authority from moving forward, and along with it stopped the $288 million upgrade that Cobo desperately needs to remain a viable venue. The judges ruling is a major setback in what has been a long five-year effort to create an agreement deemed favorable to all the stakeholders, which are the three metro counties of Wayne, Macomb, and Oakland, the state of Michigan, and the city of Detroit. Judge Torres has ruled that Detroit Mayor Ken Cockrel’s veto of the city council’s 5-3 vote in opposition of the Cobo deal will not stand, and that he has no such legal authority. Monica Conyers called the decision a victory for the citizens of Detroit. Part of the reason Conyers rejected the regional authority is that city residents and Detroit companies would no longer get first choice for jobs and contracts. It was also suggested the city have more than one vote on the regional authority. Detroit Mayor Ken Cockrel said an appeal will be filed and that the future of the city—as well as the North America Auto Show—is at risk. The North American Auto Show brings in to Metro Detroit an estimated $500 million annually and is Cobo’s highest-profile event. Oakland County Executive L. Brooks Patterson released a statement saying he would no longer negotiate a deal that would be satisfactory to Conyers. He also said Detroit has lost its best chance to secure long-term funding for Cobo Hall, which is burdened by millions
of dollars in deferred maintenance. Patterson suggested it may be time the North American Auto Show move to a location in the suburbs. The Cobo expansion would add 166,000 square feet of new convention space and provide a major face lift to the existing 700,000 square feet of floor space. In the deal, the city of Detroit was to receive $20 million dollars, and would also lose the burdensome operating debt of $13 to $15 million a year.
MIKE ILITCH STANDS UP FOR AUTOMAKERS posted 04.09.09
DETROIT -- In a bold move, Detroit Tigers’ team owner Mike Ilitch has agreed to lend a hand to Detroit’s struggling auto companies. For several years General Motors, Ford, & Chrysler have had a strong advertising presence at Comerica Park, home of the Detroit Tigers. But given the current automotive climate, all three companies were ready to pull the plug on their advertising dollars for Comerica Park for the 2009 season. However, Tigers’ team owner--and one of Detroit’s biggest success stories--Mike Ilitch has said the automakers advertising in Comerica Park will remain for the 2009 season, and that the normal $2 million expenditure will be waived in lieu of what the Big 3 have done for Metro Detroit for so many years. Thanks Mr. Ilitch and GO TIGERS!
WAYNE COUNTY $100 MILLION SHORT posted 4.06.09
DETROIT -- Despite a projected budget deficit of $100 million for the next fiscal year, Wayne County Chairman Robert Ficano has awarded pay raises--ranging from 10 percent to 41 percent for 47 political appointees. That’s a hefty increase in tough times, not to mention in the face of the county’s looming budget deficit. A spokesperson defended the raises by saying they’re a result of increased job responsibilities. The raises were also justified because they came at the recommendation of a consulting firm, which sounds and feels like political cover. Last year Wayne County gave all its non-union employees a four percent raise, which will be spread over four years, to help with increasing health care costs. At the same time the county awarded the identical four percent raise to all of its union employees. The pay increases conflict with what Ficano also recommends: a 20% cost reduction across the board for all county departments. The number of political appointments is largest in Wayne County with 238, Oakland has 22, and Macomb has none. Wayne County is Michigan’s largest populated county with 1.9 millions residents, followed by Oakland with 1.2 million, and Macomb with 830,000. Under the leadership of L. Brooks Patterson Oakland County has been proactive and successful in keeping its costs in line. For example, Oakland County did not give out any raises in 2008, nor will it in 2009. There have been no new full-time hires, and county commissioners have cut their pay by five percent. Despite having its fiscal house in order Patterson continues to be concerned about the auto industry, and has been quoted as saying losing any of the Big 3 would incite a nuclear winter for Metro Detroit. You can learn more by listening to an interview with Oakland County Executive L. Brooks Patterson here on the MIwatchdog.
DETROIT NEWS, FREE PRESS SLASH HOME DELIVERY posted 04.01.09
DETROIT -- The end of an era came to Michigan this week when the state’s two largest newspapers, the Detroit Free Press and the Detroit News, reduced home delivery to just three days a week. For the traditional newspaper readers, it’s very disappointing. The Free Press currently has a 298,243 weekday circulation; the Detroit News has a 178,280 weekday circulation. Starting this week the papers will only be delivered Thursday, Friday, and Sunday -- the biggest ad days of the week. On-line subscribers can view the exact print version any day, and there is free content available at www.freep.com and www.detnews.com. The newspaper industry is facing falling subscriptions and shrinking ad revenue. More than 80 newspapers in small markets have reduced their publishing to just one day a week, while some large papers have shut down entirely, including the Rocky Mountain News in Denver. The Detroit Media Partnership, which runs the business side of the Detroit News and Free Press, has announced it will test 100 e-reader devices by summer. The e-reader is a thin, nine-ounce electronic slate which allows the user to read the print edition of the paper. A spokesperson has said it’s feasible that 20 to 30,000 e-readers could be available in a very short time frame.
NEW MOTOWN CURRENCY: DETROIT CHEERS posted 03.24.09
DETROIT --Three Detroit businessmen have decided to create a new local currency designed to keep dollars in Metro Detroit. Called Detroit Cheers, the currency will be available in $3 denominations, and will be backed by 3000 U.S. dollars placed in an escrow account. The currency is the brainchild of Detroit businessman Jerry Belanger and two other partners, both of whom own businesses in downtown Detroit. A small number of businesses have agreed to accept Detroit Cheers including a furniture design center (Dormouse), an animal day care center, a graphics designer, a carpenter, and several bars and restaurants. During the Great Depression thousands of communities created local currency know as provincial dollars. Traverse City is the only other Michigan community that has its own local currency, which is called Bay Bucks. According to Stephanie Mills, one of the creators of the currency, there are 13,000 Bay Bucks in circulation, and they are currently accepted at 59 Traverse City area businesses. More information is available at www.baybucks.org. The largest local currency in the U. S. is Berkshares, started three years ago in Southern Massachusetts. There are currently two million Berkshares in circulation. Legal scholars say local currencies are legal, so long as they don’t resemble federally-issued money.
MAYOR FIGHTS FOR COBO PLAN posted 03.05.09
Detroit Mayor Ken Cockrel has vetoed the City Council’s vote to stop the Cobo Hall expansion project. The opposing side, lead by Council President Monica Conyers, has vowed to take the mayor to court, claiming that he has no such veto powers. The $288 million expansion project has already been approved by the state as well as Wayne, Oakland, and Macomb counties. The plan calls for a five-member board to own and operate the facility with appointees from the governor, the city of Detroit, and Wayne, Oakland, and Macomb counties. Years in the making, the project is considered essential for bringing Cobo up-to-speed, not only in square footage, but also mechanically. Officials from the Michigan State Chamber and the Detroit Regional Chamber are strong supporters. The five Detroit City Council members, who voted against the Cobo expansion project, justify their vote by saying the city is giving up too much including control of the facility. The Detroit City Council lost control of Cobo from both a financial and stewardship perspective years ago. It would be a good thing if the new five-member board took over the facility; as it would have a much better chance to survive. Cobo needs to be rehabbed from years of mismanagement. The city of Detroit needs a vibrant and healthy Cobo, and so too does the state of Michigan.
BING VS. COCKREL FOR DETROIT MAYOR posted 02.25.09
It appears it will be Detroit businessman and former Detroit Pistons’ star Dave Bing facing off against current mayor Ken Cockrel in a May 5th election for the Detroit mayoral position. With over 90% of precincts reporting, Bing had 29% of the vote, followed by Ken Cockrel with 27%, and Deputy Mayor Freman Hendrix with 23%. When it’s all said and done, Detroit voters will have gone to the polls four times this year to elect their new mayor. It started with the February 24th primary, followed by the May 5th special election, then the August primary, and ending in November with an election that will finally determine a Detroit mayor that will serve a full term…at least conceptually. The unusual series of elections was triggered by disgraced former Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick being forced out of office and serving jail time for perjury. As expected, the May 24th primary had a very low voter turnout.
DETROIT COUNCIL NIXES COBO PLAN posted 02.25.09
In a bitterly disappointing 5-3 vote, the Detroit City Council has said “no” to a much-needed plan to expand and renovate Cobo Hall. The vote sabotages five years of negotiations and hours of pain staking work to create a renovation plan that was agreeable and had already been approved by the state legislature, and by officials in Wayne, Oakland, and Macomb counties. Oakland County Executive L. Brooks Patterson had signed off on the plan, and said he felt the plan was reasonable and fair to all stakeholders. Cobo Hall is in major need of renovation and has $250 million in deferred maintenance that desperately needs to be addressed. Cobo is at risk of losing the Detroit International Auto Show, a crucial event that generates millions of dollars for the economy and provides 16,000 jobs. Some foreign car companies have already pulled out of the Detroit Auto Show, and more are threatening to leave unless something is done to upgrade Cobo. The city council members that voted against the Cobo expansion project include Alberta Tinsley-Talabi, Council President Monica Conyers, President Pro Tem JoAnn Watson, and Councilwomen Barbara Rose-Collins and Martha Reeves. Detroit Mayor Ken Cockrel blasted the five members that voted against the agreement and said he will pursue other avenues to fund the project including a possible transfer of ownership of Cobo away from the city to a regional authority.
KWAME, DAD, & CONYERS NAMED IN FBI BRIBERY PROBE posted 01.28.09
Disgraced former Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick, his father Bernard, and Council President Moncia Conyers have been named in the Synagro Technologies sludge scandal. The case involves former Synagro vice president James Rosendall, who bribed city officials with cash in exchange for Detroit agreeing to an annual $47 million sludge contract with his employer. Rosendall has pleaded guilty to bribery conspiracy charges and under a plea agreement he faces up to 11 months in prison. Rosendall began cooperating with the FBI in January of 2008, helping make videotapes of city officials and others. Federal court documents identify Kwame Kilpatrick as “City official A,” and his father Bernard Kilpatrick as “Relative of City Official A.” The documents show “Relative of Official A” received $25,000 from 2004 to 2008 for helping facilitate contracts. Plea documents also reveal that from 2001 to 2008 Rosendall contributed $200,000 to non-profits, political action committees, and campaign funds linked with “City Official A.” In a local radio interview, Detroit Prosecutor Kim Worthy said the wide-ranging federal probe will make the mayor’s text scandal conviction seem minor; but on the positive side, it will also clean up the city.
SLUDGE DEAL GETS STINKY posted 01.27.09
James R. Rosendall, a former vice president of Synagro Technologies, has admitted to wrongdoing in relation to the City of Detroit agreeing to a $47 million contract. Rosendall’s admission in court directly implicates for the first time Detroit city officials -- though none have been named specifically. In a plea document, the Grand Rapids businessman and former Synagro executive admitted to conspiring with six people, including three members of the Kilpatrick administration, a relative of an administration official, city council member, and an intermediary who funneled money to the counsel member. Plea documents also show Rosendall began making campaign contributions to “City Official A” in 2001, meeting with the official in Lansing. From 2001 to 2008, the document says Rosendall contributed around $200,000 to non-profits, political action committees, and campaign funds linked with “City Official A.” While Kwame Kilpatrick is not specifically named, according the press accounts in the Detroit Free Press, there are many parallels between the former mayor and “City Official A.” Under terms of the felony plea agreement Rosendall agreed to fully cooperate and is facing an 11 month maximum jail term, followed by probation.
NEW DETROIT-TO-WINDSOR BRIDGE APPROVED posted 01.15.09
In what could be a real economic boost to Metro Detroit, The U. S. Department of Transportation has given final environmental approval to build the Detroit River International Crossing -- a new bridge between Detroit and Windsor. Technically referred to as “record of decision” the approval means Michigan officials can acquire and begin planning construction of the new bridge, which will be built about a mile downriver from the Ambassador Bridge. The project still faces challenges from some state legislators and from Warren-based businessman Manuel Matty Moroun, owner of the Ambassador Bridge. Moroun has vowed to pursue litigation in order to stop the project. He intends to build a second bridge close right next to the Ambassador, which would compete with the new Detroit River International Crossing, or the DRIC project. |
MIDWEST OCTOBER HOME SALES EXPLODE BY 26%
posted 11.24.09
Existing home sales in the Midwest surged in October by 26%, the highest growth rate in 2-½ years. In fact, by region the Midwest lead the nation with the highest growth percentage. The market was aided as buyers sought to beat the initial deadline (November 30th) of an $8000 tax credit for first-time home buyers. Last month lawmakers extended the tax credit through April 2010. In Detroit October home sales increased by 8 percent and the median home sale price rose 6 percent to $69,900. The Midwest market with the highest growth was Des Moines, Iowa, where sales jumped 39 percent, though the median sale price did fall 5 percent to $144,000. Nationally October home sales grew by 21 percent, and the median sale price fell by 7 percent to $173,100. The figures were released by the National Association of Realtors.
SUPPLY OF HOMES FOR SALE FALLS IN METRO DETROIT
posted 11.12.09
In what could be a sign of stability, the number of homes for sale in the five-county area of Metro Detroit has fallen appreciably. Last year in the 3rd quarter the region had a 13.4 month supply of houses on the market. For the 3rd quarter in 2009, that number has decreased to an 8.4 month supply. In the last year Metro Detroit homes fell in value by 22 percent. The five counties included in the analysis include Wayne, Macomb, Oakland, Washtenaw, and Livingston.
METRO DETROIT HOME SALES UP 22.4% posted 08.19.09
DETROIT -- Amid the tough times in the auto industry, a city that is $275 million in the red, and a school system on life support, Metro Detroit home sales jumped 22.4 percent in July. Granted the median sale price in all three metro counties has fallen precipitously in the last twelve months, (Wayne down 18 percent, Oakland down 33.3 percent, Macomb down 35.1 percent) but the fact that real estate sales is on the up-tick is a very positive sign. Foreclosed homes continue to be part of the landscape as investors probe the market seeking a bargain. It would be troubling if values were down and sales were flat or down, which would mean the average sale price would continue to slide until buyers enter the market. The numbers mean real estate in Metro Detroit is bouncing along the bottom. Macomb County lead the July-to-July sales boost, up 29 percent, while Wayne County increased 23.2 percent, and Oakland was up 17.4 percent.
DETROIT REAL ESTATE IS SELLING posted 05.11.09
DETROIT -- Amidst the meltdown of the auto industry, real estate--particularly houses under $100,000--is selling in Metro Detroit. The supply of homes in that price range is down 50 percent from one year ago. In March 2008 there was an 11.7 month supply of homes on the market for under $100,000. However by March 2009 that number had shrunk to a 5.2 month supply. That’s great news for Detroit and Michigan’s beleaguered real estate industry. Those purchasing homes in Metro Detroit are getting an outstanding value for their investment. In just the last year alone (through February 2009) prices have fallen 23 percent in Metro Detroit, that according to Case Shiller Home Price Index (www.macromarkets.com). The real estate market is benefiting from the Recovery and Reinvestment Act which provides an $8000 tax credit for first time home buyers; that amount does not have to be paid back. A first time home buyer is defined as a person or couple who has not owned a home for the past three years. The home must also be purchased before December 31, 2009 – and must be the buyer’s primary residence for 36 months or the credit must be repaid. Income limits are $75,000 for individuals and $150,000 for couples. For more information about the $8000 dollar credit for first-time home buyers we recommend this website: www.ehow.com.
FORECLOSURES DOWN IN WAYNE COUNTY posted 04.14.09
DETROIT -- There are some interesting trends in Metro Detroit, the state’s largest real estate market. According to RealtyTrac, on a February year-to-year comparison home foreclosures in Wayne County are down 29 percent, but are up in Oakland and Macomb 25 and 62 percent, respectively. That would indicate the foreclosures are slowing in the core urban center, but growing in the suburban areas. The same trends have also been seen in other Midwest markets like Chicago and Cleveland. Values are now down to mid-1990 levels and that has brought out the buyers, several buyers in Metro Detroit’s case, from all over the world. The supply of foreclosures has fueled the market with prospective investors and they are buying, thank goodness. From an economic standpoint that’s a very positive development. It’s a dynamic market outcome and demonstrates signs of life for Michigan’s real estate market. But it’s not all rosy for the investor. Banks are overwhelmed with foreclosures and there is significantly more paperwork involved. The process can be slow moving and includes several hoops to jump through. Lower home prices means more affordability for buyers. According to an article in the Detroit News, a high-end luxury home in Grosse Pointe (just off Lake Shore Drive, with a view of Lake St. Clair) once valued at $1.2 million is now on market for roughly half that amount. Bottom line: now is a good time to buy real estate in Michigan.
REAL ESTATE INVESTORS INVADE DETROIT posted 03.09.09
DETROIT -- Motor City real estate values are attracting investors from around the world including Europe and Australia. The Metro Detroit market has 1800 homes for sale for under $10,000 or less, which is driving the interest of the real estate speculators. The average sale price of a home in Detroit in 2008 was $8,692, and has gone even lower for 2009, edging down to $6,605. In 2003 the average sales price was $46,502. The Motor City has the lowest ownership rate for single family detached homes in the country. How it will all shake out remains to be seen, but one investor suggests doing the math. He can buy a house for $20,000 and rent it out for $900 a month. Many are buying in bulk. An investor for the U.K. recently bought 30 homes in one day.
SAGINAW HOUSE SELLS FOR $1.75 posted 10.02.08
An abandoned home at 1606 Perkins Street in Saginaw was put up for sale and sold on E-Bay for $1.75. It generated eight bids and was sold to 30 year old Joann Smith of Chicago. Smith has no plans to move to Saginaw and wants to sell the house. With back taxes and trash/weed pick up, the total cost will be around $850. In 1999 the house sold for $2000; December 2006 it was purchased for $400; January 2007 for $10 and $26 in January 2008.
METRO REAL ESTATE UP 20% posted 8.15.08
July home sales in Metro Detroit were up 20% in July compared to last year. Meanwhile foreclosures fell by 17% in the four-county Metro area including
Wayne,
Macomb,
Oakland, and
Livingston
Counties. A total of 4,245 homes were sold in July of this year, compared to 3,538 sold in the same month last year. It was the seventh consecutive month that sales were up in Metro Detroit from a year ago. Good news, although experts caution the region remains battered and bruised by the downturn in the automotive industry.
Detroit is the only major metro market in the country where home prices have fallen below where they were in 2000.
GRAND
TRAVERSE
COUNTY #1 FOR NEW RESIDENTS posted 8.12.08
According to new census data, from 2006 to 2007, the
Michigan county with the largest growth by raw numbers is
Grand
Traverse
County in
Northwest Lower Michigan. This is based on people moving into the county, and not accounting for births and deaths.
Grand
Traverse
County had a net increase of 646 residents moving to the area, the largest in the state. Only ten of
Michigan's 83 counties had positive population growth; all others lost residents. In
West Michigan,
Kent
County lost 1656 residents and
Montcalm
County lost 541 residents. Experts say among the reasons for
Traverse City bucking the trend are the area's natural beauty, clean lakes, plentiful cultural opportunities, and vibrant economy. According to the
University of
Michigan's Institute and Industrial Relations, the population of
Grand
Traverse
County which is now 86,384 will grow to 98,505 by 2020.
HOME SALES IN METRO DETROIT UP 13.4% posted 6.19.08
Buyers looking for bargains in the state's largest real estate market are speaking with their dollars and have driven up home sales in May by 13.4%. This is the fifth consecutive month that Metro Detroit home sales were up compared to the same month last year. The large number of foreclosed homes has driven the market up and those sales are forcing traditional sellers to lower their prices too, bringing even more buyers to the market.
|
|
BIG NATURAL GAS DISCOVERY IN MICHIGAN?
posted 5.5.10
This past winter a new natural gas well was drilled in Missaukee County, and discovered was a possible Utica shale formation. Utica shale has yielded substantial production in other states, but never before in Michigan. If Michigan does have a significant Utica shale deposit, as some experts believe, it will mean a substantial return of the oil and gas industry in the state, and a boon for landowners with mineral rights. At a recent Lansing auction for mineral rights on state land, prices went through the roof. For example, in 2008 prices topped out at $200 an acre, but the 2010 auction drew prices as high as $5500 per acre (that price was paid for a parcel in Charlevoix County). The state’s Natural Resources Trust Fund—the beneficiary of the proceeds—uses the funds to purchase recreational and environmentally sensitive property. The 2010 auction drew a sizeable sum, over $140 million for the Michigan Natural Resources Trust Fund. Gee…too bad that money can’t be diverted to the state’s general fund, which is short $1800 million ($1.8 billion) for fiscal 2011.
There are some oil and gas speculators who feel the Michigan 2010 auction prices were exorbitant, especially when factoring in that the price of natural gas has fallen 50 percent in the last two years. Part of the answer will be the future demand for natural gas. There are many influential people, including oil tycoon T. Boone Pickens, who are calling for a move to natural gas, and away from traditional gasoline. The MIwatchDog emphatically concurs. Moving away from our dependence on foreign oil and employing more Americans to harvest North America’s plentiful natural gas supply is smart. The biggest challenge is a transition to automobiles that burn natural gas. Currently there is only one vehicle available in the United States that burns natural gas: the Honda Civic GX. There is also a major problem with filling up natural gas-powered vehicles, as only around 800 gas stations nationwide sell natural gas. Natural gas emits no greenhouse gases, is not combustible, and is readily available in North America. It helps the environment, lessens our dependence on foreign oil, and will employ more Americans. Long term natural gas utilization makes sense for the country, and could be a substantial economic boost for the Michigan.
(sources: Detroit Free Press, MIwatchDog)
SUPREMES DIVE FOR COVER ON ASIAN CARP (again)
posted 04.27.10
For a third and presumably final time, the U.S. Supreme Court has refused a request to prevent invasive Asian carp from entering the Great Lakes. The court gave no explanation for its decision. Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox had petitioned the high court to close Chicago area shipping locks, which biologists say would stop the invasion. It’s a devastating decision for Michigan and the Great Lakes eco-system. The ravenous carp could starve out native fish from their food supply, especially salmon and walleye. The only remedy left is the White House and, like the Supreme Court, the President has ducked the issue, and most speculate Obama will not turn on his home state. Illinois state officials strongly oppose closing the canal locks, as permanently closing the canals would wreak havoc with Midwest shipping and cost billions in new infrastructure to replace them. The fate of the Great Lakes now lies with the President. In the balance is Michigan’s $7 billion fishing industry and the serenity of the Great Lakes. The next step will likely be filing suit in federal district court, but time is not on Michigan’s side. That could take up to two months, and the Asian Carp are just 25 miles from Lake Michigan, ostensibly being held back by an electronic barrier. But biologists have already detected Asian carp DNA past the barrier and even in Lake Michigan, but no fish have been found…at least not yet. Asian carp can grow to four feet long and 100 pounds, a very dangerous threat to the Great Lakes. Startled by the sound of motors the pesky fish is also known for jumping out of the water and sometimes landing on the boat, endangering everyone on board. The MIwatchDog encourages all Michiganders and Great Lakes lovers to get involved in the Asian carp crisis. To join the fight click on http://www.stopasiancarp.com/.
(sources: Associated Press, MIwatchDog)
SUPREME COURT WILL RECONSIDER ACTION ON ASIAN CARP posted 03.16.10
The U.S. Supreme Court will reconsider closing some Chicago canal locks in order to prevent the invasion of Asian carp into the Great Lakes. In January Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox sought and was not granted a temporary request to close the Chicago area canal locks. But now the court has agreed to hear a new plea for a preliminary injunction to close the locks in question. The ecological calamity of the Asian carp invading the Great Lakes is beyond measure. Mike Cox will also argue that Illinois has exaggerated the economic costs and fallout of closing the locks. In addition to the environmental damage, Asian carp also threaten Michigan’s $9 billion boating industry and $7 billion fishing industry. The overall economic fallout is incalculable and could last for years. If allowed to get into Lake Michigan, experts say the invasive species could be slightly controlled but never eradicated. Michigan needs a remedy. The Asian carp was first introduced into ponds in the Deep South to control underwater weeds. During major flood events the carp found their way into the Mississippi River and have been swimming upstream ever since -- that was 15 years ago and 1000 miles later. The invasive species can grow up to 100 pounds and four feet long. They become easily stirred at the sound of boat motors and have been known to fly out of the water and into the watercraft, sometimes striking people on board. The Attorney General has set up a website to help prevent Asian carp from invading the Great Lakes: http://www.stopasiancarp.com.
SAGINAW BAY REGION WINDIEST IN THE STATE posted 01.28.10
According to the Michigan Public Service Commission, the Saginaw Bay region is the windiest in the state. That would include the five counties that border Saginaw Bay from the tip of the thumb to just north of Bay City. Saginaw, Bay, Tuscola, Huron, and Sanilac counties have been designated as a ‘primary wind energy zone’ by the Michigan Public Service Commission. Parts of Allegan County, which borders Lake Michigan, were also given the designation. The announcement is expected to expedite transmission projects needed to move the wind energy onto the electric grid. The MPSC recommended the Michigan House and Senate work with local zoning and planning officials for decisions on setbacks and noise levels generated from large wind turbines. Setting those negatives aside, wind farms would provide some economic stimulus for the Saginaw Bay region. The difficulty is what little capacity wind turbines deliver; three megawatts a day per turbine would be very generous. Contrast that with the new cleaner-coal plant Consumers Energy hopes to build in Hampton Township near Bay City. The new cleaner-coal plant at the Karn-Weadock facility will deliver 800 megawatts a day, and operate with improved emissions over older clean coal plants -- an improvement of 80 percent.
(Sources: Huron County, Saginaw News, MIwatchDog.com)
WHITE HOUSE WILL HOLD ASIAN CARP SUMMIT posted 01.21.10
A top advisor to President Barack Obama will convene a meeting with governors of Great Lakes states regarding the threat of Asian Carp entering Lake Michigan. Nancy Sutley, president of the Council on Environmental Quality, says there will be a meeting the first week in February in either Washington D.C. or somewhere in the Midwest. In a story posted yesterday on the MIWatchDog.com, the Army Corps of Engineers told reporters that tests show evidence of Asian Carp DNA in Lake Michigan near Chicago. Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm has been pushing for White House intervention especially after the U.S. Supreme Court refused to issue an emergency order to close all Illinois Rivers and waterways that connect to Lake Michigan.
ASIAN CARP VIRTUALLY IN LAKE MICHIGAN posted 01.20.10
The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers have found DNA samples in Calumet Harbor, above the breakwater north of Chicago. According to Major John Peabody, who spoke with reporters from a conference call, “That is Lake Michigan.” No fish were found but Peabody says DNA samples act as an early warning device. The news comes just hours after the U.S. Supreme Court refused to intervene and issue an emergency order to close all Illinois locks and rivers that connect to Lake Michigan, an appeal sought by Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox. The Asian carp threaten Michigan’s $7 billion annual fishing industry, not to mention the ecosystem of the Great Lakes. The fish can reach up to four feet in length and consume 40 percent of their body weight daily. When boaters speed by it is not uncommon for the Asian carp to leap from the water and hit the boat or passengers. Michigan Governor Jennifer Granholm and Wisconsin Governor James Doyle are calling for a White House meeting on the issue. Chicago and Illinois officials assert they are concerned about the sizable cost of closing off cargo shipping between the Illinois River system and Lake Michigan. The issue is ratcheting up pressure between Illinois and neighboring Great Lakes states. It has also placed President Obama in the middle of defending his home state versus environmentalists, normally a strong political ally of the administration.
(source: Associated Press)
JUDGE APPROVES U.P. NICKEL AND COPPER MINE
posted 01.15.10
An administrative law judge has given approval for a new nickel and copper mine in the Upper Peninsula. In a lengthy hearing, the judge reviewed Department of Environmental Quality permits that were originally granted in 2007. Specifically the permits allow the mine to be built and to discharge treated wastewater underground. The mine will be located in the Yellow Dog Plains region of Marquette County, and will be operated by Kennecott Eagle Minerals. Kennecott must still acquire a groundwater permit from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, which the company hopes to obtain this year. The mine will employ 500 contractors during the construction phase and 200 full-time workers during operations. Environmental groups vow to fight the construction of the mine, insisting it will pollute streams that feed Lake Superior and will also threaten the rare coaster brook trout. For more information on Kennecott,
click here.
(source: Mlive.com)
ASIAN CARP GETTING CLOSER TO LAKE MICHIGAN
posted 01.13.10
Federal officials have found evidence of Asian carp DNA near the Wilmette Pumping Station, north of downtown Chicago. That is the closest the invasive species has gotten to the Great Lakes. The pumping station, which pumps water into the Chicago River, is located next to Lake Michigan. This news was announced at a briefing hosted by Illinois U.S. Senator Dick Durbin at Shedd Aquarium in Chicago. Also attending the meeting was the Army Corps of Engineers who are charged with operating an electric barrier in the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal, designed to keep carp out of Lake Michigan. Many Michigan officials are deeply concerned. Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox has filed suit with the U.S. Supreme Court to close off the Chicago locks and waterways that lead to Lake Michigan. Four other Great Lake states and Ontario have joined the effort, which is opposed by the state of Illinois and the Obama administration. The Supreme Court is expected to go into closed conference on January 15th to consider Michigan’s request for a preliminary injunction to close the locks.
(Source: Detroit Free Press)
DEQ APPROVES PERMIT FOR NEW CLEANER COAL PLANT
posted 12.30.09
Michigan’s Department of Environmental Quality has approved an air permit for a new coal-fired electric generating plant in Hampton Township, near Bay City. It’s another step in a long series of tasks, events, and procedures Consumers Energy has made to get the plant built and on the power grid. But resistance has been strong from environmental groups like the Sierra Club, among others. Governor Granholm has said she wants to ‘slow down’ the process. President Obama campaigned against the concept of building new coal-fired power plants in the United States. The proposed cleaner coal-fired power plant, which will be part of the Karn-Weadock Energy Complex in Hampton Township, will generate an impressive 830 megawatts of power every day. Part of the permit with the DEA requires Consumers Energy to close seven older coal-fired power plants in Michigan. That will remove 950 megawatts of power off the grid…but it will significantly reduce pollution and emissions. What specific plants would be shut down has not been disclosed. DEQ spokesperson Robert McCann confirmed that replacing older, antiquated coal-fired plants will substantially decrease emissions – and the average age of Michigan’s fleet of 17 coal-fired power plants is 50 years. Consumers Energy estimates the new plant commensurate—in addition to shutting down seven older plants—will reduce sulfur dioxide by 91 percent, nitrogen oxides by 83 percent, and mercury by 81 percent. The company must still apply for a certificate of necessity with the Michigan Public Service Commission, which it plans on doing next year. If everything is approved and no oppositional forces delay the process, construction will begin in 2012, and will be completed in 2017. Constructing the facility will provide 1800 jobs and once in operation will generate 100 permanent jobs. Consumers Energy says the total cost of the project is $2 billion. For comparison sake, the average wind turbine generates 2 megawatts of energy per day. That means it would take 417 wind turbines to equal the energy generated by the new cleaner coal plant in Hampton Township.
(Sources: MIwatchdog, Consumers Energy, Detroit Free Press)
WILL MI EXPLODE WITH SOLAR ENERGY? posted 12.23.09
According to Mark Hagerty--President of Michigan Solar Solutions, located in Commerce Township near Bay City--the state is headed for an explosion in the solar industry. Hagerty suggests many people think solar isn’t effective in Michigan due to cold temperatures and the lack of sunshine (when compared to places like Florida and Arizona). However, according to Michigan Solar Solutions’ website Michigan has an average of 4.2 hours of peak sunlight per day, compared to Florida’s five hours. Hagerty also says solar panels are less efficient the hotter they get and actually produce more power when it gets colder. Although the Southwest gets more hours of sun, the panels produce less voltage per peak hour due to the intense heat. Consumers Energy and DTE Energy are offering incentives for renewable energy.
MI AG MIKE COX SUES TO KEEP CARP OUT posted 12.22.09
Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox has followed through on his warning to file suit in U.S. Supreme Court to keep the invasive Asian carp out of Lake Michigan. In a December 21st announcement Cox named the state of Illinois, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, and the Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago in the lawsuit. The lawsuit is being backed by several groups including the National Wildlife Federation. It calls for the following measures:
• Closure of the O'Brien Lock and Dam and the Chicago Controlling Works.
• Operation of sluice gates at Wilmette Pumping Station, the O'Brien Lock and Dam, and the Chicago Controlling Works to keep the carp at bay.
• Construction of new barriers to prevent the carp from being flooded out of the Des Plaines River and into the Chicago Sanitary and Shipping Canal.
• A study of the Chicago waterway system to better understand the number of carp, their location, and how best to deal with them.
Illinois officials have been battling the Asian carp through various means including the use of an electric fence and poisoning a 5.7-mile stretch of the Chicago Sanitary and Ship canal. The federal government has also joined the effort by allocating $13 million to prevent the Asian carp from entering the Great Lakes. Attorney General Mike Cox hopes the Supreme Court will permit some injunctive action before the end of the December.
MI POWER PLANT WILL BURN TIRES FOR ENERGY
posted 12.21.09
What to do with discarded tires has been a problem for years. Michigan South Central Power in partnership with Dayton, Ohio-based Symbiotic Energy is developing a process that will pulverize or burn tires to generate power. It is hoped three million tires a year will be burned at the Litchfield power plant, which currently creates energy from coal. The Litchfield facility supplies energy for Marshall, Hillsdale, Clinton, Coldwater, and Union City. The process itself is called “fractionation”, which extracts various gases, ash, and steel from the tire. The resulting exhaust created from the plant’s boiler is what actually generates the power. Burning tires will displace 20 percent of the coal burning at the Litchfield plant, and will add 12 new jobs. The total cost of the project is estimated at $5 million, largely paid for by Symbiotic Energy.
WIND FARM ALONG LAKE MICHIGAN? posted 12.16.09
SCOTTVILLE -- Norwegian wind development company Havgul Clean Energy AS is considering building a mammoth utility-scale wind farm two miles in from the Lake Michigan shoreline. Aegir Offshore Wind Farm would encompass 100 square miles and be located near Pentwater, north of Silver State Park in Oceana County running north into Mason County. A total of 100 to 200 turbines are being proposed. The $3 billion project would be built in conjunction with Minnesota-based Scandia Wind Offshore and would take 5 to 10 years to complete. The turbines would be 300 to 450 feet high. The development companies held a public meeting in Scottville to introduce the project which was overwhelmingly rejected by the 150 people who attended. Citizens cited noise, light-flicker, a drop in property values, and changing the view from the Lake Michigan shoreline as reasons to oppose the project. The two development companies want to gauge public opinion before moving forward with extensive and multiple public agency approvals from the federal, state, and local government, which is projected to cost $10 million. Project Manager Harald Dridal said thousands of jobs would be created in the five to seven year construction phase; while the operation of the wind farm would create 100 to 200 permanent jobs. Dridal also claimed the winds north of Silver Lake State Park are some of the best in the United States. Developers will hold another public meeting in Oceana County next month.
FEDS JOIN FIGHT TO KEEP ASIAN CARP OUT OF LAKE MICHIGAN posted 12.15.09
Federal officials have announced they will use $13 million from the Great Lakes restoration funds to step up the effort to prevent Asian carp from entering Lake Michigan. The money will be spent on engineering projects to prevent the carp from slipping into Lake Michigan near Chicago. Officials plan on closing conduits and shoring up low-lying land between the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal. Meantime the Michigan Attorney General office is preparing a lawsuit demanding a temporary closure of the shipping locks on the canal. Closure of the canal is strongly opposed by tug and barge companies that haul tons of iron ore and coal on the waterway. Asian carp can grow to 100 pounds and four feet long. The ravenous fish is a huge threat to Michigan’s $7 billion fishing industry and would wreak havoc in the Great Lakes ecosystem.
AG MIKE COX THREATENS LAWSUIT IF CARP INVADE GREAT LAKES posted 12.03.09
LOCKPORT, ILLINOIS -- Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox has sent a letter to several Illinois officials threatening legal action should Asian carp invade Lake Michigan. The Asian carp, which can grow up to four feet long, would wreak havoc in the Great Lakes ecosystem. Arkansas catfish farmers imported the fish in the 1970’s to remove algae from their ponds, but during the floods of the 1990’s the carp escaped to local waterways in the Mississippi River basin. The Asian carp have been working their way northward ever since. Now the invasive species has made it to Lockport, Illinois, just south of Chicago and only seven miles from Lake Michigan. Officials in Illinois have been waging war against the carp. The weapons they have used include an electric fence and poison. Ridding them is a massive effort, and the largest fish kill in Illinois history. The poison Rotenone was interspersed along a 5.7-mile stretch of the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal. Precautions are also being made in the event the Asian carp does invade Lake Michigan. A specialized poison pill the size of a grain of sand nicknamed BioBullets is being developed by private companies and government agencies. The poison pill would be targeted to the carp, sparing other species. Researchers are also testing bubble curtains, a wall of live bubbles that would repel the carp, in addition to steady streams of noise that bothers fish.
COUGAR TRACKS CONFIRMED IN U.P. posted 11.05.09
For years the Michigan Wildlife Conservancy (a private organization) and the DNR have disagreed about the existence of cougars or mountain lions in the state. The Conservancy claims there have been 36 documented cases of cougar evidence from both Michigan peninsulas. The DNR’s long-held position is that there may be a few cougars in Michigan, but they are likely former pets released into the wild or loners that have drifted into Michigan from established populations from Western states. The DNR does not believe there is a breeding pair in Michigan. However the evidence of cougars in Michigan continues to pile up. Last month a trail camera in eastern Chippewa County took a shot of a cougar, which was verified by the DNR. In the last two weeks there have been two sets of cougar tracks, also confirmed by the DNR, near the village of DeTour and in Schoolcraft County. The cats--which are native to Michigan--were believed to have been wiped out in the early part of the 20th century.
GREAT LAKES CLEANUP WILL TAKE 77 YEARS posted 09.16.09
According to a federal report, at the current pace cleaning up polluted sites in the Great Lakes will take 77 years. The Environmental Protection Agency identified several highly contaminated spots twenty years ago, but the full extent of the problem has not been accurately ascertained. 43 areas were identified: 26 in the United States, 12 in Canada, and five that straddle the border. Since the clean up effort began three sites have been removed from the polluted list: two in Canada and one in the United States, the Oswego River in New York. One of the primary goals of the restoration plan is the removal of toxic sediment in Great Lakes bottomlands including mercury, PCBs, and heavy metal wastes. According to state officials there are 76 million cubic yards of contaminated sediment waste that must be addressed. In 2005, the $20 billion Great Lakes Restoration Plan was established by the federal government and non-profit groups. President Obama has pledged $5 billion toward the plan including $475 million in the federal 2010 budget. States and local governments are expected to contribute another $1.2 billion.
MICHIGAN GETS $32.8 MIL FOR ENERGY PROGRAM:
WHAT A WASTE! posted 06.23.09
The U.S. Department of Energy is doling out some of the $787 billion federal stimulus money, and Michigan just got a $32.8 million chunk, which will be utilized to reduce energy use in public buildings. The announcement was made by U.S. Energy Secretary Steven Chu, and is part of the $82 million Michigan expects to receive for its energy program through the Recovery Act. The money is also targeted to create markets for renewable energy and help establish green communities. Though well-intentioned, the funding is economically flawed and in the end will do little to further Michigan’s energy policy. First of all, it’s a little ridiculous for the federal government to provide dollars for a state to develop their energy policy when there is no federal energy policy that effectively deals with the problem. That lack of a clear federal policy dates back to the late 1970’s – and our country has steadily increased its reliance on foreign oil ever since. Reducing energy costs in public buildings is simply not worth the effort, and economically is laughable. The stewards of those public buildings should pursue lowering energy costs on their own and through their own resources, not by a cash windfall from the feds -- which will more likely resemble a grab bag of who gets the money. Regarding renewable energy--specifically wind and solar--it’s a proven fact that capturing, storing, and delivering renewable energy has a two to three times cost factor when compared to clean coal and other mainstream energy sources. As Kelly Farr, Consumers Energy Public Affairs Director, pointed out in an audio interview posted here on the MIwatchdog, wind and solar energy ARE NOT FREE. Clearly some research dollars should be devoted to renewables, and as the technology improves practicality will increase. At this point, however, those precious dollars would be better served if invested in proven and reliable energy facilities such as clean coal and nuclear. That will help ensure reasonable energy costs for years to come. As far as global warming and greenhouse gases are concerned, developing a natural gas infrastructure where more gas stations would sell CNG (Compressed Natural Gas) would be extremely beneficial. Over the long haul it could be transformational for Michigan and eventually the entire country. Compressed Natural Gas, which is burned in NGV (natural gas ve | |